On unbalanced difference bodies and Godbersen's conjecture

Shiri Artstein-Avidan, Eli Putterman

Abstract

The longstanding Godbersen's conjecture states that for any convex body $K \subset \mathbb R^n$ of volume $1$ and any $j \in \{0, \ldots, n\}$, the mixed volume $V_j = V(K[j], -K[n - j])$ is bounded by $\binom{n}{j}$, with equality if and only if $K$ is a simplex. This paper demonstrates that several consequences of this conjecture are true: certain families of linear combinations of the $V_j$, arising from different geometric constructions, are bounded above by their values when one substitutes $\binom{n}{j}$ for $V_j$, with equality if and only if $K$ is a simplex. One result implies that for any $K$ of volume $1$, the conjecture holds "on average." Furthermore, the work generalizes the well-known Rogers-Shephard inequality for the difference body.

Introduction

In the field of convex geometry, the study of the difference body $K - K = \{x - y : x, y \in K\}$ has yielded some of the most profound results in the discipline. Central to this is the Rogers-Shephard inequality, which provides a sharp upper bound on the volume of the difference body relative to the original convex body $K$. However, the volume of $K - K$ is not a monolithic value; it can be decomposed into a sequence of mixed volumes $V_j = V(K[j], -K[n-j])$. These terms represent the interaction between $j$ copies of $K$ and $n-j$ copies of its reflection $-K$.

In 1938, Claus Godbersen conjectured that each individual mixed volume $V_j$ is maximized when $K$ is a simplex. Specifically, for a body of unit volume, $V_j \le \binom{n}{j}$. While this conjecture has remained one of the more elusive problems in the field, particularly for dimensions $n > 3$, recent research has made significant strides by examining these volumes through the lens of "unbalanced" difference bodies and weighted averages.

Theoretical Framework and Methodology

The authors approach the problem by employing auxiliary constructions in higher-dimensional spaces. By lifting the $n$-dimensional convex body into $\mathbb{R}^{n+1}$ or $\mathbb{R}^{2n+1}$—forming what are known as Rogers-Shephard bodies—the researchers can analyze sections and projections that correspond to the mixed volumes of the original body.

A key tool in this analysis is the unbalanced covariogram. While a standard covariogram measures the volume of intersection between a body and its translate, the unbalanced version considers the intersection between a body and a translated, scaled version of its reflection. This is mathematically linked to the mixed volumes $V_j$ via the local Steiner formula. Through geometric symmetrization, the authors demonstrate that the simplex serves as the unique extremal case where specific geometric inclusions become equalities.

Key Results: Godbersen "On Average"

One of the most significant contributions of this work is the proof that Godbersen’s conjecture holds "on average." While proving the bound for a specific index $j$ remains difficult, the authors establish that the sum of these volumes, when properly weighted, adheres to the predicted bounds.

Theorem 2 and Corollary 3

The paper establishes a sharp upper bound for a weighted sum of mixed volumes: $$\sum_{j=0}^n \lambda^j (1-\lambda)^{n-j} V_j \le Vol(K)$$ This inequality holds for any $\lambda \in [0, 1]$. From this, the authors derive a powerful corollary: for any convex body $K$ of volume 1, $$\frac{1}{n + 1} \sum_{j = 0}^n \binom{n}{j}^{-1} V_j \le 1$$ This result confirms that the conjecture cannot be "very wrong" across the set of indices; the average behavior of the mixed volumes is perfectly consistent with the simplex being the extremal case.

Unbalanced Difference Bodies

The research introduces the concept of the unbalanced difference body, defined as $D_\lambda K = (1-\lambda)K + \lambda(-K)$. When $\lambda = 1/2$, this recovers a scaled version of the classical difference body. The authors propose a new conjecture (Conjecture 6) stating that the simplex maximizes the volume of $D_\lambda K$ for any $\lambda \in [0, 1]$.

In a notable advancement, the authors prove this "Unbalanced Difference Body Conjecture" for all dimensions $n \le 5$. Given that the original Godbersen conjecture is only fully resolved for $n \le 3$, this provides strong evidence for the validity of the broader theory in higher dimensions.

Generalizing Rogers-Shephard

Beyond the specific bounds for $V_j$, the paper provides a generalization of the Rogers-Shephard inequality. Theorem 5 establishes bounds for a broader family of weighted mixed volumes, again characterizing the simplex as the unique extremal body. This suggests that the relationship between a body and its reflection is governed by a set of inequalities that are all maximized by the most "asymmetric" convex shape—the simplex.

Conclusion and Future Directions

The results presented here represent the strongest evidence to date for the full Godbersen conjecture. By shifting the focus from individual mixed volumes to weighted sums and integral representations, the authors have bypassed some of the combinatorial difficulties that have stalled progress for decades.

The primary remaining challenge is extending these proofs to all individual indices $j$ in dimensions $n > 3$. The authors suggest that the integral-based approach—viewing these sums as integrals of the volume of unbalanced difference bodies—may eventually provide the necessary framework for a complete proof of Godbersen’s 1938 conjecture.

Summary updated

Abstract

The longstanding Godbersen's conjecture states that for any convex body $K \subset \mathbb R^n$ of volume $1$ and any $j \in \{0, \ldots, n\}$, the mixed volume $V_j = V(K[j], -K[n - j])$ is bounded by $\binom{n}{j}$, with equality if and only if $K$ is a simplex. We demonstrate that several consequences of this conjecture are true: certain families of linear combinations of the $V_j$, arising from different geometric constructions, are bounded above by their values when one substitutes $\binom{n}{j}$ for $V_j$, with equality if and only if $K$ is a simplex. One of our results implies that for any $K$ of volume $1$ we have $\frac{1}{n + 1} \sum_{j = 0}^n \binom{n}{j}^{-1} V_j \le 1$, showing that Godbersen's conjecture holds ``on average'' for any body. Another result generalizes the well-known Rogers-Shephard inequality for the difference body.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{artsteinavidan2025unbalanced,
  author = {Shiri Artstein-Avidan and Eli Putterman},
  title = {{On unbalanced difference bodies and Godbersen's conjecture}},
  booktitle = {Proceedings of the American Mathematical Society},
  year = {2025},
  doi = {10.1090/proc/17428},
}
Figure