Optimal Route Design and Operational Efficiency Analysis of Wind-Assisted Propulsion Ships Using Graph Networks

Jinkyu Kim, Hyeong-Tak Lee, Wook Hyun Кwon, Kuiming Li, Yuri Seo, Ik-Soon ChoKorea 2025 · DOI

Abstract: This study focuses on exploring the optimal routes for Wind-Assisted Propulsion Ship (WAPS), targeting enhanced fuel efficiency and greenhouse gas reduction in maritime operations, using a 17K DWT bulk carrier equipped with a 2.4MW dual-fuel engine and four medium-sized rotor-sails as auxiliary propulsion devices. The research assesses the efficiency of these routes by comparing the fuel consumption on the shortest distance and the optimal route utilizing wind-assisted propulsion system crossing the North Atlantic Ocean. A numerical analysis of rotor-sails was conducted and node-based graph network was employed to construct a navigational map for searching optimal route utilizing wind and ship data. Ships using only their main propulsion system were compared to those equipped with rotor-sails. When following the shortest route, ship with rotor-sails achieved a 7.6% fuel saving. Additionally, by optimizing the route to take advantage of wind conditions favorable for rotor-sails, an extra 10.9% fuel saving was observed. This research analyzes the practical applicability of wind-assisted propulsion technology and aims to contribute to compliance with eco-friendly regulations in the maritime industry.

Introduction: The Resurgence of Wind in Modern Shipping

The global shipping industry is currently navigating a period of intense regulatory pressure to meet stringent greenhouse gas (GHG) reduction targets. As the International Maritime Organization (IMO) tightens its standards, shipowners are increasingly looking toward Wind-Assisted Propulsion Systems (WAPS) as a viable auxiliary power source. Among these technologies, rotor sails—cylindrical devices that generate thrust via the Magnus effect—have emerged as a leading solution due to their relatively simple integration and significant fuel-saving potential.

Figure 3: Distribution of various Wind-Assisted Propulsion System (WAPS) technologies currently in use or development, highlighting the prevalence of rotor sails.

However, the effectiveness of WAPS is inherently tied to the unpredictability of maritime weather. Traditional evaluation models often rely on static, global wind probability matrices that fail to capture the dynamic nature of a real-world voyage. This study, recently published in the Journal of Coastal Disaster Prevention, addresses this gap by proposing a sophisticated routing framework that treats wind not as a variable to be endured, but as a primary fuel source to be actively sought out.

The Mechanics of Wind-Assisted Propulsion

At the heart of this research is the rotor sail. Unlike traditional cloth sails, these are large, rotating cylinders. When wind blows across the rotating cylinder, it creates a pressure difference—higher pressure on one side and lower on the other—resulting in a lift force perpendicular to the wind direction. This is known as the Magnus effect.

Figure 4: Diagram illustrating the Magnus effect, where the rotation of the cylinder in a moving air stream generates thrust.

The study utilized Computational Fluid Dynamics (CFD) with an SST (Shear Stress Transport) turbulence model to precisely calculate the lift and drag coefficients of a rotor sail across a wide range of wind speeds and angles. These performance "polars" were then integrated into a 17K DWT bulk carrier model, providing a realistic baseline for how the ship would respond to varying North Atlantic wind conditions.

Methodology: Beyond the Square Grid

A critical innovation in this paper is the move away from traditional square-grid navigation models. Standard grids often limit a ship's heading changes to 45-degree increments, which can lead to "distance inflation" and prevent the vessel from maintaining the precise "beam wind" angles (crosswinds) where rotor sails are most efficient.

To solve this, the researchers developed a node-based graph network. By using a specific aspect ratio (up to 6:1) between nodes, the network allows for much finer course adjustments—as low as 9.5 degrees. This high-resolution map enables a modified A* search algorithm to find the path of least resistance—or, more accurately, the path of maximum wind assistance. The cost function of the algorithm was shifted from "shortest distance" to "minimum fuel consumption," incorporating real-time ECMWF ERA5 reanalysis wind data.

Key Results: The "Shortest Path" Fallacy

The study simulated a voyage from Norfolk, USA, to the Strait of Gibraltar, comparing three distinct scenarios:

  1. Baseline (Great Circle, No Sails): The standard shortest-distance route using only the main engine, consuming 136.01 tons of fuel.
  2. Standard Route + Sails: Equipping the ship with four rotor sails but sticking to the Great Circle path. This resulted in a 7.6% fuel saving (125.65 tons).
  3. Optimized Route + Sails: Using the graph network to find the wind-optimal path. This route was approximately 265 km longer and took 12.4 hours more than the Great Circle, yet it achieved a total 17.7% fuel saving (111.88 tons).

These results demonstrate that for wind-assisted ships, the shortest physical distance is rarely the most economical. By deviating from the direct path to "harvest" better wind, the ship more than doubled the fuel savings provided by the sails alone.

Insights and Future Directions

The research highlights that the true potential of WAPS lies in its integration with "Weather Routing." While the study assumed a constant ship speed, future work could combine wind-optimal routing with "slow steaming" to push efficiency even further.

However, limitations remain. The current model does not yet account for the added resistance of waves and ocean currents, which are significant factors in the North Atlantic. Additionally, while the study used high-resolution historical data, real-world application will require the integration of ensemble weather forecasts to manage the inherent uncertainty of maritime conditions.

Reference: Kim, J., Lee, H.-T., Kwon, W., Li, K., Seo, Y., & Cho, I. (2025). Optimal Route Design and Operational Efficiency Analysis of Wind-Assisted Propulsion Ships Using Graph Networks. Journal of Coastal Disaster Prevention, 12(1), 73-88. https://doi.org/10.20481/kscdp.2025.12.1.73

Summary updated

Abstract

This study focuses on exploring the optimal routes for Wind-Assisted Propulsion Ship (WAPS), targeting enhanced fuel efficiency and greenhouse gas reduction in maritime operations, using a 17K DWT bulk carrier equipped with a 2.4MW dual-fuel engine and four medium-sized rotor-sails as auxiliary propulsion devices. The research assesses the efficiency of these routes by comparing the fuel consumption on the shortest distance and the optimal route utilizing wind-assisted propulsion system crossing the North Atlantic Ocean. A numerical analysis of rotor-sails was conducted and node-based graph network was employed to construct a navigational map for searching optimal route utilizing wind and ship data. Ships using only their main propulsion system were compared to those equipped with rotor-sails. When following the shortest route, ship with rotor-sails achieved a 7.6% fuel saving. Additionally, by optimizing the route to take advantage of wind conditions favorable for rotor-sails, an extra 10.9% fuel saving was observed. This research analyzes the practical applicability of wind-assisted propulsion technology and aims to contribute to compliance with eco-friendly regulations in the maritime industry.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{kim2025optimal,
  author = {Jinkyu Kim and Hyeong-Tak Lee and Wook Hyun Кwon and Kuiming Li and Yuri Seo and Ik-Soon Cho},
  title = {{Optimal Route Design and Operational Efficiency Analysis of Wind-Assisted Propulsion Ships Using Graph Networks}},
  booktitle = {Korea},
  year = {2025},
  doi = {10.20481/kscdp.2025.12.1.73},
}
Figure