Optimal Configuration of Wind-PV and Energy Storage in Large Clean Energy Bases

Mingyi Liu, Bin Zhang, Jiaqi Wang, Han Liu, Jianxin Wang, Chenghao Liu, Jiahui Zhao, Yue Sun, Rongrong Zhai, Yong ZhuSustainability 2023 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper proposes an optimized configuration for large-scale clean energy bases by integrating wind, solar PV, and energy storage. They developed a novel method to minimize investment and storage capacity by coupling thermal energy storage (for rough modulation) with battery energy storage (for fine modulation), significantly reducing costs and improving system stability.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The increasing integration of renewable energy sources like wind and solar into power grids presents a significant challenge due to their inherent intermittency and fluctuation. This variability makes it difficult to ensure a stable and reliable power supply, especially for meeting peak demands and providing grid services like frequency regulation. Traditional thermal power plants are being relied upon to compensate for these fluctuations, but this can be inefficient and costly. The paper addresses the need for an optimized approach to configure and operate large-scale clean energy bases that combine multiple renewable sources with various energy storage technologies to overcome these challenges, reduce costs, and maximize the utilization of clean energy.

Methods

The authors employed a multi-faceted approach:

  • System Modeling: They utilized the EBSILON Professional software to model a large-scale clean energy base system, incorporating wind power, PV, thermal power, and different types of energy storage (molten salt thermal storage, battery energy storage, and hydrogen energy).
  • Capacity Optimization: A novel capacity calculation method was developed. This method aims to minimize both the total investment cost and the required energy storage capacity of the power system. It considers crucial constraints such as power balance, state of charge (SOC) of storage systems, and power fluctuation limits.
  • Coordinated Operation Strategy: A key contribution is the proposed coupled operation mode. This strategy leverages:
  • Thermal Energy Storage (Molten Salt): Primarily used for rough modulation and handling large-scale energy storage, coupled with thermal power generation for primary regulation tasks.
  • Battery Energy Storage: Employed for fine modulation, specifically for tasks like frequency regulation and meeting district heating demands.
  • Economic Evaluation: The paper uses various static and dynamic economic indicators, including Static Pay-Back Period (SPP), Return on Investment (ROI), Net Present Value (NPV), and Internal Rate of Return (IRR), to assess the economic feasibility of the proposed configuration.

Datasets

The paper uses hourly electricity load data from a specific province as a basis for its analysis. This data is used to understand power demand characteristics and to simulate the performance of the proposed clean energy base configuration. No new benchmark datasets were introduced.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Synergistic Storage: The core insight is the effective synergy between thermal energy storage (for bulk storage and rough adjustments) and battery energy storage (for rapid, fine-tuned responses). This "two-tier" storage approach is more efficient and cost-effective than relying on a single type of storage.
  • Reduced Investment: By strategically coupling thermal and battery storage, the paper demonstrates a significant reduction in the required investment for energy storage systems (over 95% reduction for fine modulation tasks).
  • Optimized Configuration: The study provides a concrete optimal configuration for a 10 million kilowatt clean energy base, detailing the capacities of wind, PV, thermal power, and the specific amounts of thermal and battery storage needed.
  • Economic Viability: The proposed configuration and operation strategy lead to a favorable economic outcome, with a pre-tax internal rate of return of 8%, indicating good profitability.
  • Addressing Intermittency: The integrated approach effectively addresses the intermittency of wind and PV by providing stable power output, reducing power shortage rates, and improving grid stability.

Key Results

  • The proposed optimal configuration for a 10 million kilowatt clean energy base includes:
  • 10,000 MW of wind power
    • 2,000 MW of PV power
    • 4,000 MW of thermal power
    • 80 million kWh of molten salt thermal storage capacity
    • 144,000 kW (1-hour duration) of electrochemical (battery) energy storage
  • The integrated system can solve 85.4% of the power limitation problem through thermal storage.
  • The battery energy storage system effectively handles fine adjustments and frequency regulation.
  • The overall pre-tax internal rate of return for the project is 8%, demonstrating strong economic benefits.
  • The power generation composition shows a significant reliance on wind and PV (90.5%), with thermal storage contributing 7.1% and battery storage 0.1% of the total energy generation.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Data Specificity: The study relies on specific provincial load data and wind/PV resource characteristics. While representative, the results might vary for different geographical locations and resource profiles.
  • Exclusions in Economic Analysis: The economic feasibility calculation conservatively excludes revenues from external heating and hydrogen production, suggesting that the actual profitability could be even higher.
  • Future Work: The authors implicitly suggest further research into refining the optimization algorithms, exploring other energy storage technologies, and conducting more detailed analyses of the impact of hydrogen energy integration. The paper also highlights the need for continued research into advanced control strategies for managing complex integrated energy systems.

Summary updated

Abstract

The installed capacity of energy storage in China has increased dramatically due to the national power system reform and the integration of large scale renewable energy with other sources. To support the construction of large-scale energy bases and optimizes the performance of thermal power plants, the research on the corporation mode between energy storage and thermal energy, including the optimization of energy-storage capacity and its operation in large-scale clean energy bases. In this paper, a large-scale clean energy base system is modeled with EBSILON and a capacity calculation method is established by minimizing the investment cost and energy storage capacity of the power system and constraints such as power balance, SOC, and power fluctuations. The research proposed a method of using coupled system of thermal energy storage systems primarily based on molten salt thermal storage and thermal power generation for rough modulation and using battery energy storage system for fine modulation tasks. Example of fine modulation includes frequency modulation and heating demand of the district, which significantly reduces the energy storage investment by more than 95%. A case study of a 10 MW clean energy base is conducted. The result shows that the overall pre-tax internal rate of return of the base project is 8%, which has good economic benefits.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{liu2023optimal,
  author = {Mingyi Liu and Bin Zhang and Jiaqi Wang and Han Liu and Jianxin Wang and Chenghao Liu and Jiahui Zhao and Yue Sun and Rongrong Zhai and Yong Zhu},
  title = {{Optimal Configuration of Wind-PV and Energy Storage in Large Clean Energy Bases}},
  booktitle = {Sustainability},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.3390/su151712895},
}
Figure