On the Latency, Rate, and Reliability Tradeoff in Wireless Networked Control Systems for IIoT

Wanchun Liu, Girish N. Nair, Yonghui Li, Dragan Nesic, Branka Vucetic, H. Vincent Poor

TL;DR

This paper tackles the critical challenge of balancing latency, data rate, and reliability in wireless networked control systems (WNCSs) for Industrial IoT (IIoT). By developing a detailed model that captures the interplay of these communication parameters, the authors derive the stability region for WNCSs and analyze their performance, offering crucial insights for designing optimal communication strategies in these systems.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Industrial Internet of Things (IIoT) applications heavily rely on wireless networked control systems (WNCSs) for tasks ranging from industrial automation to smart grids. Unlike traditional wired systems that offer high reliability and low latency, WNCSs must contend with the inherent limitations of wireless communication. Existing research often oversimplifies wireless channel models, neglecting the crucial interplay between latency, data rate, and reliability. This oversight hinders the ability to design WNCSs that are both stable and performant, especially for mission-critical applications. This paper aims to bridge this gap by providing a comprehensive analysis of WNCS stability and performance under realistic wireless communication constraints.

Methods

The authors propose a detailed model for a scalar WNCS that incorporates a realistic wireless communication channel. Key methodological contributions include:

  • Inter-related Communication Parameter Model: Instead of treating latency, data rate, and reliability (quantized by error probability $\epsilon$) in isolation, the paper models them as interconnected parameters, reflecting real-world trade-offs. This is achieved by leveraging finite blocklength information theory to relate these parameters.
  • Stability Region Derivation: The paper derives the stability region of the WNCS, defining the set of communication parameter tuples (blocklength $n$, data rate $R$) for which the system remains stable in the mean-square sense. This analysis considers both ideal and practical quantization methods.
  • Zooming Quantizer: For practical WNCSs, a novel "zooming quantizer" is introduced. This quantizer adaptively adjusts its range based on the success or failure of codeword decoding, allowing for more efficient handling of wide-ranging control signals.
  • Performance Analysis (Average Cost Function): The paper analyzes the average cost function, a key performance metric, which is challenging due to the non-linear nature of quantizers. Tight upper and lower bounds for this cost function are derived, providing insights into system performance.
  • Stability Region Characterization: The paper investigates conditions under which the stability region is "n-bounded" (meaning stability is achievable for any blocklength $n$) or "n-unbounded."

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The paper focuses on theoretical analysis and simulation-based results rather than training or evaluating on specific datasets.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Counter-Intuitive Stability: A plant can be stabilized with an arbitrarily large blocklength (high latency) as long as the Signal-to-Noise Ratio (SNR) of the wireless channel is sufficiently high. This is a surprising result, as one might expect increased latency to always degrade stability.
  • The Cost of Stability: While high latency can enable stability, it comes at the cost of a potentially very high average cost (performance degradation). This highlights that stability alone is not sufficient; performance must also be considered.
  • Interdependence is Key: The stability and performance of WNCSs are critically dependent on the joint design of communication parameters (latency, rate, reliability), not just individual optimization.
  • Zooming Quantizer's Role: The proposed zooming quantizer is crucial for practical WNCSs, enabling adaptive range adjustment to handle dynamic control signals and improving the feasibility of stability analysis.
  • Trade-offs are Inherent: The paper clearly illustrates the fundamental trade-offs between latency, data rate, and reliability, showing how these influence both the possibility of stabilization and the overall system performance.

Key Results

  • Stability Region: The paper derives explicit conditions for the stability region of the WNCS in terms of communication parameters ($n$, $R$, $\epsilon$) for both ideal and practical scenarios.
  • n-Bounded vs. n-Unbounded Regions: Conditions are established for when the stability region is n-bounded or n-unbounded, linking this behavior to SNR levels.
  • Performance Bounds: Tight upper and lower bounds for the average cost function are derived, providing a quantitative measure of system performance.
  • Numerical Illustrations: Figures demonstrate the stability regions for different SNR values and illustrate the behavior of the average cost function with varying blocklength and data rate, confirming the analytical findings. For instance, Figure 8 shows a contour plot of the average cost, revealing regions where the cost is minimized.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Scalar System Assumption: The analysis is primarily focused on scalar WNCSs. Extending these results to multi-dimensional systems would be a valuable next step.
  • Fading Channels: The current model assumes an AWGN channel. Investigating WNCSs operating over fading channels is identified as an area for future research.
  • Energy Consumption: The paper suggests exploring the energy consumption of the controller and actuator as additional objectives for optimization, leading to a multi-objective optimization problem.
  • Vector Plant Systems: The authors mention that extending the work to vector plant systems is of interest.
  • Computational Complexity: The practical WNCS with the zooming quantizer requires significant computation for adaptive range updating. Future work might explore more computationally efficient solutions.

Summary updated

Abstract

Wireless networked control systems (WNCSs) provide a key enabling technique for Industrial Internet of Things (IIoT). However, in the literature of WNCSs, most of the research focuses on the control perspective and has considered oversimplified models of wireless communications that do not capture the key parameters of a practical wireless communication system, such as latency, data rate, and reliability. In this article, we focus on a WNCS, where a controller transmits quantized and encoded control codewords to a remote actuator through a wireless channel, and adopt a detailed model of the wireless communication system, which jointly considers the interrelated communication parameters. We derive the stability region of the WNCS. If and only if the tuple of the communication parameters lies in the region, the average cost function, i.e., a performance metric of the WNCS, is bounded. We further obtain a necessary and sufficient condition under which the stability region is n -bounded, where n is the control codeword blocklength. We also analyze the average cost function of the WNCS. Such analysis is nontrivial because the finite-bit control-signal quantizer introduces a nonlinear and discontinuous quantization function that makes the performance analysis very difficult. We derive tight upper and lower bounds on the average cost function in terms of latency, data rate, and reliability. Our analytical results provide important insights into the design of the optimal parameters to minimize the average cost within the stability region.
BibTeX
@article{liu2021latency,
  author = {Wanchun Liu and Girish N. Nair and Yonghui Li and Dragan Nesic and Branka Vucetic and H. Vincent Poor},
  title = {{On the Latency, Rate, and Reliability Tradeoff in Wireless Networked Control Systems for IIoT}},
  journal = {IEEE Internet of Things Journal},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.1109/jiot.2020.3007070},
}
Figure