Abstract
Autonomous robots often face tasks specified in Linear Temporal Logic (LTL) that may become unsatisfiable due to environmental uncertainties. This paper proposes a framework for generating optimal policies that maximize the probability of task satisfaction, maximize partial progress when full satisfaction is impossible, and minimize expected costs. By converting co-safe LTL formulas into Deterministic Finite Automata (DFA) and defining a progression metric, the authors utilize multi-objective probabilistic model checking to ensure robust performance in stochastic environments.
Introduction
In traditional robotics, tasks are often defined by simple reward functions. However, complex missions (e.g., "Visit all offices, but if you see a fire, go to the exit") are better described using Linear Temporal Logic (LTL). Standard LTL planning assumes the environment is "nice" enough that the task can be completed with a probability of 1. But the real world is messy: doors are locked, batteries die, or paths are blocked. If a task becomes unsatisfiable, standard algorithms often break down—either the cost calculations fail to converge, or the robot simply gives up. This paper fills this gap by providing a mathematically rigorous way to define "doing your best" when total success is off the table, ensuring the robot still performs as much of the task as possible as efficiently as possible.
Methodology
The authors build their approach on Markov Decision Processes (MDPs), which model system transitions with inherent uncertainty. The core innovation lies in the integration of task progression metrics within the formal verification framework.
Task Progression and the DFA
Co-safe LTL formulas—tasks that can be completed in finite time—are converted into a Deterministic Finite Automaton (DFA). This state machine tracks task progress. The authors define a distance metric ($d_\phi$) on the DFA states. If the robot cannot reach the "Accepting" (Success) state, it aims for the state "closest" to it. This distance is transformed into a progression reward ($p_\phi$).
The Trimmed Product MDP
The robot's world model (MDP) is combined with the task model (DFA) to create a product MDP. Crucially, the model is "trimmed" by removing states where no further task progress is possible. This ensures that undiscounted cumulative costs (like total time or energy) remain finite and calculable.
Multi-Objective Optimization
Instead of a single reward, the framework uses a lexicographic (prioritized) approach:
- Priority 1: Maximize the probability of total task success.
- Priority 2: Maximize the expected "progression reward" (partial satisfaction).
- Priority 3: Minimize the expected cost (e.g., time) to achieve the first two goals.
Experimental Evaluation
The paper evaluates the method using a simulated robot navigation scenario in an office environment.
The environment consists of a topological map with 6 rooms and 18 navigation nodes. Doors have a 90% probability of being open, and one specific path has a 20% chance of leading the robot into a "trap" node ($v_0$) that must be avoided. The task is to visit three specific rooms in any order while avoiding the forbidden zone.
Key Results
- Robustness vs. Efficiency: In the office simulation, the generated policy chose a longer detour to avoid the 20% risk of entering the forbidden zone, prioritizing a 72.9% success probability over a faster but riskier path.
- Partial Satisfaction: When the robot encountered a locked door that made the full task impossible, the policy automatically pivoted to visiting the remaining accessible rooms rather than stalling.
- Computational Performance: For a product MDP with ~21,000 states, the policy was generated in about 9 minutes on standard hardware, making it suitable for offline policy generation.
Conclusion
This work demonstrates that prioritization over simple summation is essential for robust robot behavior. By treating task satisfaction as a distance-to-target problem on a DFA, the authors turn a logical problem into a geometric one that MDP solvers can handle. Future work will address the "state-space explosion" and explore integration with learning-based approaches for environments with unknown probabilities.
Summary updated