Observation of charmed strange meson pair production in $Υ(2S)$ decays and in $e^{+}e^{-}$ annihilation at $\sqrt{s} = 10.52~ \rm{GeV}$

Belle Collaboration, Bo Gao, W. J. Zhu, X. L. Wang, I. Adachi, H. Aihara, D. M. Asner, V. Aulchenko, T. Aushev, R. Ayad, V. Babu, Sw. Banerjee, Martin Bauer, P. K. Behera, K. Belous, J. V. Bennett, M. Bessner, V. Bhardwaj, T. Bilka, D. Biswas, A. Bobrov, D. Bodrov, A. Bondar, A. Bożek, M. Bračko, P. Branchini, T. E. Browder, A. Budano, D. Červenkov, M.-c. Chang, P. Chang, V. Chekelian, B. G. Cheon, K. Chilikin, H. E. Cho, K. Cho, S.-k. Choi, Y. Choi, S. Choudhury, D. Cinabro, G. De Nardo, G. De Pietro, R. Dhamija, F. Di Capua, J. Dingfelder, Z. Doležal, T. V. Dong, P. Ecker, T. Ferber, D. Ferlewicz, B. G. Fulsom, V. Gaur, A. Giri, E. Graziani, T. Gu, K. Gudkova, C. Hadjivasiliou, K. Hayasaka, H. Hayashii, S. Hazra, M. T. Hedges, D. Herrmann, W.-s. Hou, C.-l. Hsu, T. Iijima, K. Inami, N. Ipsita, A. Ishikawa, R. Itoh, M. Iwasaki, W. W. Jacobs, E.-j. Jang, S. Jia, Y. Jin, K. K. Joo, T. Kawasaki, C. Kiesling, C. H. Kim, D. Y. Kim, K. -h. Kim, Y. -k. Kim, K. Kinoshita, P. Kodyš, T. Konno, A. Korobov, S. Korpar, P. Križan, M. Kumar, R. Kumar, K. Kumara, A. Kuzmin, Y.-j. Kwon, Y.-t. Lai, S. C. Lee, D. Levit, P. Lewis, L. K. Li, L. Li Gioi, J. Libby, K. LieretarXiv 2023 · DOI · arXiv

Abstract

We observe the process $Υ(2S)\to D_s^{(*)+} D_{sJ}^{-}$ and continuum production $e^+e^- \to D_s^{(*)+} D_{sJ}^- $ at $\sqrt{s} = 10.52$ GeV (and their charge conjugates) using the data samples collected by the Belle detector at KEKB, where $D_{sJ}^-$ is $D_{s1}(2536)^-$ or $D^{*}_{s2}(2573)^-$. Both $D_{sJ}^-$ states are identified through their decay into $\bar{K}\bar{D}^{(*)}$. We measure the products of branching fractions ${\cal B}(Υ(2S) \to D_{s}^{(*)+} D_{sJ}^-) {\cal B}(D_{sJ}^-\to \bar{K} \bar{D}^{(*)})$ and the Born cross sections $σ^{\rm Born}(e^+e^- \to D_{s}^{(*)+} D_{sJ}^-) {\cal B}(D_{sJ}^-\to \bar{K} \bar{D}^{(*)})$, and then compare the ratios $R_1 \equiv {\cal B}(Υ(2S)\to D_{s}^{(*)+} D_{sJ}^-)/{\cal B}(Υ(2S)\to\mu^{+}\mu^-)$ for $Υ(2S)$ decays and $R_2 \equiv σ^{\rm Born}(e^+e^-\to D_{s}^{(*)+}D_{sJ}^-)/σ^{\rm Born}(e^+e^-\to \mu^{+}\mu^-)$ for continuum production. We obtain $R_1/R_2$ values ranging from 3.4 to 10.2 for various final states, indicating that strong decay dominates in the $Υ(2S)\to D_{s}^{(*)+}D_{sJ}^-$ processes. We also confirm isospin symmetry in the decays of $D_{s1}(2536)^-$ and $D_{s2}^{*}(2573)^-$.

Introduction

In particle physics, the decay of heavy quarkonia like the $\Upsilon(2S)$ meson (a $b\bar{b}$ bound state) provides a window into fundamental forces. These mesons can decay either electromagnetically via a virtual photon or through the strong interaction via gluons. While charm quark production in these decays is known, the exact mechanism—whether it mimics the electromagnetic "continuum" process or involves significant gluon fragmentation—has remained an open question. By measuring the production of specific excited charmed-strange mesons ($D_{sJ}$), physicists can test theoretical models of Quantum Chromodynamics (QCD) and OZI-suppressed hadronic decays.

