TL;DR
This paper investigates Hugging Face Hub (HFH) as a potential data source for empirical software engineering studies, a role currently dominated by GitHub. The authors propose a framework to analyze HFH's features and data availability, aiming to determine its suitability for researchers studying ML-centric software development.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
Empirical studies in software engineering (SE) heavily rely on data from code hosting platforms like GitHub to understand developer behavior, project evolution, and software quality. However, the rise of Machine Learning (ML) has led to specialized platforms like Hugging Face Hub (HFH), which host ML artifacts (models, datasets, demos). While HFH is rapidly growing and incorporating features similar to GitHub, its suitability as a data source for empirical SE research remains unexplored. This paper aims to fill that gap by assessing HFH's features and data accessibility for researchers.
Methods
The authors propose a mixed-methods approach to evaluate HFH's suitability.
- Qualitative Analysis: This involves developing a "feature framework" by analyzing existing code hosting platforms (primarily GitHub and GitLab) to identify common features relevant to software development and data retrieval. This framework will then be used to characterize HFH's offerings, addressing RQ1 (What features does HFH provide?). This is further broken down into:
- RQ1.1: Features for collaborative ML-oriented project development.
- RQ1.2: Features for platform-level data retrieval.
- Quantitative Analysis: This part focuses on assessing the current state of HFH data and its usage, addressing RQ2 (How is HFH currently being exploited?). This involves analyzing data volume and diversity at both the platform and project levels. The authors plan to leverage the HFCOMMUNITY dataset, which aggregates data from HFH and Git repositories.
Datasets
The primary dataset mentioned is HFCOMMUNITY, an open-source tool that collects data from Hugging Face Hub and Git repositories, storing it in a relational database. This dataset is stated to contain over 250,000 repositories. The paper does not introduce any newly created benchmarks.
Key Insights and Ideas
- HFH as a Nascent Ecosystem: HFH is presented not just as a code repository but as a growing ecosystem for ML artifacts, with features evolving to support more complex development workflows.
- The "Suitability" Question: The core idea is to define and measure "suitability" for empirical studies, encompassing both the platform's features and the availability/quality of its data.
- Bridging ML and SE Research: The paper highlights the need for SE research to adapt to the unique characteristics of ML development, which HFH aims to facilitate.
- Comparative Analysis: By comparing HFH's features to those of established platforms like GitHub, the authors aim to identify areas where HFH might enable replication of existing studies or open new avenues for research.
- Data Retrieval Challenges: A key focus is on how easily researchers can access and extract data from HFH, which is crucial for empirical studies.
Key Results
As this is a proposal for a registered report, the paper outlines the plan for analysis rather than presenting final results. However, it anticipates potential findings:
- RQ1: The qualitative analysis will characterize HFH's features, potentially revealing shared features with GitHub (enabling replication), missing features (highlighting limitations), or unique features (offering new research opportunities).
- RQ2: The quantitative analysis is expected to provide an overview of HFH's usage, platform behavior, and typical project characteristics. The authors anticipate that HFH might not yet be mature enough for extensive longitudinal studies compared to platforms like GitHub.
Limitations and Future Work
- Emerging Platform: HFH is a relatively young platform, and its features and data collection mechanisms are still evolving. This dynamic nature poses a threat to the long-term validity of findings.
- Data Clashing: Usernames across HFH and Git might not always match, potentially complicating data analysis.
- Snapshot Analysis: The quantitative analysis will be based on a snapshot of HFH data, which might not represent its future state.
- Generalization: The authors acknowledge that the findings might not be directly generalizable without proper comparison and validation.
- Future Work: The paper's conclusion aims to discuss what types of empirical studies could benefit from HFH data, either as a standalone source or in combination with other data sources. The authors also plan to address threats to validity, including internal, external, construct, and conclusion validity.
Summary updated