On the Generalization Capacities of Neural Controlled Differential Equations

Linus Bleistein, Agathe Guilloux

Abstract

Neural Controlled Differential Equations (NCDEs) have emerged as a robust solution for modeling irregularly sampled time series by treating them as discretizations of underlying continuous paths. Despite their empirical success, the theoretical impact of sampling density on their generalization performance has remained poorly understood. This paper establishes a rigorous framework to quantify the "discretization bias" inherent in learning from discrete data. By leveraging the continuity of the flow of controlled differential equations, the authors decompose the generalization gap into components representing model complexity, discretization bias, and approximation bias. Their findings prove that discretization error vanishes linearly as sampling frequency increases, providing a theoretical foundation for the application of NCDEs to real-world, irregularly sampled data.

Introduction: The Challenge of Irregular Sampling

In many practical applications, such as intensive care monitoring or environmental sensing, measurements are taken at irregular intervals. NCDEs handle this by interpolating discrete points into a continuous path that "drives" a latent differential equation. However, most machine learning theory assumes either purely discrete or regularly sampled data. This paper addresses the gap by investigating how the act of sampling a continuous process into discrete points affects a model's ability to generalize to the true, unobserved continuous trajectory.

Theoretical Framework: Decomposing the Generalization Gap

The authors treat the problem through a generative lens, assuming a "true" underlying predictor defined by a CDE with an unknown vector field. To bound the error, they decompose the total generalization gap into three primary parts:

  1. Rademacher Complexity: The standard measure of how much a model class can overfit a finite dataset.
  2. Discretization Bias: The inherent error introduced by learning from a finite set of points rather than the true continuous path.
  3. Approximation Bias: The cost of using a neural network to approximate the "true" physics or dynamics of the system.
Visualization of the continuous path evolution and flow in an NCDE framework.

A key technical insight is the use of Flow Continuity. The authors leverage the mathematical property that the solution (flow) of a CDE is continuous with respect to its driving signal. This allows them to prove that if the sampled path is close to the true path, the NCDE solution will remain close to the true solution.

Key Results: Linear Vanishing Bias

The centerpiece of the research is Theorem 4.3, which provides a formal upper bound on the difference between the risk of a learned NCDE and the true predictor. A major practical takeaway is that the discretization bias vanishes at a linear speed relative to the maximum gap between sampling times ($|D|$). Essentially, doubling the sampling frequency roughly halves this specific component of the error.

To validate these bounds, the authors utilized a Synthetic Teacher-Student Setup. A "teacher" NCDE generates ground truth paths, while a "student" NCDE attempts to learn the dynamics from downsampled versions. The experiments demonstrated a clear positive correlation between the sampling gap and the generalization error, confirming that the model's ability to recover the true dynamics degrades exactly as the theory predicts.

Conclusion and Future Work

This work provides the first comprehensive generalization bounds for NCDEs that explicitly account for irregular sampling. While the current theory focuses on shallow neural networks for mathematical clarity, the logic suggests that the linear relationship between sampling density and error holds for deeper architectures as well. Future research may explore the trade-offs between latent space dimensionality and overfitting, further refining our understanding of how these models scale with complex, high-dimensional time series.

Summary updated

Abstract

We consider a supervised learning setup in which the goal is to predicts an outcome from a sample of irregularly sampled time series using Neural Controlled Differential Equations (Kidger, Morrill, et al. 2020). In our framework, the time series is a discretization of an unobserved continuous path, and the outcome depends on this path through a controlled differential equation with unknown vector field. Learning with discrete data thus induces a discretization bias, which we precisely quantify. Using theoretical results on the continuity of the flow of controlled differential equations, we show that the approximation bias is directly related to the approximation error of a Lipschitz function defining the generative model by a shallow neural network. By combining these result with recent work linking the Lipschitz constant of neural networks to their generalization capacities, we upper bound the generalization gap between the expected loss attained by the empirical risk minimizer and the expected loss of the true predictor.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{bleistein2024generalization,
  author = {Linus Bleistein and Agathe Guilloux},
  title = {{On the Generalization Capacities of Neural Controlled Differential Equations}},
  booktitle = {International Conference on Learning Representations},
  year = {2024},
  url = {https://openreview.net/forum?id=kILAd8RdzA},
}
Figure