On the ghost problem of conformal gravity

Anamaria Hell, Dieter Lüst, George Zoupanos

TL;DR

This paper tackles the "ghost problem" in Conformal Gravity, a theoretical issue that leads to instabilities. By carefully analyzing boundary conditions for de Sitter and Minkowski spacetimes, the authors show how to eliminate these ghosts and recover the well-behaved predictions of Einstein's gravity.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Conformal Gravity (CG) is an intriguing alternative to Einstein's theory of gravity, offering potential solutions to problems like dark matter. However, CG suffers from a significant theoretical pathology: the presence of "ghosts." These are problematic degrees of freedom that lead to an unbounded energy spectrum and classical instabilities. While a previous proposal by Maldacena suggested that specific boundary conditions could resolve this issue by making CG equivalent to Einstein's gravity with a cosmological constant (EΛ) in de Sitter (dS) space, this approach left some questions unanswered and only yielded particular solutions. This paper aims to provide a more complete resolution by finding boundary conditions that not only remove the ghosts but also yield general solutions for both dS and Minkowski spacetimes, thus establishing a robust equivalence with Einstein's gravity.

Methods

The authors employ a perturbation theory approach, analyzing the behavior of metric perturbations around both de Sitter and Minkowski backgrounds. They leverage the Starobinsky expansion, a method for describing the asymptotic structure of an expanding universe, to systematically analyze the metric coefficients. A key part of their methodology involves deriving and applying specific boundary conditions. For the de Sitter case, they build upon Maldacena's Neumann Boundary Condition (NBC) by introducing an additional condition to ensure a general solution. For the Minkowski case, they discover that the NBC is insufficient and instead derive "alternative boundary conditions" (ABC) that successfully remove the ghosts and yield a general solution.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Ghosts are inherent but solvable: The paper confirms that ghosts are a feature of Conformal Gravity across different spacetimes, but crucially, they are not insurmountable.
  • Boundary conditions are key: The central theme is that the choice of boundary conditions is paramount in resolving the ghost problem and establishing an equivalence with Einstein's gravity.
  • Maldacena's NBC is a good start, but not enough for Minkowski: While the Neumann Boundary Condition is effective in de Sitter space, it fails to provide a general solution in Minkowski space, necessitating a new approach.
  • Alternative Boundary Conditions (ABC) for Minkowski: The introduction of ABC is a significant development, allowing for a general solution in Minkowski space and a complete removal of ghosts.
  • Breaking conformal invariance is necessary: The conditions derived to select the de Sitter background actively break the conformal invariance of CG, which is essential for singling out a specific spacetime.

Key Results

  • In the de Sitter case, the authors derive an additional condition alongside the Neumann Boundary Condition that leads to a general solution for metric perturbations, matching those of Einstein's gravity with a cosmological constant.
  • In the Minkowski case, the Neumann Boundary Condition alone does not yield a general solution. However, the newly derived "alternative boundary conditions" successfully remove the ghosts and provide a general solution that aligns with Einstein's gravity.
  • The paper demonstrates that by imposing specific conditions, Conformal Gravity can be reduced to Einstein's gravity with a cosmological constant (and a Gauss-Bonnet term in the de Sitter case), effectively removing the problematic ghost degrees of freedom at a classical level.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Classical level analysis: The paper focuses on classical solutions and does not delve into the quantum aspects of the ghost problem.
  • Future work: The authors suggest extending this procedure to other higher-derivative gravity theories and incorporating additional matter sources. They also hint at further investigation into the role of the Gauss-Bonnet term.

Summary updated

Abstract

A bstract We study the metric perturbations around the de Sitter and Minkowski backgrounds in Conformal Gravity. We confirm the presence of ghosts in both cases. In the de Sitter case, by applying the Maldacena boundary conditions — the Neumann boundary condition and the positive-frequency mode condition — to the metric, we show that one cannot recover a general solution for the perturbations. In turn, alongside the Neumann boundary condition, we derive an additional condition with which the perturbations of conformal gravity and dS perturbations of Einstein gravity with cosmological constant coincide. We further show that the Neumann boundary condition does not lead to a general solution in Minkowski space. Conversely, we derive the alternative boundary conditions, with which we attain an agreement between the perturbations of conformal and Einstein gravity in full generality, thus removing the ghost of conformal gravity.
BibTeX
@article{hell2023ghost,
  author = {Anamaria Hell and Dieter Lüst and George Zoupanos},
  title = {{On the ghost problem of conformal gravity}},
  journal = {Journal of High Energy Physics},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.1007/jhep08(2023)168},
}
Figure