One-Shot Strategic Classification Under Unknown Costs

Elan Rosenfeld, Nir Rosenfeld

Abstract

The goal of strategic classification is to learn decision rules which are robust to strategic input manipulation. Earlier works assume that these responses are known; while some recent works handle unknown responses, they exclusively study online settings with repeated model deployments. But there are many domains—particularly in public policy, a common motivating use case—where multiple deployments are infeasible, or where even one bad round is unacceptable. To address this gap, we initiate the formal study of one-shot strategic classification under unknown responses, which requires committing to a single classifier once. Focusing on uncertainty in the users' cost function, we begin by proving that for a broad class of costs, even a small mis-estimation of the true cost can entail trivial accuracy in the worst case. In light of this, we frame the task as a minimax problem, aiming to minimize worst-case risk over an uncertainty set of costs. We design efficient algorithms for both the full-batch and stochastic settings, which we prove converge (offline) to the minimax solution at the rate of $\tilde{\mathcal{O}}(T^{-\frac{1}{2}})$. Our analysis reveals important structure stemming from strategic responses, particularly the value of dual norm regularization with respect to the cost function.

Introduction: The Challenge of One-Shot Strategic Classification

In high-stakes machine learning applications like loan approvals or school admissions, subjects are active agents. When a model is deployed, these agents strategically modify their features—such as opening new credit lines or retaking tests—to obtain favorable outcomes. This phenomenon, a manifestation of Goodhart’s Law, necessitates "strategic classification" models that are robust to such manipulations.

Traditional strategic classification assumes the learner knows the exact cost users incur to change their features. While online learning approaches can estimate these costs over time, many domains, particularly in public policy, are "one-shot." In these scenarios, a model must be deployed once and perform reliably from the start. This paper addresses the critical gap of one-shot strategic classification under unknown costs, where even a minor mis-estimation of the cost function can lead to a catastrophic collapse in model accuracy.

The Peril of Small Errors

A central insight of this work is the extreme sensitivity of strategic models to cost estimation. Because strategic behavior depends on the inverse of the cost matrix, a tiny error in identifying the "easiest" directions for a user to move can lead to massive errors in predicting their final features.

Geometric illustration of the sensitivity of Excess 0-1 Risk to cost estimation errors $\epsilon$.

As illustrated above, small perturbations in the estimated cost (represented by $\epsilon$) can significantly shift the expected risk. The authors prove that for any two distinct cost functions, there exists a data distribution where a classifier optimized for one will suffer near-total error under the other. This sensitivity is not mitigated by simply being "conservative" (assuming users have lower costs than they do), as strategic responses can sometimes be beneficial to the learner (e.g., users improving true qualities).

Minimax Framework and Methodology

To combat this uncertainty, the authors frame the task as a distributionally robust optimization (DRO) problem. Instead of optimizing for a single guessed cost, they minimize the worst-case risk over an entire uncertainty set of plausible cost functions.

Key Technical Contributions

  • Cost-Aware Strategic Hinge Loss: The authors derive a modified hinge loss incorporating the dual norm of the classifier's weights. This captures the decision rule's sensitivity to feature changes relative to the cost function.
  • Dual Norm Regularization: They prove that regularizing models using the dual norm relative to the cost function is the "natural" approach, ensuring the optimization remains convex and tractable.
  • Algorithmic Solutions:
    • MAXLOSSCOST: An efficient $O(n \log n)$ algorithm to find the worst-case cost function for a fixed classifier.
  • Stochastic Mirror Descent-Ascent (SMDA): A solver for large-scale data that uses an "algorithmic $\epsilon$-net" to handle the non-concave nature of cost maximization, achieving a convergence rate of $\tilde{O}(T^{-1/2})$.

Theoretical Validation and Results

The paper's findings are supported by rigorous proofs and synthetic experiments. Using isotropic Gaussian distributions, the authors demonstrate how excess risk scales with the dimensionality of the problem.

Excess 0-1 Risk vs. dimensionality $d$ for various cost decay rates and uncertainty levels $\epsilon$.

As shown in the figure, for various cost structures ($\lambda_k$), the excess risk can grow rapidly with the dimension $d$ if the cost is not perfectly known. However, the proposed minimax approach provides guarantees that are independent of dimensionality for a broad class of cost functions (specifically $p$-norms where $p \le 2$), making it viable for high-dimensional real-world data.

Conclusion and Future Directions

This work establishes a robust foundation for one-shot strategic classification. By accounting for the worst-case cost function within an uncertainty set, the proposed framework avoids the catastrophic failures associated with point-estimation of costs.

Future research may address the assumption of perfect rationality in users, as real-world behavior is often noisy or boundedly rational. Additionally, while the framework covers a wide range of norm-based costs, extending these guarantees to non-norm-based cost structures and exploring the "graceful degradation" of performance when the true cost lies just outside the uncertainty set remain open challenges.

Summary updated

Abstract

The goal of strategic classification is to learn decision rules which are robust to strategic input manipulation. Earlier works assume that these responses are known; while some recent works handle unknown responses, they exclusively study online settings with repeated model deployments. But there are many domains$\unicode{x2014}$particularly in public policy, a common motivating use case$\unicode{x2014}$where multiple deployments are infeasible, or where even one bad round is unacceptable. To address this gap, we initiate the formal study of one-shot strategic classification under unknown responses, which requires committing to a single classifier once. Focusing on uncertainty in the users' cost function, we begin by proving that for a broad class of costs, even a small mis-estimation of the true cost can entail trivial accuracy in the worst case. In light of this, we frame the task as a minimax problem, aiming to minimize worst-case risk over an uncertainty set of costs. We design efficient algorithms for both the full-batch and stochastic settings, which we prove converge (offline) to the minimax solution at the rate of $\tilde{\mathcal{O}}(T^{-\frac{1}{2}})$. Our analysis reveals important structure stemming from strategic responses, particularly the value of dual norm regularization with respect to the cost function.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{rosenfeld2024one,
  author = {Elan Rosenfeld and Nir Rosenfeld},
  title = {{One-Shot Strategic Classification Under Unknown Costs}},
  booktitle = {International Conference on Machine Learning},
  year = {2024},
  url = {https://openreview.net/forum?id=OURP5Z58jt},
}
Figure