Observation of Flat Bands and Dirac Cones in a Pyrochlore Lattice Superconductor

Jianwei Huang, Chandan Setty, Liangzi Deng, Jing‐Yang You, Hongxiong Liu, Sen Shao, Ji Seop Oh, Yucheng Guo, Yichen Zhang, Ziqin Yue, Jia‐Xin Yin, Makoto Hashimoto, Dong-Hui Lu, Sergey Gorovikov, Pengcheng Dai, M. Zahid Hasan, Yuan Ping Feng, R. J. Birgeneau, Youguo Shi, C. W. Chu, Guoqing Chang, Qimiao Si, Ming Yi, Yi, MingarXiv 2023 · DOI · arXiv

TL;DR

Researchers have experimentally confirmed that the pyrochlore lattice—a 3D network of corner-sharing tetrahedra—acts as a powerful platform for "correlated topology." By studying the superconductor $CeRu_2$ using high-resolution spectroscopy, the team observed 3D flat electronic bands and symmetry-protected Dirac cones, providing a new 3D roadmap for engineering exotic quantum states like unconventional superconductivity.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

In condensed matter physics, the "holy grail" is finding materials where electronic kinetic energy is suppressed, allowing electron-electron (Coulomb) interactions to dominate. This regime leads to "emergent phases" like high-temperature superconductivity and exotic magnetism.

One way to kill kinetic energy is through geometric frustration: arranging atoms so that electron waves interfere destructively, getting "trapped" in place. This creates flat bands in momentum space. While this has been heavily explored in 2D "kagome" lattices (think of a Star of David pattern), 2D materials often suffer from interlayer coupling that "smears out" the flatness.

The challenge has been to find a 3D equivalent. The pyrochlore lattice (a 3D arrangement of corner-sharing tetrahedra) is the natural 3D analog of the kagome lattice. Theory predicted it should host 3D flat bands and unique "nonsymmorphic" Dirac points, but these features had never been clearly seen in a metallic, superconducting crystal—until now.

Methods

The authors combined experimental spectroscopy with advanced theoretical modeling:

  • Sample Growth: High-quality single crystals of $CeRu_2$ (a Laves phase superconductor) were grown using the Czochralski pulling method in a tetra-arc furnace.
  • ARPES (Angle-Resolved Photoemission Spectroscopy): This was the primary tool used to "map" the energy and momentum of electrons. The team used various photon energies (from 21.2 eV to 120 eV) at synchrotron facilities to distinguish between different atomic orbitals (specifically the Ce $4f$ and Ru $4d$ states).
  • DFT (Density Functional Theory): Computational simulations (using VASP and WIEN2k) were used to predict the band structure and compare it with experimental results.
  • Tight-Binding Modeling: A simplified mathematical model of the lattice was used to prove that the observed features were inherent to the pyrochlore geometry itself, rather than just specific chemical quirks.

Datasets

The "datasets" in this study consist of:

  • Experimental ARPES Spectra: Energy-vs-momentum maps across multiple Brillouin zones.
  • Computational Band Structures: Comparative DFT calculations for $Ru_2$ (artificial lattice), $LaRu_2$ (control), and $CeRu_2$ (target).
  • Transport Data: Temperature-dependent magnetization and resistivity curves confirming the superconducting transition at $T_c \approx 5.1$ K.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • 3D Destructive Interference: The paper demonstrates that the pyrochlore lattice effectively "disconnects" into interwoven 2D kagome planes. This geometry forces electrons into localized states, creating flat bands that persist in 3D space.
  • Nonsymmorphic Symmetry Protection: The crystal structure of $CeRu_2$ possesses "nonsymmorphic" symmetries (rotations combined with fractional translations). The authors show that this symmetry guarantees that all band crossings at the Brillouin zone "X" point are 3D gapless Dirac points. Unlike standard Dirac cones (like in graphene), these are robust against spin-orbit coupling.
  • Orbital Hybridization: The flat bands aren't perfectly flat because the Ru $4d$ electrons "talk" to the Ce $4f$ electrons. However, this hybridization is actually a feature—it suggests that the many-body physics of the Cerium atoms is deeply intertwined with the topological structure of the Ruthenium lattice.
  • Tuning Superconductivity: The researchers noted a correlation between the position of these flat bands relative to the Fermi level and the superconducting transition temperature ($T_c$), suggesting the flat bands might be driving the superconductivity.