Experimental Methods

The Belle Collaboration utilized the Belle detector at the KEKB asymmetric-energy $e^+e^-$ collider. The study analyzed $24.7 \text{ fb}^{-1}$ of data at the $\Upsilon(2S)$ resonance (containing $\sim 158$ million events) and $89.5 \text{ fb}^{-1}$ of continuum data at $\sqrt{s} = 10.52 \text{ GeV}$.

To identify the rare $D_s^{(*)+} D_{sJ}^-$ pairs, researchers employed a partial reconstruction technique. $D_s^+$ mesons were fully reconstructed in six hadronic channels, and $D_s^{*+}$ candidates were identified via $D_s^+ \gamma$. Instead of fully reconstructing the $D_{sJ}^-$ state, which suffers from low efficiency, they used the recoil mass method. By identifying a kaon ($K^-$ or $K_S^0$) from the $D_{sJ}^-$ decay and calculating the mass recoiling against the $D_s^{(*)+} K$ system, they could infer the presence of the missing $D^{(*)}$ meson.

Figure 1: 2D distributions of the recoil mass of $D_s^{(*)+}$ versus the recoil mass of the $D_s^{(*)+} K$ system for data (a, b) and signal Monte Carlo (c, d).

Results and Discussion

Clear signals for $D_s^+$ and $D_s^{*+}$ were observed in both the $\Upsilon(2S)$ and continuum datasets, as shown in the invariant mass distributions in Figure 2.

Figure 2: Invariant mass distributions for $D_s^+$ (a, c) and $D_s^{*+}$ (b, d) candidates.

The critical finding of the study is the ratio $R_1/R_2$, where $R_1$ is the production rate in $\Upsilon(2S)$ decays and $R_2$ is the rate in continuum production. If the decay were purely electromagnetic, this ratio would be approximately 1. However, the measured ratios were significantly higher:

  • $D_s^+ D_{s1}(2536)^-$: $9.7 \pm 2.3 \pm 1.1$
  • $D_s^{*+} D_{s1}(2536)^-$: $6.8 \pm 2.1 \pm 0.8$
  • $D_s^+ D_{s2}^{*}(2573)^{-}$: $10.2 \pm 3.3 \pm 2.5$
  • $D_s^{*+} D_{s2}^{*}(2573)^{-}$: $3.4 \pm 2.1 \pm 0.5$

These values provide a "smoking gun" for the dominance of the strong interaction (gluon-mediated processes) in creating these charmed states during $\Upsilon(2S)$ decays. Furthermore, the team measured branching fraction ratios for $D_{s1}(2536)^-$ and $D_{s2}^*(2573)^-$ decays that were consistent with $0.5$, confirming isospin symmetry. The measurement for $D_{s2}^*(2573)^-$ represents the first such result for this state. The signals for $D_{s1}(2536)^-$ were observed with statistical significances of $5.3\sigma$ and $4.3\sigma$ for the $D_s^+$ and $D_s^{*+}$ modes, respectively.

Conclusion

The Belle Collaboration has provided the first observation of $D_s^{(*)+} D_{sJ}^-$ pairs in $\Upsilon(2S)$ decays and continuum $e^+e^-$ annihilation. The results confirm that strong interaction processes dominate the production of these charmed-strange mesons in heavy quarkonium decays. While the $D_{s1}$ signals are statistically robust, future experiments at Belle II will be necessary to improve precision, particularly for the $D_{s2}^*(2573)^-$ state, and to further explore the dynamics of heavy-flavor production.

