Open source software-a recipe for vulnerable software,or the only way to keep the bugs and the bad guys out?

Saurabh Bagchi, Henrique Madeira

Abstract

Open source software (OSS) as a movement has come a long way since its beginnings at MIT in the Free Software Foundation movement. The initial connotation was “free software” with little or no commercial angle to it. With time, the movement has morphed into the Open Source movement which accommodates within itself various different kinds of licensing agreements some of which enable the commercial usage of open software as well. The emphasis has been broadened from the low cost and wide accessibility argument to include non functional attributes of reliability, security, availability and survivability. This broadening is to an extent a function of the broadening of the locales where open source software is found today. The locales include not just college campuses and government research laboratories, but also mainstream commercial software development houses. The developer base for the open source initiative has grown to include developers in all these locales and also geographically widely dispersed. The developer base though large is a miniscule fraction of the user base of open source software, and that is probably a fundamental model that will be followed for some time to come. In this discussion, we consider Closed Source Software (CSS) as an alternative model for software development. This is the tried and tested software development model where the development, integration and testing are all done within a commercial establishment and the source code is not made available to the general user base. The source code is in fact closely guarded and is looked upon as valuable intellectual capital for the organization. There are some variations of this model in recent years, such as Microsoft’s Shared Source Initiative, in which the source code is made available to some partners, typically without granting the right to modify and re-distribute the code. With the non functional attributes of OSS being emphasized, there has been a lively and very inconclusive debate on the effect of OSS on software robustness. First, let us take a sample of some arguments against OSS that have been heard. It is true that the code in OSS is open to many more eyeballs than CSS. However, the eyeballs can be malicious ones intent on finding vulnerabilities in the software for the purpose of exploiting them. A vast majority of the eyeballs may be disinterested or
BibTeX
@inproceedings{bagchi2003open,
  author = {Saurabh Bagchi and Henrique Madeira},
  title = {{Open source software-a recipe for vulnerable software,or the only way to keep the bugs and the bad guys out?}},
  booktitle = {ISSRE},
  year = {2003},
  url = {https://openreview.net/forum?id=QnaCDj2hhor},
}

Loading related content...

Figure