On Designing the Optimal Integrated Ad Auction in E-commerce Platforms

Yuchao Ma, Weian Li, Yuhan Wang, Zitian Guo, Yuejia Dou, Qi Qi, Changyuan Yu

Introduction

Modern e-commerce platforms face a persistent challenge: balancing short-term revenue from advertisements with long-term user satisfaction derived from organic product recommendations. Traditionally, these two systems operate in silos. A fixed number of ad slots are auctioned off, and the remaining space is filled by a recommendation engine. This "separate-then-integrate" approach often results in sub-optimal outcomes, as it fails to account for the externalities organic items impose on ad competition and vice versa.

To address this, researchers presented JINTER Net (Joint INTEgrated Regret Network) at AAAI-25. JINTER Net is a neural network architecture designed to jointly optimize the placement of both ads and organic items, treating auction design as an Automated Mechanism Design (AMD) problem.

Methodology: The JINTER Net Architecture

JINTER Net moves away from manual formula derivation, instead "learning" optimal allocation and payment rules that maximize a weighted sum of platform revenue and Gross Merchandise Volume (GMV), a proxy for user experience.

The JINTER Net architecture consists of an Allocation Network using a double-softmax approach and a Payment Network trained to minimize regret.

The architecture comprises two main components:

  1. Allocation Network: This network determines the probability of an item (ad or organic) occupying a specific slot. It employs a double-softmax mechanism: a row-wise softmax ensures slots are not over-allocated, while a column-wise softmax prevents item duplication.
  2. Payment Network: For ads, this network calculates payments that satisfy Individual Rationality (IR), ensuring advertisers are never charged more than their stated value. It accounts for the presence of organic items—treated as "passive bidders" with zero bids—by learning a scaling parameter for externalities.

The model is trained using an augmented Lagrangian method within the RegretNet framework. This ensures the system is approximately Dominant Strategy Incentive Compatible (DSIC), meaning advertisers achieve the best results by bidding their true valuations.

Experimental Evaluation

The authors evaluated JINTER Net using both synthetic data (Uniform, Normal, and Lognormal distributions) and the real-world Avito search log dataset, which includes over 112 million page views.

Pareto frontier comparing JINTER Net against GSP and IAS baselines, showing the trade-off between Revenue and GMV.

Key Results

  • Performance Gains: JINTER Net consistently outperformed traditional baselines, including the Generalized Second Price (GSP) auction and the Integrated Auction System (IAS). On the Avito dataset, it achieved significant improvements in the combined Revenue + GMV metric.
  • The Pareto Frontier: By adjusting a hyperparameter ($\alpha$), platforms can navigate the Pareto curve to find the ideal balance between immediate revenue and long-term user satisfaction.
  • Economic Stability: The "regret" (the incentive for advertisers to misreport their values) remained below 0.001 across tests, confirming the system's practical truthfulness.

Conclusion and Future Work

JINTER Net demonstrates the power of neural networks in solving complex mechanism design problems where traditional theories struggle. By breaking the "fixed slot" constraint and integrating organic items into the auction framework, it offers a more flexible and globally optimal solution for e-commerce platforms.

Future research directions include relaxing the assumption of separable Click-Through Rates (CTR) to account for complex item-to-item interactions and improving the scalability of the AMD approach for real-time deployment in high-volume environments.

Reference: Ma, Y., Li, W., Wang, Y., et al. (2025). On Designing the Optimal Integrated Ad Auction in E-commerce Platforms. Proceedings of the 39th AAAI Conference on Artificial Intelligence (AAAI-25).

Summary updated

Abstract

Currently, e-commerce platforms integrate ads and organic content into a mixed list for users. While platforms seek to maximize profit from advertisers, organic items enhance user experience. To ensure long-term development, platforms aim to design mechanisms that optimize both revenue and user satisfaction. Current methods rank ads and organic items separately before integrating them. Even if each part is locally optimal, the combined result may not be globally optimal. In this paper, we come up with the Joint Integrated Regret Network (JINTER Net). Unlike traditional methods, which pre-order ads and organic items separately, JINTER Net directly selects from the combined set of candidate ads and organic items to generate an optimal list. This approach aims to optimally balance platform revenue and user experience while satisfying approximate dominant strategy incentive compatibility and individual rationality. We validate the effectiveness of JINTER Net using both synthetic data and real dataset, and our experimental results show that it significantly outperforms baseline models across multiple metrics.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{ma2025designing,
  author = {Yuchao Ma and Weian Li and Yuhan Wang and Zitian Guo and Yuejia Dou and Qi Qi and Changyuan Yu},
  title = {{On Designing the Optimal Integrated Ad Auction in E-commerce Platforms}},
  booktitle = {AAAI Conference on Artificial Intelligence},
  year = {2025},
  doi = {10.1609/aaai.v39i12.33347},
}
Figure