Summary updated

Abstract

We observe the process $Υ(2S)\to D_s^{(*)+} D_{sJ}^{-}$ and continuum production $e^+e^- \to D_s^{(*)+} D_{sJ}^- $ at $\sqrt{s} = 10.52$ GeV (and their charge conjugates) using the data samples collected by the Belle detector at KEKB, where $D_{sJ}^-$ is $D_{s1}(2536)^-$ or $D^{*}_{s2}(2573)^-$. Both $D_{sJ}^-$ states are identified through their decay into $\bar{K}\bar{D}^{(*)}$. We measure the products of branching fractions ${\cal B}(Υ(2S) \to D_{s}^{(*)+} D_{sJ}^-) {\cal B}(D_{sJ}^-\to \bar{K} \bar{D}^{(*)})$ and the Born cross sections $σ^{\rm Born}(e^+e^- \to D_{s}^{(*)+} D_{sJ}^-) {\cal B}(D_{sJ}^-\to \bar{K} \bar{D}^{(*)})$, and then compare the ratios $R_1 \equiv {\cal B}(Υ(2S)\to D_{s}^{(*)+} D_{sJ}^-)/{\cal B}(Υ(2S)\toμ^{+}μ^-)$ for $Υ(2S)$ decays and $R_2 \equiv σ^{\rm Born}(e^+e^-\to D_{s}^{(*)+}D_{sJ}^-)/σ^{\rm Born}(e^+e^-\to μ^{+}μ^-)$ for continuum production. We obtain $R_1/R_2 = 9.7\pm 2.3 \pm 1.1$, $6.8 \pm 2.1 \pm 0.8$, $10.2 \pm 3.3 \pm 2.5$, and $3.4 \pm 2.1 \pm 0.5$ for the $D_s^+ D_{s1}(2536)^-$, $D_s^{*+} D_{s1}(2536)^-$, $D_s^+ D_{s2}^{*}(2573)^{-}$, and $D_s^{*+} D_{s2}^{*}(2573)^{-}$ final states in the $D_{sJ}^-\to K^{-} \bar{D}^{(*)0}$ modes, respectively. Therefore, the strong decay is expected to dominate in the $Υ(2S)\to D_{s}^{(*)+}D_{sJ}^-$ processes. We also measure the ratios of branching fractions ${\cal B}(D_{s1}(2536)^-\to K_S^0 D^{*}(2010)^{-})/{\cal B}(D_{s1}(2536)^-\to K^{-} D^{*}(2007)^0) = 0.48 \pm 0.07 \pm 0.02$ and ${\cal B}(D_{s2}^{*}(2573)^- \to K_S^0 D^-)/{\cal B}(D_{s2}^{*}(2573)^- \to K^{-}D^0) = 0.49 \pm 0.10 \pm 0.02$, which are consistent with isospin symmetry. The second ratio is the first measurement of this quantity. Here, the first uncertainties are statistical and the second are systematic.
BibTeX
@misc{collaboration2023observation,
  author = {Belle Collaboration and Bo Gao and W. J. Zhu and X. L. Wang and I. Adachi and H. Aihara and D. M. Asner and V. Aulchenko and T. Aushev and R. Ayad and V. Babu and Sw. Banerjee and Martin Bauer and P. K. Behera and K. Belous and J. V. Bennett and M. Bessner and V. Bhardwaj and T. Bilka and D. Biswas and A. Bobrov and D. Bodrov and A. Bondar and A. Bożek and M. Bračko and P. Branchini and T. E. Browder and A. Budano and D. Červenkov and M.-C. Chang and P. Chang and V. Chekelian and B. G. Cheon and K. Chilikin and H. E. Cho and K. Cho and S.-K. Choi and Y. Choi and S. Choudhury and D. Cinabro and G. De Nardo and G. De Pietro and R. Dhamija and F. Di Capua and J. Dingfelder and Z. Doležal and T. V. Dong and P. Ecker and T. Ferber and D. Ferlewicz and B. G. Fulsom and V. Gaur and A. Giri and E. Graziani and T. Gu and K. Gudkova and C. Hadjivasiliou and K. Hayasaka and H. Hayashii and S. Hazra and M. T. Hedges and D. Herrmann and W.-S. Hou and C.-L. Hsu and T. Iijima and K. Inami and N. Ipsita and A. Ishikawa and R. Itoh and M. Iwasaki and W. W. Jacobs and E.-J. Jang and S. Jia and Y. Jin and K. K. Joo and T. Kawasaki and C. Kiesling and C. H. Kim and D. Y. Kim and K. -H. Kim and Y. -K. Kim and K. Kinoshita and P. Kodyš and T. Konno and A. Korobov and S. Korpar and P. Križan and M. Kumar and R. Kumar and K. Kumara and A. Kuzmin and Y.-J. Kwon and Y.-T. Lai and S. C. Lee and D. Levit and P. Lewis and L. K. Li and L. Li Gioi and J. Libby and K. Lieret},
  title = {{Observation of charmed strange meson pair production in $Υ(2S)$ decays and in $e^\{+\}e^\{-\}$ annihilation at $\textbackslash\{\}sqrt\{s\} = 10.52~ \textbackslash\{\}rm\{GeV\}$}},
  year = {2023},
  eprint = {2308.08900},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/2308.08900},
}
Figure