On Structural Properties of MDPs that Bound Loss Due to Shallow Planning

Nan Jiang, Satinder Singh, Ambuj Tewari

Abstract

Planning in Markov Decision Processes (MDPs) often involves a trade-off between computational efficiency and performance. "Shallow planning"—using a shorter horizon or a smaller discount factor than the evaluation criteria—is a common heuristic to manage this cost. However, theoretical understanding of the resulting performance loss has remained limited to loose bounds based on maximum rewards. This paper identifies specific structural properties of MDPs, such as reward variation, mixing time, and action variation, that provide tighter, more informative bounds on planning loss. We validate these bounds through smoothed analysis on synthetic MDPs, demonstrating how environment dynamics influence the feasibility of shallow planning.

Introduction

In reinforcement learning and robotics, planning for an infinite or very long horizon is often computationally prohibitive. To maintain real-time performance, practitioners frequently employ shallow planning, where an agent optimizes for a shorter horizon (effectively using a smaller discount factor $\gamma$) than the one used for final evaluation ($\gamma_{eval}$). While this approach saves computation, it introduces a "planning loss"—the difference in value between the optimal policy and the one derived from the shortened horizon.

Existing theoretical bounds for this loss typically rely on the maximum possible reward ($R_{max}$), leading to overly pessimistic estimates that ignore the specific dynamics of the environment. This work aims to bridge the gap between theory and practice by identifying finer-grained structural parameters of MDPs that determine the actual loss incurred.

Theoretical Framework: Structural Parameters

The authors derive new mathematical upper bounds for planning loss by introducing Value Function Variation ($\kappa_\gamma$), which quantifies the maximum difference in optimal value between any two states. This parameter serves as a bridge to several high-level MDP properties:

  • Reward Variation ($\Delta_R$): Measures the disparity in immediate best rewards across different states.
  • Mixing Time and Stochastic Diameter: Transition-based metrics that describe how quickly an MDP stabilizes or how easily an agent can navigate between states. Fast mixing implies that the long-term future becomes independent of current choices, reducing the need for deep planning.
  • Action Variation ($\delta_P$): A novel metric measuring the similarity of next-state distributions for different actions at a given state. If actions lead to similar outcomes, the problem resembles a contextual bandit, where shallow planning is highly effective.
Worst-case MDP constructions for proving theoretical bounds on planning loss.

Experimental Methodology

To validate the theoretical bounds, the authors conducted a smoothed analysis using synthetic datasets of randomly generated MDPs. These MDPs featured 10 states and 2 actions, with three distinct topologies:

  1. Fixed: Constant number of next-states per state-action pair.
  2. Binomial: Probabilistic distribution of next-states.
  3. Ring: Navigation-like structure where actions move the agent clockwise or counter-clockwise.

The analysis involved generating thousands of MDPs and grouping them into quantiles based on the identified structural parameters to observe how these properties correlate with planning loss.

Key Insights

The Contextual Bandit Connection

When Action Variation ($\delta_P$) is low, the long-term consequences of different actions are nearly identical. In such "simple" environments, the agent only needs to focus on immediate rewards, making shallow planning nearly as effective as deep planning.

Value Variation as the Primary Driver

The core driver of planning loss is not the absolute magnitude of rewards, but how much the potential value fluctuates across the state space. If all states are roughly equivalent in the long-term, the penalty for a short lookahead is minimal.

Non-monotonicity Surprise

Interestingly, increasing the planning horizon does not always lead to a monotonic decrease in loss. In some cases, a medium-depth lookahead can "distract" an agent with a local optimum that a very shallow lookahead would have ignored, leading to a temporary spike in relative loss before eventually converging to zero at full depth.

Empirical validation of planning loss across different MDP structures and horizons.

Results and Discussion

The derived theorems provide upper bounds that are strictly tighter than standard $R_{max}$-based bounds. Specifically, Theorem 2 demonstrates that loss scales linearly with Action Variation ($\delta_P$), formally justifying why certain environments are more amenable to shallow planning. Empirical results confirmed these findings: MDPs with high variation and slow mixing times consistently exhibited higher planning loss across all tested horizons.

Limitations and Future Work

While these parameters offer tighter bounds, calculating properties like mixing time or stochastic diameter can be computationally expensive for large state spaces. Furthermore, this analysis assumes a perfect model of the MDP. In practice, shallow planning is often used to mitigate model error; future work should integrate these structural bounds with model-uncertainty estimates. Extending these concepts to continuous state and action spaces also remains a significant open challenge.

Summary updated

Abstract

Planning in MDPs often uses a smaller planning horizon than specified in the problem to save computational expense at the risk of a loss due to suboptimal plans. Jiang et al. [2015b] recently showed that smaller than specified planning horizons can in fact be beneficial in cases where the MDP model is learned from data and therefore not accurate. In this paper, we consider planning with accurate models and investigate structural properties of MDPs that bound the loss incurred by using smaller than specified planning horizons. We identify a number of structural parameters some of which depend on the reward function alone, some on the transition dynamics alone, and some that depend on the interaction between rewards and transition dynamics. We provide planning loss bounds in terms of these structural parameters and, in some cases, also show tightness of the upper bounds. Empirical results with randomly generated MDPs are used to validate qualitative properties of our theoretical bounds for shallow planning.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{jiang2016structural,
  author = {Nan Jiang and Satinder Singh and Ambuj Tewari},
  title = {{On Structural Properties of MDPs that Bound Loss Due to Shallow Planning}},
  booktitle = {International Joint Conference on Artificial Intelligence},
  year = {2016},
}

Loading related content...

Figure