On sub-Riemannian geodesics within $SE(3)/(\{0\}\times SO(2))$ whose spatial projections do not have cusps

Remco Duits, Arpan Ghosh, Tom Dela Haije, Alexey Mashtakov

TL;DR

This paper tackles the problem of finding smooth 3D curves that minimize a combination of length and curvature, with fixed start and end points and directions. They achieve this by reformulating the problem in the context of sub-Riemannian geometry on the special Euclidean group SE(3), deriving explicit formulas for "cuspless" curves, and analyzing their geometric properties. This work is crucial for applications like image processing where smooth curve reconstruction is essential.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The core problem, dubbed $\mathbf{P_{curve}}$, is to find a 3D curve $\mathbf{x}(s)$ that minimizes the functional $E(\mathbf{x}) = \int_0^L \sqrt{\xi^2 + \kappa^2(s)} \, ds$, where $L$ is the curve's length, $\kappa(s)$ is its absolute curvature, and $\xi$ is a positive constant. This functional balances the curve's length with its "bendiness." The problem also requires the curve to connect a specific starting point and direction $(\mathbf{x}_0, \mathbf{n}_0)$ to a specific ending point and direction $(\mathbf{x}_1, \mathbf{n}_1)$.

This problem is motivated by applications in computer vision and medical imaging (like Diffusion Weighted MRI), where reconstructing smooth, elongated structures from noisy or incomplete data is vital. The challenge is that standard minimization techniques can lead to curves with "cusps" – sharp, undesirable points in their spatial projection. The paper aims to find solutions that avoid these cusps, ensuring a more natural and useful reconstruction.

Methods

The authors tackle $\mathbf{P_{curve}}$ by lifting it to a more abstract mathematical space: the sub-Riemannian manifold $\operatorname{SE(3)}\nolimits/(\{\mathbf{0}\}\times \operatorname{SO(2)}\nolimits)$. This involves:

  • Sub-Riemannian Geometry: They reframe the problem as finding geodesics (shortest paths) on this manifold. This allows them to leverage powerful tools from this field.
  • Pontryagin Maximum Principle (PMP): This is a standard technique in optimal control theory used to find necessary conditions for optimality. They apply PMP to the lifted problem to derive equations governing the geodesics.
  • Liouville Integrability: They prove that the resulting Hamiltonian system is Liouville integrable. This is a significant mathematical result that implies the existence of a complete set of conserved quantities, which is crucial for finding explicit solutions.
  • Cartan Connection: They utilize a specific type of connection (a "partial - Cartan connection") to relate the abstract geometric framework to the explicit formulas for the geodesics.
  • Explicit Formula Derivation: By combining the above techniques, they derive analytical formulas for the sub-Riemannian geodesics. These formulas involve elliptic integrals, which are standard but complex mathematical functions.
  • Geometric Analysis: They then analyze these explicit formulas to extract geometric properties of the resulting curves, such as conditions for planarity, bounds on torsion, and symmetries.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The paper focuses on theoretical derivations and numerical exploration of a mathematical problem, not on empirical evaluation using datasets.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Lifting to SE(3) is Key: The core idea is that by lifting the 3D curve problem to the group of rigid body motions (SE(3)), the problem of minimizing length and curvature becomes a problem of finding shortest paths in a sub-Riemannian sense.
  • Cuspless Projections are Special: The paper identifies a specific condition (related to the momentum components $\lambda_6=0$ and $\lambda_3 > 0$) that ensures the spatial projection of the sub-Riemannian geodesics does not exhibit cusps. This is crucial for practical applications.
  • Liouville Integrability Enables Solutions: Proving Liouville integrability is not just a mathematical curiosity; it's what makes finding explicit analytical formulas for the geodesics possible.
  • Geometric Properties are Predictable: The derived formulas allow for a deep understanding of the curves' behavior, including when they are planar, their torsion bounds, and their symmetries. This is valuable for understanding the space of possible solutions.
  • The Set of Reachable Endpoints (R) is Characterized: The paper characterizes the set of all possible start/end point and direction combinations for which a cuspless solution exists, providing a fundamental understanding of the problem's well-posedness.

