On the Spectral Efficiency of Noncooperative Uplink Massive MIMO Systems

Nir Shlezinger, Yonina C. Eldar

TL;DR

This paper investigates the spectral efficiency (SE) of uplink massive MIMO systems by moving beyond the traditional assumption of base stations (BSs) treating inter-cell interference as noise. The authors propose and analyze novel schemes that allow BSs to jointly decode signals, leading to significant SE gains, especially in scenarios with strong interference.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Future wireless networks face a growing demand for higher throughput, and massive MIMO (multiple-input multiple-output) systems, which equip base stations with a large number of antennas, are a promising solution. In the uplink (user to base station communication), a common simplification is to assume that each BS decodes its users' signals independently and treats interference from other cells as noise. While this approach offers some SE improvement with increasing BS antennas, it's information-theoretically suboptimal. The exact capacity of such interfering systems is unknown, and the gap between this simplified approach and the true achievable rates, particularly when inter-cell interference is significant, is not well understood. This paper aims to bridge this gap by characterizing the SE of uplink massive MIMO systems when BSs are allowed to jointly decode signals and handle interference more effectively.

Methods

The paper proposes and analyzes three main decoding schemes for handling inter-cell interference:

  1. Interference as Noise: Each BS decodes its own users' signals and treats all other cell's transmissions as noise. This is a variation of the standard approach, but it allows for joint decoding of signals from users within the same cell.
  2. Simultaneous Decoding: Each BS decodes signals from all users in the network, including those from other cells. This allows for interference cancellation.
  3. Time Division: The data transmission phase is divided among cells, so only one cell transmits at a time, effectively eliminating intercell interference.

The authors derive the achievable average ergodic rates for these schemes in both finite and massive MIMO regimes (where the number of BS antennas approaches infinity), utilizing tools from random matrix theory. They also propose an Optimized Scheme that intelligently combines the advantages of the three schemes by partitioning the transmission phase and allowing BSs to selectively decode or treat interference as noise.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study relies on synthetic models and simulations to evaluate performance.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Joint Decoding is Crucial: The traditional assumption of treating inter-cell interference as noise, even with joint decoding within a cell, significantly underestimates the achievable spectral efficiency, especially when interference is dominant.
  • Interference Management is Key: The optimal strategy for handling intercell interference depends heavily on its level. Treating it as noise is best in weak interference regimes, while simultaneous decoding is optimal in strong interference regimes.
  • Time Division Offers a Trade-off: While time division eliminates interference, it reduces the available transmission time, leading to a trade-off between interference cancellation and spectral efficiency.
  • An Optimized Scheme Unlocks Potential: A combined approach that intelligently partitions time and selectively decodes/treats interference as noise can achieve the highest spectral efficiency, approaching fundamental performance limits.
  • Massive MIMO Benefits from Advanced Techniques: The gains from joint decoding and sophisticated interference management are substantial, highlighting that simply increasing antenna count isn't enough; intelligent signal processing is vital.

Key Results

  • The paper provides analytical expressions for the achievable average ergodic rates for the proposed schemes in both finite and massive MIMO regimes.
  • Numerical simulations demonstrate significant SE gains from joint decoding compared to standard separate linear decoding, particularly in strong interference scenarios. For instance, in weak interference, gains of 2.2 bps/Hz and 0.45 bps/Hz were observed over matched filtering and MMSE filtering, respectively.
  • The optimized scheme consistently achieved the highest SE across various interference levels and SNR, indicating it approaches the true fundamental limits of massive MIMO systems.
  • The study shows that for weak interference, treating interference as noise (even with joint decoding) is near-optimal, while for strong interference, simultaneous decoding is optimal.
  • The asymptotic analysis was shown to be accurate for a large number of BS antennas (above 160).

Limitations and Future Work

  • Computational Complexity: While the proposed schemes offer significant gains, optimal joint decoding can be computationally complex, especially for a large number of users. The paper mentions that interference cancellation and deep learning can mitigate this complexity.
  • Cooperation Level: The time division scheme requires a basic level of centralized network control for time allocation, which is a form of cooperation, though not full cooperative encoding/decoding.
  • Generalization of Optimized Scheme: The paper notes that the SE can be further optimized by allowing cells to be active on more than one transmission interval, a generalization deferred to future exploration.
  • Additional Design Objectives: Future work could explore how to incorporate other practical network design objectives, such as fairness, into the optimization framework.
  • Different System Models: The analysis could be extended to different system models and network architectures.

Summary updated

Abstract

Massive multiple-input multiple-output (MIMO) systems have been drawing considerable interest due to the growing throughput demands on wireless networks. In the uplink, massive MIMO systems are commonly studied assuming that each base station (BS) decodes the signals of its user terminals separately and linearly while treating all interference as noise. Although this approach provides improved spectral efficiency which scales with the number of BS antennas in favorable channel conditions, it is generally sub-optimal from an information-theoretic perspective. In this work we characterize the spectral efficiency of massive MIMO when the BSs are allowed to jointly decode the received signals. In particular, we consider four schemes for treating the interference, and derive the achievable average ergodic rates for both finite and asymptotic number of antennas for each scheme. Simulation tests of the proposed methods illustrate their gains in spectral efficiency compared to the standard approach of separate linear decoding, and show that the standard approach fails to capture the actual achievable rates of massive MIMO systems, particularly when the interference is dominant.
BibTeX
@article{shlezinger2019spectral,
  author = {Nir Shlezinger and Yonina C. Eldar},
  title = {{On the Spectral Efficiency of Noncooperative Uplink Massive MIMO Systems}},
  journal = {IEEE Trans. Communications},
  year = {2019},
  doi = {10.1109/tcomm.2018.2884008},
}
Figure