On the Diameter of Lattice Polytopes

Alberto Del Pia, Carla Michini

TL;DR

This paper tackles the problem of bounding the "diameter" of lattice polytopes, which are geometric shapes with integer vertices. The authors establish a new, tighter upper bound for the diameter of a specific class of these shapes, called (0,k)-polytopes, and show this bound is tight for a related class of half-integral polytopes. This work is significant for understanding the complexity of problems involving integer programming and combinatorial optimization.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The paper investigates the diameter of lattice polytopes. Imagine a polytope (a multi-dimensional shape with flat sides) whose corners (vertices) all have integer coordinates. The "diameter" of such a polytope isn't the usual geometric distance, but rather the length of the longest shortest path between any two vertices along the edges of the polytope. This is known as the 1-skeleton diameter.

Understanding this diameter is crucial because it relates to how "complex" or "difficult" it might be to navigate or solve problems defined on these polytopes, particularly in areas like integer programming and combinatorial optimization. Previous work had established bounds on this diameter, but they weren't always tight, especially for certain types of polytopes. This paper aims to refine these bounds, providing a more precise understanding of the maximum possible diameter for a class of polytopes called (0,k)-polytopes (those contained within the hypercube $[0,k]^d$ and having integer vertices).

Methods

The core of the paper's contribution lies in a new proof for an upper bound on the diameter of d-dimensional (0,k)-polytopes. The proof uses a combination of:

  • Induction: The authors prove the result for dimension $d$ by relying on the proven results for dimensions less than $d$.
  • Linear Programming and Polyhedral Theory: They leverage fundamental concepts from these fields, particularly focusing on distances to faces of polytopes.
  • Lemma 2: A key lemma establishes an upper bound on the distance between a vertex and a face of a lattice polytope, using a specific integral vector $c$. This lemma is generalized beyond the simple coordinate vectors used in prior work.
  • Constructive Proof: The proof is not just theoretical; it outlines how to construct a path between any two vertices whose length is within the derived bound.

The paper also introduces several claims that simplify the proof by allowing assumptions about the polytope's properties (e.g., being full-dimensional, intersecting certain facets, or having specific vertex sums). These claims are proven rigorously, reducing the problem to a more manageable set of cases.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Refined Diameter Bound: The most significant insight is the new upper bound for the diameter of d-dimensional (0,k)-polytopes: $\lfloor (k - \frac{1}{2})d \rfloor$. This is a tighter bound than previously known for $k \ge 2$.
  • Tightness for Half-Integral Polytopes: The paper demonstrates that this bound is not just theoretical but is actually achieved by certain types of polytopes. Specifically, for (0,2)-polytopes, the bound $\lfloor \frac{3}{2}d \rfloor$ is shown to be tight for any dimension $d$. This is important because (0,2)-polytopes are closely related to "half-integral polytopes," which appear frequently in combinatorial optimization.
  • Importance of Face Distances: The proof's reliance on Lemma 2, which bounds distances to polytope faces using arbitrary integral vectors, highlights a powerful technique for analyzing polytope diameters. This approach is more general than previous methods that only considered coordinate vectors.
  • Strategic Simplifications: The claims made in the proof (e.g., assuming $u+v = k\mathbf{1}$ or $u \in \{0,k\}^d$) are clever ways to reduce the complexity of the problem without losing generality, making the inductive step more tractable.

Key Results

  • Theorem 1: For $k \ge 2$, the diameter of a $d$-dimensional (0,k)-polytope is at most $\lfloor (k - \frac{1}{2})d \rfloor$.
  • Corollary 2: The diameter of a $d$-dimensional (0,2)-polytope is at most $\lfloor \frac{3}{2}d \rfloor$. Moreover, this bound is tight for any natural number $d$, meaning there exist (0,2)-polytopes that achieve this maximum diameter.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Tightness for $k \ge 3$: The authors acknowledge that their upper bound, and the previously known bound by Kleinschmidt and Onn, are not tight for $k \ge 3$. While their new bound is better, it doesn't fully close the gap for these cases.
  • Asymptotic Behavior: The paper discusses the asymptotic behavior of the diameter function $d_k^d$ (the maximum diameter of a (0,k)-polytope of dimension at most $d$). They note that while their approach yields a linear upper bound in $k$ and $d$, existing constructions provide a lower bound that grows as a fractional power of $k$ and linearly in $d$. This suggests a significant gap remains in understanding the precise asymptotic behavior.
  • Further Directions: The authors suggest that studying the asymptotic behavior of $d_k^d$ is an interesting direction for future research, aiming to bridge the gap between the current lower and upper bounds. They also imply that their current approach might not be easily refined to achieve a tight bound for general $k \ge 3$.

Summary updated

Abstract

In this paper we show that the diameter of a d-dimensional lattice polytope in $$[0,k]^n$$ [ 0 , k ] n is at most $${\lfloor }{\left( k-\frac{1}{2}\right) d}{\rfloor }$$ ⌊ k - 1 2 d ⌋ . This result implies that the diameter of a d-dimensional half-integral polytope is at most $${\lfloor }{\frac{3}{2} d}{\rfloor }$$ ⌊ 3 2 d ⌋ . We also show that for half-integral polytopes the latter bound is tight for any d.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{pia2016diameter,
  author = {Alberto Del Pia and Carla Michini},
  title = {{On the Diameter of Lattice Polytopes}},
  booktitle = {Discret. Comput. Geom},
  year = {2016},
  url = {https://openreview.net/forum?id=uCqlYCUPdF6},
}
Figure