On the Importance of Registers for Computability

Rati Gelashvili, Mohsen Ghaffari, Jerry Li, Nir Shavit

TL;DR

This paper questions the necessity of unbounded registers in existing consensus hierarchies, exploring what happens when they are removed. The authors demonstrate that certain objects, like queues and stacks, cannot emulate registers, and that initialization becomes crucial for computability in a register-less environment.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The field of distributed computing has established "consensus hierarchies" that classify the power of different synchronization objects (like queues, stacks, etc.) based on their ability to solve consensus problems (getting multiple processes to agree on a value). A standard assumption in these hierarchies is the availability of an unbounded number of read-write registers. This paper challenges this assumption: Why are these registers so essential? What if we try to solve consensus without them? The authors aim to understand the true synchronization power of objects when registers are removed, and how factors like the number of objects and their initial states influence this power.

Methods

The paper introduces the concept of "consistent sets," a general class of objects that includes queues, stacks, and priority queues. They then explore various scenarios:

  • Consensus with limited objects and no registers: They prove that a single queue (or consistent set) initialized in a specific "lucky" state can solve two-process consensus, but an empty queue cannot. This highlights the critical role of initialization.
  • Consensus with multiple objects and no registers: They show that two queues (or consistent sets) are sufficient to solve two-process consensus, even with arbitrary initial states.
  • Test-and-Set without registers: A key result is the impossibility of implementing an isolation-bounded test-and-set object (a simpler agreement problem) for an unbounded number of processes using only empty queues or stacks. This is proven using a novel "diagonalization" technique to construct interleaved executions that processes cannot distinguish from their solo runs.
  • Test-and-Set with registers: They confirm that with the addition of registers, implementing test-and-set for an unbounded number of processes becomes possible, leveraging existing constructions and their own results for two-process consensus.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Initialization is King (Without Registers): The paper reveals that when registers are absent, the initial state of an object can drastically alter its computability. An empty queue is useless for consensus, but a queue with a single element (a "lucky" state) can be powerful.
  • Queues/Stacks Can't Emulate Registers: A surprising finding is that even an unbounded number of empty queues or stacks cannot replicate the functionality of a single read-write register in an isolation-bounded setting. This suggests registers offer a fundamental advantage.
  • Rethinking Consensus Hierarchies: The work questions whether existing consensus hierarchies, which assume unbounded registers, truly capture the inherent synchronization power of objects. The findings suggest a need to re-evaluate these hierarchies in register-less models.
  • Novel Proof Techniques: The paper introduces a new technique for proving lower bounds in shared-memory systems by constructing interleaved executions that are indistinguishable from solo executions, using a form of diagonalization.

Key Results

  • Impossibility Results:
    • It's impossible to solve two-process consensus with a single consistent set object initialized in an empty state.
  • It's impossible to implement an isolation-bounded test-and-set object for an unbounded number of processes using only empty queues or stacks.
  • It's impossible to implement an isolation-bounded read-write register using any number of empty queues or stacks.
  • Possibility Results:
    • Two-process consensus is solvable with a single consistent set object if it's initialized in a "lucky" state (containing a single item).
  • Two-process consensus is solvable with two consistent set objects, regardless of their initial states.
  • Test-and-set for an unbounded number of processes is possible using consistent set objects and read-write registers.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge that their proofs often rely on the axiom of countable choice. They also suggest that their work opens a new line of research into understanding the interaction between memory models and synchronization operations, particularly in the context of modern architectures. Future work could explore the precise conditions under which objects can emulate registers or achieve higher levels of consensus without them.

Summary updated

Abstract

All consensus hierarchies in the literature assume that we have, in addition to copies of a given object, an unbounded number of registers. But why do we really need these registers?
BibTeX
@inproceedings{gelashvili2014importance,
  author = {Rati Gelashvili and Mohsen Ghaffari and Jerry Li and Nir Shavit},
  title = {{On the Importance of Registers for Computability}},
  booktitle = {OPODIS},
  year = {2014},
  url = {https://openreview.net/forum?id=iErtjthklk},
}

Loading related content...

Figure