On r-to-p norms of random matrices with nonnegative entries: Asymptotic normality and ℓ∞-bounds for the maximizer

Souvik Dhara, Debankur Mukherjee, Kavita Ramanan

TL;DR

This paper establishes the asymptotic normality of a key matrix norm (the $r \to p$ operator norm) for random matrices with non-negative entries. It also provides a sharp bound on the stability of the vector that maximizes this norm, offering new tools for analyzing random matrices beyond traditional spectral methods.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The $r \to p$ operator norm of a matrix, defined as the maximum $p$-norm of the matrix applied to a vector with a bounded $r$-norm, is a fundamental quantity appearing in various fields like machine learning, optimization, and network design. While the $2 \to 2$ norm (related to singular values) has been extensively studied, the behavior of $r \to p$ norms for other values of $r$ and $p$, especially for random matrices with non-negative entries, remains less understood. This paper tackles two main challenges:

  1. Asymptotic behavior: How does the $r \to p$ norm of a large random matrix with non-negative entries behave statistically? Specifically, does it converge to a normal distribution after appropriate scaling and centering?
  2. Maximizer stability: The definition of the $r \to p$ norm involves a maximizing vector. How close is this maximizing vector to a simple, deterministic vector (like a vector of all ones) when the matrix is random? This relates to the stability of the maximizer under perturbations.

Methods

The authors introduce a novel approach that moves beyond spectral methods, which are not applicable for general $r \to p$ norms. Key techniques include:

  • Nonlinear Power Iteration: They adapt Boyd's nonlinear power method to approximate the $r \to p$ norm. This iterative method, starting from a vector of ones, is shown to converge to the norm.
  • Refined Convergence Analysis: They analyze the convergence rate of the power iteration, particularly focusing on the role of the maximizer vector and the second largest eigenvalue of related matrices.
  • ℓ∞-Approximation Bounds: They derive sharp bounds on the $l_\infty$ distance between the true maximizing vector and a scaled vector of ones. This is crucial for understanding the stability of the maximizer.
  • Taylor Expansion: For proving asymptotic normality, they employ a Taylor expansion of an approximating functional of the norm, allowing them to analyze the distribution of the centered and scaled norm.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The paper focuses on theoretical analysis of random matrix properties.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Beyond Spectral Methods: The paper demonstrates that asymptotic normality of $r \to p$ norms can be established even when spectral methods (like those used for singular values) are not applicable, by developing new analytical tools.
  • Shift in Asymptotic Normality: For non-negative random matrices, the asymptotic normality of the $r \to p$ norm exhibits a non-trivial shift term, which is larger than the mean of the matrix entries, even when the matrix is sparse. This is a departure from some simpler random matrix models.
  • ℓ∞-Stability of Maximizer: The paper provides a precise quantitative bound on how close the maximizing vector is to a simple vector of ones. This suggests a form of "stability" of the maximizer under random perturbations.
  • Generalization of Füredi-Komlós: The results generalize the seminal work of Füredi and Komlós on the asymptotic normality of the largest eigenvalue (the $2 \to 2$ norm) to a broader class of $r \to p$ norms.

Key Results

  • Asymptotic Normality: For symmetric random matrices with non-negative entries and $1 < p < r < \infty$, the paper establishes that the scaled and centered $r \to p$ norm converges to a normal distribution as $n \to \infty$.
  • ℓ∞-Approximation Bound: For the same class of matrices, a sharp bound is derived for the $l_\infty$ distance between the maximizing vector and a scaled vector of ones, showing it decays rapidly with $n$.
  • Connection to ℓp Grothendieck Problem: As a corollary, the paper shows that for $p \ge 2$, the asymptotic normality of the $r \to p$ norm implies asymptotic normality for the solution to the $l_p$ Grothendieck problem.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Sparsity Optimality: While the paper covers sparse matrices, the conditions on sparsity are not claimed to be optimal, and identifying such conditions is left as future work.
  • Upper Bound Tightness: The paper notes that the upper bound on $\|A_n\|_{2 \to p}$ for $p > 2$ might not be tight, suggesting potential for further refinement.
  • Generalization to Non-Symmetric Matrices: The current results are for symmetric matrices. Extending these findings to non-symmetric matrices would be a natural next step.
  • Applications: The paper highlights various applications, and further exploration of how these new theoretical results can be directly applied to specific problems in machine learning, optimization, or network analysis would be valuable.

Summary updated

Abstract

For an n×n matrix An, the r→p operator norm is defined as ‖A n‖r→p:=supx∈Rn:‖x‖r≤1‖Anx‖pforr,p≥1. For different choices of r and p, this norm corresponds to key quantities that arise in diverse applications including matrix condition number estimation, clustering of data, and construction of oblivious routing schemes in transportation networks. This article considers r→p norms of symmetric random matrices with nonnegative entries, including adjacency matrices of Erdős–Rényi random graphs, matrices with positive sub-Gaussian entries, and certain sparse matrices. For 1<p≤r<∞, the asymptotic normality, as n→∞, of the appropriately centered and scaled norm ‖An‖r→p is established. When p≥2, this is shown to imply, as a corollary, asymptotic normality of the solution to the ℓp quadratic maximization problem, also known as the ℓp Grothendieck problem. Furthermore, a sharp ℓ∞-approximation bound for the unique maximizing vector in the definition of ‖An‖r→p is obtained, and may be viewed as an ℓ∞-stability result of the maximizer under random perturbations of the matrix with mean entries. This result, which may be of independent interest, is in fact shown to hold for a broad class of deterministic sequences of matrices having certain asymptotic expansion properties. The results obtained can be viewed as a generalization of the seminal results of Füredi and Komlós (1981) on asymptotic normality of the largest singular value of a class of symmetric random matrices, which corresponds to the special case r=p=2 considered here. In the general case with 1<p≤r<∞, spectral methods are no longer applicable, and so a new approach is developed involving a refined convergence analysis of a nonlinear power method and a perturbation bound on the maximizing vector, which may be of independent interest.
BibTeX
@article{dhara2024r,
  author = {Souvik Dhara and Debankur Mukherjee and Kavita Ramanan},
  title = {{On r-to-p norms of random matrices with nonnegative entries: Asymptotic normality and ℓ∞-bounds for the maximizer}},
  journal = {The Annals of Applied Probability},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.1214/24-aap2061},
}
Figure