Key Results

  • Explicit Analytical Formulas: The paper provides the first explicit analytical formulas for sub-Riemannian geodesics in SE(3) whose spatial projections are cuspless. These formulas involve elliptic integrals.
  • Geometric Properties Derived: They derive conditions for planarity, bounds on torsion, and symmetries of these geodesics. For instance, they show that a curve is planar if and only if its boundary conditions are coplanar and $W=0$.
  • First Cusp Time Computation: They provide a formula for the first time a cusp appears in the spatial projection of a geodesic, denoted $s_{max}$.
  • Characterization of Reachable Endpoints: The set $\mathcal{R}$ of admissible end conditions for $\mathbf{P_{curve}}$ is characterized.
  • Liouville Integrability Proven: The Hamiltonian system governing the geodesics is proven to be Liouville integrable.
  • Numerical Tools Developed: A Wolfram Mathematica package is provided for numerically solving the boundary value problem.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Elliptic Integrals: While explicit formulas are derived, they involve elliptic integrals, which are not elementary functions and can be computationally intensive to evaluate.
  • Numerical Verification of Conjecture: The paper poses a conjecture about the homeomorphism between the domain and range of the exponential map, supported by numerical experiments. Formal proof for all cases is left for future work.
  • Sub-Riemannian Spheres: The authors suggest extending their work to analyze sub-Riemannian spheres using viscosity solutions of sub-Riemannian HJB-equations, which would generalize their findings to the SE(3) case and potentially yield insights into Maxwell sets.
  • Conjugate Points: While the paper numerically investigates the absence of conjugate points before the first cusp, a formal proof for all cases is not presented.

Summary updated

Abstract

We consider the problem $\mathbf{P_{curve}}$ of minimizing $\int \limits_0^L \sqrt{\xi^2 + \kappa^2(s)} \, {\rm d}s$ for a curve $\mathbf{x}$ on $\mathbb R$ with fixed boundary points and directions. Here the total length $L\geq 0$ is free, $s$ denotes the arclength parameter, $\kappa$ denotes the absolute curvature of $\mathbf{x}$, and $\xi>0$ is constant. We lift problem $\mathbf{P_{curve}}$ on $\mathbb R^3$ to a sub-Riemannian problem $\mathbf{P_{mec}}$ on $\operatorname{SE(3)}\nolimits/(\{\mathbf{0}\}\times \operatorname{SO(2)}\nolimits)$. Here, for admissible boundary conditions, the spatial projections of sub-Riemannian geodesics do not exhibit cusps and they solve problem $\mathbf{P_{curve}}$. We apply the Pontryagin Maximum Principle (PMP) and prove Liouville integrability of the Hamiltonian system. We derive explicit analytic formulas for such sub-Riemannian geodesics, relying on the co-adjoint orbit structure, an underlying Cartan connection, and the matrix representation of $\operatorname{SE(3)}\nolimits$ arising in the Cartan-matrix. These formulas allow us to extract geometrical properties of the sub-Riemannian geodesics with cuspless projection, such as planarity conditions, explicit bounds on their torsion, and their symmetries. Furthermore, they allow us to parameterize all admissible boundary conditions reachable by geodesics with cuspless spatial projection. Such projections lay in the upper half space. We prove this for most cases, and the rest is checked numerically. Finally, we employ the formulas to numerically solve the boundary value problem, and visualize the set of admissible boundary conditions.
BibTeX
@misc{duits2013sub,
  author = {Remco Duits and Arpan Ghosh and Tom Dela Haije and Alexey Mashtakov},
  title = {{On sub-Riemannian geodesics within $SE(3)/(\textbackslash\{\}\{0\textbackslash\{\}\}\textbackslash\{\}times SO(2))$ whose spatial projections do not have cusps}},
  year = {2013},
  eprint = {1305.6061},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/1305.6061},
}
Figure