On the convergence rate of distributed gradient methods for finite-sum optimization under communication delays

Thinh T. Doan, Carolyn L. Beck, R. Srikant

Abstract

In this paper, we study distributed optimization problems over a network of nodes, where the goal is to optimize a global objective composed of a sum of local functions. For solving such optimization problems, we are interested in a popular distributed gradient-based consensus algorithm, which only requires local computation and communication. A significant challenge in this area is to analyze the convergence rate of such algorithms in the presence of communication delays that are inevitable in distributed systems. We provide convergence results and convergence rate estimates of the gradient-based consensus algorithm in the presence of uniform, but possibly arbitrarily large, communication delays between the nodes. Our results explicitly characterize the rate of convergence of the algorithm as a function of the network size, topology, and the inter-node communication delays.

Introduction

In the era of Big Data, optimization problems—such as training large-scale machine learning models—often exceed the processing capacity of a single machine. To address this, workloads are distributed across a network of processors. Each node in the network computes a local portion of the objective function and communicates with its neighbors to reach a global consensus on the optimal solution.

However, real-world distributed systems are rarely instantaneous. Hardware limitations and network congestion introduce communication delays (latencies) that can significantly impact performance. While most classical theoretical models assume zero-delay communication, this paper addresses the critical gap of how these inevitable delays affect the speed and reliability of distributed optimization. Specifically, we investigate whether convergence can still be guaranteed when delays are arbitrarily large and how the convergence rate scales with the magnitude of those delays.

The Distributed Gradient-Based Consensus Algorithm

The study focuses on a distributed gradient-based consensus algorithm. In this framework, each node $i$ maintains a local estimate of the solution. At each iteration, the node updates its estimate through two primary actions:

  1. Consensus Update: The node calculates a weighted average of its current estimate and the delayed estimates received from its neighbors.
  2. Innovation Update: The node takes a step in the direction of the negative gradient of its local cost function (the gradient step).

Mathematical Innovation: Razumikhin-Krasovskii Lyapunov Functional

Analyzing systems with delays is mathematically complex because the system's state depends on its history, not just its current value. Standard stability analysis tools often fail when such "memory" is introduced. To overcome this, we employ a Razumikhin-Krasovskii Lyapunov functional. Unlike standard Lyapunov functions, this functional includes an integral term that accounts for the system's history over the delay interval $[t-\tau, t]$. This approach allows for a rigorous bounding of the error introduced by the stale information circulating through the network.

Convergence Analysis and Key Insights

Our theoretical analysis yields several critical insights into the behavior of distributed optimization under latency:

1. Asymptotic Convergence

We prove that delays are asymptotically negligible if the step size (learning rate) is chosen to decay at a rate of $1/\sqrt{t}$. Under this condition, the nodes will eventually reach the correct global optimum regardless of the delay magnitude, provided the delay is uniform across the network.

2. The Cubic Cost of Latency

The most significant finding is the explicit characterization of the convergence rate: $$O\left(\frac{n\tau^3 \ln(t)}{(1-\gamma)^2 \sqrt{t}}\right)$$ This formula reveals that the "penalty" for communication delay $\tau$ is cubic. For example, doubling the network latency could potentially increase the time required to reach a specific accuracy threshold eightfold. This $O(\tau^3)$ relationship provides a concrete metric for system architects to evaluate the trade-offs between network speed and optimization time.

3. The Role of Network Topology

The term $(1-\gamma)$ represents the spectral gap or algebraic connectivity of the network. Our results confirm that well-connected networks (high algebraic connectivity) are significantly more resilient to delays than sparse or "stringy" networks. In well-connected topologies, information spreads more efficiently, mitigating the impact of stale data.

Empirical Validation

To validate these theoretical findings, we conducted simulations using synthetic datasets for a linear regression task. The goal was to solve a distributed least-squares problem across randomly generated connected graphs with 30, 40, and 50 nodes.

  • Distributed Gradient (DG) vs. Distributed Dual Averaging (DA): In head-to-head comparisons, the DG method consistently outperformed DA. Even under significant delays, the DG algorithm required fewer iterations to reach a target error threshold (e.g., an error of 0.2).
  • Verification of Cubic Scaling: The simulations confirmed the $O(\tau^3)$ relationship. As the delay steps were increased from 0 to 10, the number of iterations required for convergence grew following a cubic curve, matching our theoretical predictions.

Conclusion and Future Work

This research provides the first explicit convergence rate analysis for distributed gradient-based optimization in the presence of uniform communication delays. While we have shown that convergence is guaranteed and characterized the cubic impact of latency, several avenues for future research remain.

Currently, the model assumes uniform and constant delays. Real-world networks often exhibit heterogeneous delays (where different links have different latencies) or time-varying delays. Extending this analysis to asynchronous distributed gradient algorithms and investigating the behavior of adaptive step-size methods (like Adam) in delayed environments are the next major steps in this field.

Summary updated

Abstract

Motivated by applications in machine learning and statistics, we study distributed optimization problems over a network of processors, where the goal is to optimize a global objective composed of a sum of local functions. In these problems, due to the large scale of the data sets, the data and computation must be distributed over processors resulting in the need for distributed algorithms. In this paper, we consider a popular distributed gradient-based consensus algorithm, which only requires local computation and communication. An important problem in this area is to analyze the convergence rate of such algorithms in the presence of communication delays that are inevitable in distributed systems. We prove the convergence of the gradient-based consensus algorithm in the presence of uniform, but possibly arbitrarily large, communication delays between the processors. Moreover, we obtain an upper bound on the rate of convergence of the algorithm as a function of the network size, topology, and the inter-processor communication delays.
BibTeX
@article{doan2018convergence,
  author = {Thinh T. Doan and Carolyn L. Beck and R. Srikant},
  title = {{On the convergence rate of distributed gradient methods for finite-sum optimization under communication delays}},
  journal = {ACM SIGMETRICS Performance Evaluation Review},
  year = {2018},
  doi = {10.1145/3292040.3219654},
}
Figure