Key Results

  • Observation of Ru 4d Flat Bands: Identified a clear flat band feature around -0.5 eV, which aligns with theoretical predictions for 3D destructive interference.
  • Discovery of 3D Dirac Cones: Observed two distinct Dirac points (DP1 at -1.7 eV and DP2 at -2.5 eV) at the X point of the Brillouin zone, confirming the nonsymmorphic protection for the first time in this lattice type.
  • Ce 4f Resonance: Using 120 eV photons, they successfully isolated the "Kondo resonance" flat bands originating from Cerium, showing how they coexist with the lattice-induced flat bands.
  • Consistency: The experimental ARPES data showed remarkable agreement with DFT calculations after applying a modest renormalization factor (1.2), indicating a well-understood electronic system.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Band Flatness: While the bands are "flat," they still have some dispersion (bandwidth) due to hybridization. Future work could involve chemical "tuning" (doping) to make these bands even flatter or move them precisely to the Fermi level to maximize many-body effects.
  • Magnetism Mystery: The origin of weak magnetism suggested by other techniques (like $\mu$SR) remains unclear in $CeRu_2$, as ARPES did not detect magnetic band splitting.
  • Broadening the Search: $CeRu_2$ is part of a large family of Laves phase materials ($AB_2$). The authors suggest that this "pyrochlore physics" should be a universal feature across this class, opening the door to discovering new topological superconductors.

Summary updated

Abstract

Emergent phases often appear when the electronic kinetic energy is comparable to the Coulomb interactions. One approach to seek material systems as hosts of such emergent phases is to realize localization of electronic wavefunctions due to the geometric frustration inherent in the crystal structure, resulting in flat electronic bands. Recently, such efforts have found a wide range of exotic phases in the two-dimensional kagome lattice, including magnetic order, time-reversal symmetry breaking charge order, nematicity, and superconductivity. However, the interlayer coupling of the kagome layers disrupts the destructive interference needed to completely quench the kinetic energy. Here we demonstrate that an interwoven kagome network-a pyrochlore lattice-can host a three dimensional (3D) localization of electron wavefunctions. Meanwhile, the nonsymmorphic symmetry of the pyrochlore lattice guarantees all band crossings at the Brillouin zone X point to be 3D gapless Dirac points, which was predicted theoretically but never yet observed experimentally. Through a combination of angle-resolved photoemission spectroscopy, fundamental lattice model and density functional theory calculations, we investigate the novel electronic structure of a Laves phase superconductor with a pyrochlore sublattice, CeRu$_2$. We observe flat bands originating from both the Ce 4$f$ orbitals as well as from the 3D destructive interference of the Ru 4$d$ orbitals. We further observe the nonsymmorphic symmetry-protected 3D gapless Dirac cones at the X point. Our work establishes the pyrochlore structure as a promising lattice platform to realize and tune novel emergent phases intertwining topology and many-body interactions.
BibTeX
@misc{huang2023observation,
  author = {Jianwei Huang and Chandan Setty and Liangzi Deng and Jing‐Yang You and Hongxiong Liu and Sen Shao and Ji Seop Oh and Yucheng Guo and Yichen Zhang and Ziqin Yue and Jia‐Xin Yin and Makoto Hashimoto and Dong-Hui Lu and Sergey Gorovikov and Pengcheng Dai and M. Zahid Hasan and Yuan Ping Feng and R. J. Birgeneau and Youguo Shi and C. W. Chu and Guoqing Chang and Qimiao Si and Ming Yi and Yi, Ming},
  title = {{Observation of Flat Bands and Dirac Cones in a Pyrochlore Lattice Superconductor}},
  year = {2023},
  eprint = {2304.09066},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/2304.09066},
}
Figure