On the Sensitivity of Continuous-Time Noncoherent Fading Channel Capacity

Giuseppe Durisi, Veniamin I. Morgenshtern, Helmut Bölcskei

TL;DR

This paper investigates the noncoherent capacity of continuous-time fading channels, a crucial metric for wireless communication reliability. It demonstrates that for practical SNR levels and a broad class of realistic fading channels (underspread Rayleigh-fading), the capacity is remarkably robust and closely approximates that of a simple AWGN channel, regardless of the fine details of the fading process. This finding simplifies the design of communication systems by alleviating concerns about precisely characterizing complex fading statistics.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

In wireless communications, the "capacity" of a channel defines the theoretical maximum rate at which information can be transmitted reliably. For fading channels, where the signal strength fluctuates, this capacity is often analyzed in a "noncoherent" setting, meaning neither the transmitter nor the receiver perfectly knows the instantaneous state of the fading. Previous research on discrete-time fading channels revealed a concerning sensitivity: the channel's capacity at high signal-to-noise ratios (SNRs) could drastically change based on subtle, hard-to-measure properties of the fading's statistical model (specifically, the "support" of its power spectral density). This made it difficult for engineers to predict or design for real-world scenarios. This paper aims to determine if this sensitivity persists in more general, continuous-time fading channels and if it impacts capacity at SNRs relevant to practical wireless systems.

Methods

The authors tackle this problem by developing a novel approach to analyze continuous-time fading channels. Standard methods involve discretizing the channel, but this often requires knowledge of channel statistics that are unavailable in the noncoherent setting. Instead, they discretize the channel by projecting the input and output signals onto a specific set of basis functions called "Weyl-Heisenberg (WH) sets." These sets are essentially time-frequency shifted versions of a basic pulse, allowing for a mathematically tractable analysis.

A key innovation is their definition of an "underspread" channel, which is more robust and physically meaningful than previous definitions. They then derive a lower bound on the noncoherent capacity using this discretization and by treating the "self-interference" (an artifact of the discretization process) as additive noise. This lower bound is then compared to an upper bound derived from the capacity of a standard additive white Gaussian noise (AWGN) channel.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The paper focuses on theoretical analysis and deriving bounds on channel capacity, rather than empirical evaluation on specific datasets.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Robustness of Capacity: The most significant insight is that for practical SNR values and underspread Rayleigh-fading channels, the noncoherent capacity is surprisingly insensitive to the precise statistical model of the fading. This is a major relief for system designers.
  • New Underspread Definition: The paper introduces a more practical and robust definition of "underspread" channels, based on the scattering function having a small fraction of its volume outside a specific rectangular region. This definition is more amenable to verification through measurements.
  • Weyl-Heisenberg Sets for Discretization: The use of WH sets for discretizing continuous-time LTV channels is presented as a powerful tool for analysis, preserving channel stationarity and offering a way to handle the inherent complexities of these systems.
  • Trade-off in WH Set Design: The analysis reveals a trade-off when designing WH sets: optimizing for signal-to-interference ratio (SIR) versus maximizing the number of signal-space dimensions. The paper suggests that for practical capacity, prioritizing signal-space dimensions (by choosing parameters like TF close to 1) is more beneficial.

Key Results

  • For all SNR values of practical interest, the noncoherent capacity of band-limited continuous-time underspread Rayleigh-fading channels is shown to be close to the capacity of an AWGN channel with the same SNR and bandwidth.
  • This closeness holds regardless of the specific measure of the support of the channel's scattering function, addressing the sensitivity issue found in prior discrete-time models.
  • A lower bound on the channel capacity is derived, which is explicit in channel parameters like ΔH (related to delay spread) and ε (related to the fraction of volume outside the underspread region).
  • Numerical results and analysis suggest that a specific choice of WH set parameters (TF slightly larger than 1) provides a good balance for achieving near-capacity performance.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Treating Self-Interference as Noise: The capacity lower bound is obtained by treating the signal-dependent self-interference as additive noise. While this is a common technique for obtaining lower bounds, it inherently makes the bound looser than the true capacity.
  • Upper Bound on Capacity: The paper primarily focuses on a lower bound and compares it to an AWGN upper bound. Deriving a tighter, channel-specific upper bound, especially one that accounts for self-interference, remains an open problem.
  • Perfect Channel State Information: The paper analyzes the noncoherent setting. Computing an upper bound on capacity assuming perfect channel state information at the receiver is identified as an interesting future direction, though it presents significant analytical challenges, potentially requiring advanced tools from random matrix theory.
  • Analytical Maximization: While a criterion for choosing WH sets is derived, analytically maximizing the capacity lower bound over all possible WH sets is noted as being analytically complicated.

Summary updated

Abstract

The noncoherent capacity of stationary discrete-time fading channels is known to be very sensitive to the fine details of the channel model. More specifically, the measure of the support of the fading-process power spectral density (PSD) determines if noncoherent capacity grows logarithmically with the signal-to-noise ratio (SNR) or slower than logarithmically. Such a result is unsatisfactory from an engineering point of view, as the support of the PSD cannot be determined through measurements. The aim of this paper is to assess whether, for general continuous-time Rayleigh-fading channels, this sensitivity has a noticeable impact on capacity at SNR values of practical interest. To this end, we consider the general class of band-limited continuous-time Rayleigh-fading channels that satisfy the wide-sense stationary uncorrelated-scattering (WSSUS) assumption and are, in addition, under spread. We show that, for all SNR values of practical interest, the noncoherent capacity of every channel in this class is close to the capacity of an additive white Gaussian noise channel with the same SNR and bandwidth, independently of the measure of the support of the scattering function (the 2-D channel PSD). Our result is based on a lower bound on noncoherent capacity, which is built on a discretization of the channel input-output relation induced by projecting onto Weyl-Heisenberg sets. This approach is interesting in its own right as it yields a mathematically tractable way of dealing with the mutual information between certain continuous-time random signals.
BibTeX
@article{durisi2012sensitivity,
  author = {Giuseppe Durisi and Veniamin I. Morgenshtern and Helmut Bölcskei},
  title = {{On the Sensitivity of Continuous-Time Noncoherent Fading Channel Capacity}},
  journal = {IEEE Trans. Information Theory},
  year = {2012},
  url = {https://openreview.net/forum?id=p1C1R0OT5v},
}
Figure