Online Social Networking Has a Greater Effect on Others than on Me: A Third-Person Effect Perspective

Alireza Heravi, Sameera Mubarak, Kim-Kwang Raymond Choo

TL;DR

We often think we are immune to the influence of social media while worrying that everyone else is falling into its traps. This paper confirms that the "Third-Person Effect" is alive and well in online social networking, showing that users perceive both the risks (like stalking) and the benefits (like making friends) to be significantly greater for others than for themselves.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The "Privacy Paradox" is a well-known headache for researchers: why do people claim to value their privacy yet continue to overshare on platforms like Facebook or Instagram?

This paper tackles that question through the lens of Third-Person Effect (TPE) theory. TPE posits that individuals tend to underestimate the impact of media on themselves while overestimating its impact on others. While previous research focused on negative media—like the effects of televised violence or pornography—this study explores whether this bias extends to the complex world of Online Social Networking (OSN). Specifically, the authors look at whether we think we are "smarter" than others regarding both the dangers (privacy and usage risks) and the rewards (socializing and information seeking) of being online.

Methods

The researchers employed a mixed-methods approach to get both the "what" and the "why":

  1. Quantitative Survey: They surveyed 187 participants (mostly university students) using a "back-to-back" questioning format. Participants rated the perceived effect of various OSN factors on "self" and then on "others" using a scale of 0 to 3.
  2. Qualitative Interviews: To dig deeper, they conducted semi-structured interviews with 8 experienced OSN users.
  3. Statistical Analysis: They used paired-samples t-tests to measure the perceptual gap and linear regression to see if these perceptions actually predicted "protective behaviors" (like tightening privacy settings).

This approach is standard for TPE research but novel in its application to the benefits of social media, which are usually ignored in favor of studying risks.

Datasets

The study relied on a primary dataset collected by the authors:

  • Survey Pool: 188 valid responses (later filtered to 187 for specific analyses). The demographic was skewed toward young adults (49.4% aged 19-25) and males (52.1%), primarily based in Australia.
  • Interview Pool: A subset of 8 participants (4 male, 4 female) who had been using OSNs for at least two years and spent at least 30 minutes a day on them.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The "I'm Immune" Bias for Benefits: Surprisingly, the TPE isn't just about risks. Users believe that others get more out of social media—like finding new friends or learning new things—than they do. The authors suggest this might be because users feel they only use a fraction of a platform's features, assuming others are "power users" reaping more rewards.
  • Usage Risks vs. Privacy Risks: The study makes a sharp distinction between usage risks (stalking, gossip, harassment) and privacy risks (data misuse by companies or governments).
  • The Behavioral Trigger: Thinking that others are at risk of stalking or gossip (usage risks) actually motivates people to support privacy protection. However, simply thinking others are at risk of data misuse (privacy risks) does not. This suggests that social/interpersonal threats feel more "real" and actionable than abstract data privacy concerns.
  • The Gender Gap: Men exhibited a significantly higher TPE gap regarding privacy risks than women. In other words, men were much more likely to think, "I've got my data under control, but everyone else is exposed."

Key Results

  • Perceptual Gaps: Every single category tested showed a statistically significant TPE. The largest gap was found in Usage Risks (Mean for others: 2.556 vs. Self: 1.289) and Relationship Building (Mean for others: 1.877 vs. Self: 0.647).
  • Frequency of Bias: 61.4% of participants believed usage risks were greater for others, while only 1.1% thought they were at more risk than others.
  • Predictive Power: The TPE for usage risks was a statistically significant predictor of support for taking protective actions ($p < .05$).
  • Education Influence: Interestingly, the gap for "relationship maintenance" increased with education level, peaking with PhD students, who perceived the social benefits for others to be much higher than for themselves.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge a few key hurdles:

  • Sample Bias: The study used a relatively small sample of university students, which may not represent the general public's behavior or perceptions.
  • Abstract vs. Specific: The study looked at OSNs in general. Future work could look at specific features—like "tagging" or "checking in"—to see if certain functionalities trigger a stronger TPE.
  • The "Why" of Benefits: While the study proved TPE exists for benefits, it didn't fully explain why we think others are better at "socializing" than we are. This remains a fertile ground for psychological research.

Summary updated

Abstract

To date, much research has been conducted on the positive and negative effects of online social networking (OSN). However, how users perceive others and themselves being subject to these effects and the consequences of users' perceptions are understudied. Drawing from the third-person effect theory, this study examines the self-other perceptual gap for positive and negative effects of OSN and the consequences of perceptions for negative effects. Findings from our online survey (N=187) and interviews (N=8) suggested a significant difference between the perceived positive and negative effects on self and on others. Furthermore, the link between the third-person perception for usage risks of OSN and support for taking privacy protection actions was confirmed. We also found that the self-other discrepant perceptions were not influenced by age, time spent on OSN, number of OSN friends. However, gender emerged as a key difference in the third-person effects gap for privacy risks.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{heravi2015online,
  author = {Alireza Heravi and Sameera Mubarak and Kim-Kwang Raymond Choo},
  title = {{Online Social Networking Has a Greater Effect on Others than on Me: A Third-Person Effect Perspective}},
  booktitle = {ACIS},
  year = {2015},
}
Figure