On the Performance of Interference-Based Energy-Harvesting-Enabled Wireless AF Relaying Communication Systems

Yazid M. Khattabi, Yazan H. Al-Badarneh, Mohamed‐Slim AlouiniIEEE Open Journal of Vehicular Technology 2024 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper explores a "green" communication strategy where ambient interference—usually a nuisance—is the sole power source for a wireless relay system. By analyzing three different energy-harvesting modes, the authors demonstrate that while interference degrades signal quality, it can be harvested to make IoT networks self-sustaining, even finding a "sweet spot" where system performance becomes immune to increases in interference power.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The massive growth of the Internet of Things (IoT) has created a sustainability crisis: how do we power billions of small, often inaccessible sensors? While Radio-Frequency Energy Harvesting (RF-EH) is a promising solution, most existing models rely on dedicated power transmitters or harvesting energy from the information signal itself (which reduces data range).

This paper tackles the challenge of interference-based EH. In dense urban or industrial environments, "noise" from other electronic devices is everywhere. The authors ask: Can we use this ambient interference as the only power source for a dual-hop relay system? The catch is that the same interference that powers the nodes also corrupts the signals they are trying to receive. Balancing this "double-edged sword" is the core technical challenge.

Methods

The researchers modeled a dual-hop Amplify-and-Forward (AF) relaying system consisting of a Source ($S$), a Relay ($R$), and a Destination ($D$), all operating under the influence of a dominant ambient Interferer ($I$).

Key technical components include:

  • Three EH Modes: They analyzed scenarios where energy is harvested only by the source (Mode I), only by the relay (Mode II), or concurrently by both (Mode III).
  • TSR Protocol: They employed a Time-Switching-based Relaying (TSR) protocol, where a specific fraction of time ($\tau$) is dedicated to harvesting energy, and the remainder is used for data transmission.
  • Mathematical Framework: The authors derived exact analytical expressions for outage probability and delay-limited throughput using complex statistical tools like Tricomi hypergeometric functions and infinite series representations.
  • Validation: All theoretical derivations were verified using Monte-Carlo simulations (1 million independent realizations).

Datasets

As a theoretical communication theory paper, no external datasets were used. The results are based on mathematical modeling and numerical simulations of wireless channels following a Rayleigh fading distribution.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The Interference Paradox: In Modes I and II, increasing the interferer's power actually decreases throughput. Even though the nodes get more power to transmit, the increased noise at the receivers outweighs the benefit.
  • The "Immunity" of Mode III: The most striking finding is that in Mode III (where both $S$ and $R$ harvest energy), the system throughput becomes invariant to the interferer's transmit power. Essentially, the boost in transmission power gained from harvesting perfectly cancels out the increased interference at the destination.
  • Channel Geometry Matters: The system performance is highly sensitive to where the interference is coming from. Improving the channel between the interferer and a harvesting node helps, but improving the channel between the interferer and a receiving node hurts.
  • AF vs. DF: The paper compares their AF model to existing Decode-and-Forward (DF) models. They found that AF is actually superior when the interference is moderate or weak because it avoids the "hard" decoding errors that plague DF in those regimes.

Key Results

  • Analytical Accuracy: The derived "lower-bound" expressions for throughput proved to be extremely tight, matching simulation results almost perfectly across all values of $\tau$.
  • Optimal Timing: The results show a clear "bell curve" for the harvesting time $\tau$. If $\tau$ is too small, there isn't enough power; if it's too large, there isn't enough time left to send data.
  • Mode Comparison:
    • Mode I (Source harvesting) generally performs best when interference is low.
  • Mode III (Dual harvesting) is the most robust and becomes the superior choice in high-interference environments.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several areas for expansion:

  • Single Interferer: The model assumes one dominant ambient interferer. Real-world scenarios often involve a "field" of multiple interference sources.
  • Fading Models: The study is limited to Rayleigh fading. Future work could explore more complex environments like Nakagami-$m$ or Rician fading.
  • CSI Assumptions: The paper assumes perfect Channel State Information (CSI) at the receivers, which is difficult to achieve in highly interference-prone environments.
  • Hardware Impairments: The impact of non-ideal hardware (e.g., non-linear energy harvesters) was not considered in this specific analysis.

Summary updated

Abstract

This paper considers an interference-based radio-frequency energy harvesting (RF-EH)-empowered wireless dual-hop amplify-and-forward relaying system in which an ambient interferer is beneficially utilized as the solely free power source for EH and detrimentally considered as the dominant factor that corrupts its receivers. Three EH modes are considered and analyzed separately. In mode I, energy is harvested only by the source; in mode II, energy is harvested only by the relay; and in mode III, energy is harvested concurrently by both the source and relay. Under these modes, exact and approximate analytical expressions are derived for the system's outage probability, which are directly used to determine the system's delay-limited throughput as a performance figure of merit. Thorough numerical and simulation results are presented to verify the analytical work and to demonstrate the system's throughput performance under different system and channel parameters. For example, results reveal that for given channel conditions, increasing the interferer's power reduces the throughput in case of modes I and II, and has no effect on it in case of mode III. Also, for given interferer's power, improving the channel conditions between the interferer and a harvesting node, improves the throughput, while improving them between the interferer and a receiving node, degrades the throughput.
BibTeX
@article{khattabi2024performance,
  author = {Yazid M. Khattabi and Yazan H. Al-Badarneh and Mohamed‐Slim Alouini},
  title = {{On the Performance of Interference-Based Energy-Harvesting-Enabled Wireless AF Relaying Communication Systems}},
  journal = {IEEE Open Journal of Vehicular Technology},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.1109/ojvt.2024.3373721},
}
Figure