On the Anomaly of the Specific Heat at High Temperatures in α Phase Alloys of Copper and Zinc

Hakaru Masumoto, Hideo Saitô, Makoto SugiharaJournal of the Japan Institute of Metals and Materials 1952 · DOI

Abstract

The specific heat of seven alloys in the solid solution range of the copper-zinc system was measured in both annealed and quenched states using an inverse rate curve method. The specific heat-temperature curves generally exhibit a slight anomaly between 200°C and 260°C, which is most pronounced in the alloy containing 30.35% zinc. While the temperatures of the "knick points" remain constant for alloys with less than 20.75% zinc, they decrease as zinc content increases further. This anomaly is suppressed by quenching from 500°C, suggesting it is linked to atomic ordering processes.

Introduction

In the field of metallurgy, α-phase copper-zinc alloys (brass) have long been known to exhibit unusual hardening when heated at temperatures below their recrystallization point (approximately 250°C). This phenomenon, often referred to as strain-aging hardening, was historically debated. While many researchers focused on the effects of deformation, the intrinsic thermodynamic behavior of annealed alloys remained less understood. This study investigates whether a fundamental change in the crystal lattice—detectable through specific heat measurements—could explain this hardening anomaly.

Experimental Methods

The researchers employed an inverse rate curve method to precisely measure the specific heat of seven Cu-Zn alloys. The experimental setup was designed for high sensitivity and stability.

Schematic diagram of the experimental apparatus used for specific heat measurements.

The apparatus featured a specimen housed within an "Isolite" vessel inside a silica tube, heated by a non-inductive furnace. To achieve the necessary precision, high-sensitivity Pt-Pt·Rh thermocouples and a potentiometer capable of detecting $10^{-7}$ Volts were utilized. The system was validated against pure Nickel, successfully reproducing the standard Ewart curve. Measurements were conducted on both annealed samples (slow-cooled at 30°C/hr) and quenched samples (rapidly cooled from 500°C).

Key Results and Observations

The primary finding of the study is the presence of a distinct "knick point" or bump in the specific heat curves of annealed alloys between 200°C and 260°C.

Specific heat curves for various Cu-Zn alloys showing the anomaly between 200°C and 260°C.

As shown in Figure 3, the intensity of this anomaly is highly dependent on the zinc concentration. It becomes increasingly conspicuous as the zinc content rises, peaking at 30.35% Zn. Furthermore, the temperature at which this anomaly occurs is constant for lower zinc concentrations but begins to shift downward once the zinc content exceeds 20.75%.

When the alloys were quenched from 500°C, the anomaly disappeared entirely. However, upon reheating these quenched samples, a small specific heat minimum appeared at 150°C, followed by a peak at 200°C. This suggests that the atoms begin to re-order themselves as soon as sufficient thermal energy is provided.

Discussion: The $Cu_3Zn$ Superstructure

The researchers conclude that the observed specific heat anomaly is caused by the formation of a short-range atomic superstructure, specifically $Cu_3Zn$. The relatively small energy change associated with the anomaly indicates that this is a short-range ordering process rather than a full long-range phase transition.

This thermodynamic evidence refutes alternative theories suggesting that the hardening is due to changes in the solubility limit of zinc in copper. Instead, the data supports the hypothesis that atomic rearrangement into an ordered state is the driving force behind the material's anomalous behavior at these temperatures.

Conclusion

This study provides the first systematic specific heat data for α-phase Cu-Zn alloys, confirming a thermodynamic anomaly between 200°C and 260°C. The results strongly support the existence of a $Cu_3Zn$ short-range order, providing a clear physical explanation for the low-temperature hardening of brass.

Summary updated

Abstract

The speci heat of the 7 a110ys insolid solution range of copper and zinc system was measured in annealed and quenched states by an inversate curve method The speci heattemperature curves of the alloys generaUy show a slight anomaly at about 200 to 260the anomaly is most conspicuous in the alloy cotaining 3035 percent of zinc And whiIe the temperatues of the knick points on the curves of the alloys contalningess than 2075 percent of zinc are almost constant they become lower when the content of zinc is increased to more than 2075 percent Thls anomaly can be prevented by quenching from 500 Thus it has been
BibTeX
@article{masumoto1952anomaly,
  author = {Hakaru Masumoto and Hideo Saitô and Makoto Sugihara},
  title = {{On the Anomaly of the Specific Heat at High Temperatures in \α Phase Alloys of Copper and Zinc}},
  journal = {Journal of the Japan Institute of Metals and Materials},
  year = {1952},
  doi = {10.2320/jinstmet1952.16.7\_359},
}
On the Anomaly of the Specific Heat at High Temperatures in α Phase Alloys of Iron and ChromiumJournal of the Japan Institute of Metals and Materials · 1952
On the Specific Heat of α Phase Alloys of Iron and CobaltJournal of the Japan Institute of Metals and Materials · 1953
Statistical theory of superlatticesProceedings of the Royal Society of London. Series A - Mathematical and Physical Sciences · 1935
Discovering short-range ordering in a medium entropy alloy via intelligent big dataResearch · 2022
On the Rigidiy Modulus and its Temperature Coefficient of the Alloys of Cobalt, Iron and ChromiumJournal of the Japan Institute of Metals and Materials · 1952
A New Type of Multivalued Ic–H CharacteristicJapanese · 1987
Figure