On the Power of Quantum Algorithms for Vector Valued Mean Computation

Stefan Heinrich

Abstract

We study computation of the mean of sequences with values in finite dimensional normed spaces and compare the computational power of classical randomized with that of quantum algorithms for this problem. It turns out that in contrast to the known superiority of quantum algorithms in the scalar case, in high dimensional $L_p^M$ spaces classical randomized algorithms are essentially as powerful as quantum algorithms.

Introduction

In the field of quantum complexity, the "mean computation" problem is a cornerstone example of quantum advantage. For scalar values, it is well-established that quantum algorithms provide a quadratic speedup, achieving an error rate of $O(n^{-1})$ compared to the $O(n^{-1/2})$ rate of classical randomized algorithms. This paper investigates whether this advantage persists when the problem is extended to high-dimensional vector spaces, such as those encountered in financial modeling or complex physics simulations.

The Vector-Valued Mean Problem

The research focuses on the "many sums problem," where the goal is to compute multiple weighted means of the same data set simultaneously. This task is mathematically equivalent to computing the mean of a sequence with values in a finite-dimensional normed space, specifically $L_p^M$ spaces. The central question is whether the high dimensionality ($M$) of the target space acts as a bottleneck that negates the efficiency of quantum superposition.

Methodology

This study is a theoretical exploration in computational complexity using the tools of functional analysis and Banach space theory. The author utilizes the standard Quantum Query Model, where algorithms interact with an oracle to retrieve function values.

Key theoretical steps include:

  • Reduction: Proving that the many sums problem can be reduced to a vector-valued mean computation.
  • Algorithmic Transformation: A critical component of the proof (Lemma 2) demonstrates how to transform any classical randomized algorithm into a quantum algorithm with nearly identical error behavior. This establishes a rigorous upper bound on the potential superiority of quantum methods.
  • Geometric Analysis: The author uses "type $p$ constants" of normed spaces to derive upper bounds for classical Monte Carlo methods in high-dimensional settings, allowing for a direct comparison with quantum query complexity.

The Dimensionality Bottleneck

The paper identifies a "Measurement Collapse" penalty as a primary reason for the loss of quantum advantage. In classical Monte Carlo sampling, once a data point is sampled, its value can be reused to calculate every component of a high-dimensional vector without additional cost. In contrast, the destructive nature of quantum measurement makes it difficult to "re-use" query results for different vector components.

When the dimension of the vector space ($M$) is large relative to the number of samples ($N$), the geometric complexity of the space overwhelms the algorithmic efficiency of quantum superposition. In these high-dimensional regimes, dimensionality acts as an equalizer between classical and quantum paradigms.

Key Results

The findings are formalized in Theorem 2, which compares the error rates of classical randomized algorithms ($e_n^{ran}$) and quantum algorithms ($e_n^q$):

  1. Vanishing Speedup: In high-dimensional $L_p^M$ spaces (where $M \ge N$), the speedup of quantum algorithms over randomized settings essentially vanishes.
  2. Convergence Rates: For spaces where $2 \le p \le \infty$, both classical and quantum algorithms converge at a rate of approximately $n^{-1/2}$.
  3. Lower Bounds: The author proves that for specific matrices, the best possible quantum rate is no better than the classical rate, up to logarithmic factors.

Conclusion and Limitations

The research demonstrates that the famous quantum speedup for summation is a specific property of 1D (scalar) space rather than a universal rule for all mean-related computations. In high-dimensional $L_p^M$ spaces, classical randomized algorithms are essentially as powerful as quantum ones.

Future work may explore the "transition zone"—the behavior of these algorithms when the dimension $M$ is larger than 1 but significantly smaller than the number of queries $N$. Additionally, while this paper focuses on $L_p^M$ spaces, other normed spaces with different geometric properties may yet yield different results regarding quantum advantage.

Summary updated

Abstract

We study computation of the mean of sequences with values in finite dimensional normed spaces and compare the computational power of classical randomized with that of quantum algorithms for this problem. It turns out that in contrast to the known superiority of quantum algorithms in the scalar case, in high dimensional $L_p^M$ spaces classical randomized algorithms are essentially as powerful as quantum algorithms.
BibTeX
@article{heinrich2004power,
  author = {Stefan Heinrich},
  title = {{On the Power of Quantum Algorithms for Vector Valued Mean Computation}},
  journal = {Monte Carlo Methods Appl.},
  year = {2004},
  doi = {10.1515/mcma.2004.10.3-4.297},
}
Figure