TL;DR
This paper tackles the problem of "negative transfer" in multi-output Gaussian Processes (MGPs), where combining related outputs can actually hurt performance. They propose new MGP structures that avoid this issue by carefully managing how latent functions are shared, allowing for scalable and robust modeling.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
Multi-output Gaussian Processes (MGPs) are powerful tools for modeling multiple related datasets simultaneously. The core idea is that by learning about one output, we can improve our understanding of others, especially if they share underlying commonalities. This is often achieved through a "convolution construction" where latent functions are shared across outputs. However, a critical issue arises when this assumption of shared commonalities doesn't hold: "negative transfer." This occurs when the attempt to model outputs together leads to worse performance than modeling them independently. The paper aims to formally define negative transfer in the MGP context, identify conditions under which it occurs, and propose novel MGP architectures that can avoid it, even when outputs have distinct characteristics.
Methods
The authors first define negative transfer in MGPs as a situation where the expected risk of a multi-output model is higher than that of a model using only a subset of related outputs. They then derive a key condition for avoiding negative transfer: the number of latent functions ($Q$) must be greater than the number of distinct, uncorrelated output groups ($M$). However, a direct implementation of this condition leads to a combinatorial explosion in the number of parameters, making it computationally infeasible for large datasets.
To address this, they introduce two novel MGP structures:
- Arrowhead Model: This model uses $N$ latent functions (one for each output) but structures their sharing such that one "central" output (e.g., $y_1$) shares information with all other outputs, while the other outputs ($y_i, i \neq 1$) are largely independent of each other. This significantly reduces the parameter space while still allowing for information sharing.
- Pairwise Model: Inspired by existing work, this approach decomposes the problem into $N-1$ independent bivariate GPs, each modeling the relationship between a target output ($y_1$) and one other output ($y_i$). Predictions are then combined using robust methods like product of experts. This offers excellent scalability for very large $N$.
A crucial aspect of both proposed models is the incorporation of regularization. This allows for automatic "functional variable selection," identifying which outputs are truly related and should share information, and which should be modeled independently, thus preventing negative transfer.
Datasets
The paper uses synthetic data generated with varying kernel types (convolved squared exponential and spectral kernels) and dimensions to illustrate their theoretical findings. Additionally, they evaluate their models on a real-world financial dataset (Pacific Exchange Rate Service) and a Parkinson's Telemonitoring dataset.
Key Insights and Ideas
- Negative transfer is a real problem in MGPs: When outputs are more distinct than assumed, combining them can hurt performance.
- Latent function count is key: Avoiding negative transfer fundamentally requires a sufficient number of latent functions ($Q > M$, where $M$ is the number of distinct output groups).
- Parameter explosion is the bottleneck: Directly implementing the $Q > M$ condition leads to intractable parameter spaces.
- Structured latent functions are the solution: The proposed arrowhead and pairwise models cleverly structure latent function sharing to manage parameter complexity.
- Regularization enables automatic selection: Penalties on model parameters can automatically identify which outputs are related, preventing unwanted information sharing and thus negative transfer. This is a significant step towards interpretable and robust MGPs.
Key Results
- Theoretical Guarantee: The paper provides theoretical conditions for avoiding negative transfer, showing that $Q > M$ latent functions are necessary and sufficient.
- Scalable Models: The proposed arrowhead and pairwise models significantly reduce the parameter space and computational complexity, allowing them to scale to large numbers of outputs ($N$).
- Performance Improvement: In experiments, the proposed models consistently outperformed a naive MGP that suffered from negative transfer, especially when outputs had dissimilar characteristics. For instance, on synthetic data with distinct outputs, the proposed models achieved MSEs orders of magnitude lower than a basic MGP with insufficient latent functions.
- Automatic Variable Selection: Regularization successfully identified and limited information sharing between unrelated outputs, demonstrating automatic functional variable selection. For example, in a pairwise model with regularization, parameters controlling shared kernels were shrunk to near zero, indicating independent modeling.
- Real-world Efficacy: The models showed competitive performance on exchange rate and Parkinson's disease datasets, demonstrating their practical applicability.
Limitations and Future Work
- Unknown M: A key challenge is that the number of distinct output groups ($M$) is typically unknown in practice, necessitating the use of $Q \ge N$ latent functions in the worst case. The proposed models aim to mitigate this by allowing for flexible selection.
- Computational Complexity: While the proposed models are more scalable than a full MGP, exact inference can still be computationally intensive. The authors mention that sparse approximations can be readily plugged in, suggesting future work in this direction.
- Further Exploration: The authors suggest exploring the use of these latent structures and regularization techniques in other dependent GP models, functional data analysis, and probabilistic graphical models.
Summary updated