On the cosmological degrees of freedom of Proca field with non-minimal coupling to gravity

Antonio De Felice, Anamaria Hell

TL;DR

This paper investigates a modified Proca theory of massive vector fields coupled non-minimally to gravity. The authors discover that this theory, under specific conditions, propagates an extra degree of freedom beyond the standard ones, leading to intriguing phenomena like vanishing propagation speeds and strong coupling regimes. This finding has implications for understanding dark matter and the early universe.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The standard model of particle physics includes vector fields, like photons, which are massless and gauge-invariant. However, extensions to this model, such as massive vector fields (Proca fields) or theories with non-minimal couplings to gravity, are explored to address cosmological puzzles like dark matter and the accelerated expansion of the universe. A key challenge in these extended theories is understanding their stability and the number of propagating degrees of freedom. Generalized Proca theories are designed to avoid extra degrees of freedom, but this paper explores a more general Proca theory with non-minimal couplings to gravity, questioning whether these theories inherently introduce additional, potentially problematic, degrees of freedom.

Methods

The authors employ a standard approach in theoretical cosmology: perturbing the metric and the vector field around a background solution and analyzing the resulting linearized equations of motion. They specifically examine two cosmological backgrounds: the homogeneous and isotropic Friedmann-Lemaître-Robertson-Walker (FLRW) universe and the more general anisotropic Bianchi Type I universe. By expanding the action to second order in perturbations and performing detailed algebraic manipulations, they derive the equations of motion for various modes (scalar, vector, and tensor). They then analyze these equations to identify the number of propagating degrees of freedom, check for instabilities (no-ghost conditions), and determine the speeds of propagation for each mode.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Emergence of an Extra Degree of Freedom: The non-minimal coupling of the Proca field to gravity, particularly with a non-vanishing background value for the temporal component of the vector field ($A_0$), leads to an additional propagating degree of freedom. This is a departure from generalized Proca theories, which are constructed to avoid this.
  • Vanishing Speed of Propagation: A striking finding is that this extra scalar mode exhibits a vanishing speed of propagation ($c_s = 0$). This is a strong indicator of strong coupling, suggesting that higher-order terms in the theory might become dominant and invalidate the linearized analysis.
  • Strong Coupling Regimes: The theory exhibits several strong coupling regimes. These can arise from the value of the background solution ($A_0$), the specific combination or vanishing of coupling constants ($\beta_1, \beta_2$), and even scale-dependent effects.
  • Anisotropy Reveals More: Extending the analysis to the Bianchi Type I universe, which is anisotropic, confirms the presence of the extra degree of freedom. It also reveals new phenomena, including a scale-dependent strong coupling and modes that propagate in only one direction.
  • Instabilities: The presence of instabilities (e.g., tachyonic instabilities) is observed, particularly in the anisotropic case, suggesting that the theory might require specific parameter choices or backgrounds to be physically viable.

Key Results

  • In the FLRW universe, the theory propagates six modes: two scalar, two vector, and two tensor.
  • The extra scalar mode has a vanishing speed of propagation, indicating strong coupling.
  • In the Bianchi Type I universe, the extra scalar mode persists, and new strong coupling phenomena are observed, including scale-dependent strong coupling and directional propagation.
  • The no-ghost conditions (ensuring stability) are analyzed for different modes, revealing parameter spaces where the theory is stable.
  • The speed of propagation for vector and tensor modes is generally modified by the Ricci tensor coupling, unlike the Ricci scalar coupling which tends to preserve unity.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge that the vanishing speed of propagation for the extra scalar mode suggests that the linearized analysis might not be trustworthy, and non-linear terms could be crucial. They suggest that studying more general backgrounds or considering non-linear effects could be necessary to fully understand this phenomenon. The paper also points out that while the Bianchi Type I analysis provides more insight, the complexity of the equations necessitates studying specific parameter values. Future work could involve a more comprehensive scan of the parameter space and a deeper investigation into the implications of these strong coupling regimes and instabilities for cosmological models. The possibility of a Vainshtein-like mechanism hiding the strong coupling issue is also mentioned as an avenue for future research.

Summary updated

Abstract

A bstract We study Proca theory with non-minimal coupling to gravity through the Ricci tensor and Ricci scalar interactions. We show that in the homogeneous and isotropic Universe together with cosmological constant, the temporal component of the vector field acquires a background value. As a result, we show that the theory propagates an additional degree of freedom, with respect to the generalized Proca theories, whose kinetic term suggests the presence of several strong coupling regimes that depend on the value of the background solution, the combination and vanishing of coupling constants, together with a scale-dependent one. We show in addition, that the speed of propagation for this mode vanishes, indicating the presence of a another type of strong coupling. To further investigate this, we extend our analysis to the Bianchi Type I Universe, with the most general solution for the vector field. We show that the extra degree of freedom remains in the theory. Among the modes, we further show that the mode with vanishing speed of propagation is still present, pointing to the strong coupling. In addition, we discover a mode with scale-dependent strong coupling (vanishing kinetic term), one mode that propagates only in one single direction and two unstable modes.
BibTeX
@article{felice2025cosmological,
  author = {Antonio De Felice and Anamaria Hell},
  title = {{On the cosmological degrees of freedom of Proca field with non-minimal coupling to gravity}},
  journal = {Journal of High Energy Physics},
  year = {2025},
  doi = {10.1007/jhep07(2025)228},
}
Figure