Observation of non-Hermitian topological disclination states and charge fractionalization

Ruifeng Li, Rimi Banerjee, Subhaskar Mandal, Da Li, Long Yang, T.p. Ma, Jianwei Liu, Gui-Geng Liu, Y. D. Chong, Baile Zhang, Er‐Ping LiarXiv 2025 · DOI · arXiv

TL;DR

Researchers have achieved the first experimental observation of topological disclination states and charge fractionalization in a non-Hermitian system. Using a sophisticated electric circuit platform with active gain and loss, the team demonstrated that non-Hermiticity can drive unique topological phases and trap fractional charges at lattice defects, opening new doors for active topological photonics.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

In the world of topological materials, we usually look at the edges to understand the bulk (the "bulk-edge correspondence"). However, certain "hidden" topological properties are better revealed by looking at defects within the material's structure, such as disclinations—defects where the lattice's rotational symmetry is broken (think of a honeycomb lattice where a wedge has been cut out and the edges glued back together).

While these effects are well-documented in Hermitian systems (where energy is conserved), the frontier of non-Hermitian (NH) physics—systems involving gain and loss—remained largely theoretical. Theory suggested that gain and loss could actually induce topological phases and trap fractional charges at these defects, but until now, no one had managed to observe this in a physical experiment. The challenge lies in creating a stable, tunable lattice that can precisely balance gain and loss to reveal these subtle topological signatures.

Methods

The authors utilized topolectrical circuits as their experimental playground. This approach maps the Hamiltonian of a quantum system onto the Laplacian of an electrical circuit.

  • The Lattice: They designed C5-symmetric and C4-symmetric lattices based on a graphene-like honeycomb structure. To create the disclination, they used a "cut-and-glue" procedure, removing a $60^\circ$ ($\pi/3$) sector to form the C5 geometry.
  • Active Non-Hermiticity: To implement gain and loss, the researchers used:
  • Loss: Standard resistors.
  • Gain: Negative Impedance Converters with current inversion (INIC) powered by operational amplifiers. These act as "negative resistors" that pump energy into the system.
  • Measurement: They used a Vector Network Analyzer (VNA) to measure the admittance matrix ($J$). Because NH systems are not energy-conserving, they employed bi-orthogonal eigenstate analysis (looking at both "left" and "right" eigenvectors) to correctly identify the topological states and calculate the fractional charge.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. (This is an experimental physics paper; the "data" consists of original measurements from fabricated printed circuit boards rather than external datasets).

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Gain/Loss as a Topological Switch: The most striking insight is that the topological phase isn't just a property of the lattice geometry; it is induced solely by the pattern of gain and loss. By changing the resistor values, the researchers could flip the system from a "trivial" state to a "topological" one.
  • The "Smoking Gun" of Fractional Charge: In topological crystalline insulators, the bulk topology manifests as a fractional charge trapped at a defect. The authors successfully measured a disclination charge of approximately $1/2$ (modulo 1), providing definitive proof of the non-Hermitian bulk-defect correspondence.
  • Symmetry-Dependent States: The researchers found that different lattice symmetries yield different types of localized modes. The C5 lattice produced a mix of singlet and doublet mid-gap states, while the C4 lattice hosted degenerate zero-energy states, showing how geometry and non-Hermiticity interact to shape the energy spectrum.

Key Results

  • Observation of Disclination Modes: In the C5 topological configuration, the team identified five mid-gap states localized at the disclination core. These were absent in the trivial configuration, which showed a pure bandgap.
  • Quantitative Charge Fractionalization: The calculated fractional charge for the topological phase was 0.57 (numerical) and 0.47 (experimental), both clustering near the theoretical value of $1/2$. In contrast, the trivial phase showed a negligible charge of ~0.1.
  • Direct Visualization: Using monochromatic field excitation, the authors directly imaged the voltage distribution across the circuit. The topological circuit showed intense, localized "hotspots" at the disclination core, while the trivial circuit showed no such localization.
  • Zero-Energy States: In the C4-symmetric NH lattice, they observed twofold degenerate zero-energy states, providing a non-Hermitian analogue to previously discovered Hermitian acoustic states.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Linear Regime Constraints: The current experiment was carefully calibrated to operate in the linear regime of the operational amplifiers. If the gain is too high, the system becomes unstable or enters a non-linear saturation regime.
  • Non-linearity as a Feature: The authors suggest that future work should intentionally explore the non-linear regime. Understanding how gain saturation affects these topological states could lead to the development of "topological lasers"—devices that are robust against defects and can be precisely tuned.
  • Scaling Down: While electric circuits are excellent macroscopic models, the next step is translating these principles into integrated photonic or acoustic micro-devices for real-world signal processing and sensing applications.

Summary updated

Abstract

There has been significant interest in exploring topological disclination states, which effectively probe the band topology of the host material beyond the conventional bulk-edge correspondence. While most studies in this area have primarily focused on Hermitian systems, recent theoretical work predicts that non-Hermiticity can drive topological phase transitions and host topological disclination states associated with fractional charge. However, no experimental observations have been reported to date. Here, we report the first experimental observation of topological disclination states in electric circuits, induced solely by gain and loss. Through admittance matrix measurements and eigenstate analysis, we confirm their emergence and compute the corresponding fractional charge. Moreover, the disclination mode profile and localization effect can be directly visualized via monochromatic field excitation. Additionally, we demonstrate the emergence of degenerate zero-energy topological disclination states, devoid of fractional charge, in distinct non-Hermitian geometries. Our findings open the possibility of non-Hermiticity-induced fractional charges in two-dimensional non-Hermitian lattices, which may pave the way for advancements in active topological photonic devices.
BibTeX
@misc{li2025observation,
  author = {Ruifeng Li and Rimi Banerjee and Subhaskar Mandal and Da Li and Long Yang and T.P. Ma and Jianwei Liu and Gui-Geng Liu and Y. D. Chong and Baile Zhang and Er‐Ping Li},
  title = {{Observation of non-Hermitian topological disclination states and charge fractionalization}},
  year = {2025},
  eprint = {2502.04922},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/2502.04922},
  howpublished = {arXiv},
}
Figure