Numerical Study on Stratigraphic and Structural Deformation Patterns Considering Surface Load with Pile-Beam-Arch Method Construction

Yu Zeng, Yao Bai, Yu Zou, Bo HuangSymmetry 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper investigates the ground and structural deformation patterns during the construction of subway stations using the Pile-Beam-Arch (PBA) method, a complex technique involving multiple stages. By employing numerical simulations, the study quantifies the impact of different construction phases and external surface loads on ground settlement and structural stress, offering insights into controlling deformation and ensuring construction safety.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Constructing underground infrastructure like metro stations, especially in urban environments, poses significant challenges. Excavation activities can disturb the surrounding soil, leading to ground settlement, potential damage to nearby structures, and even collapse. The Pile-Beam-Arch (PBA) method, while offering advantages like reduced ground settlement and minimal environmental impact, involves a complex, multi-stage construction process with intricate structural force transformations. Understanding and predicting the ground and structural deformation throughout these stages, particularly under the influence of external surface loads (common in dense urban areas), is crucial for safe and efficient construction. This paper aims to fill this gap by providing a detailed numerical analysis of these deformation patterns during PBA construction.

Methods

The study utilizes a three-dimensional numerical calculation model developed using the finite element software FLAC3D. The model incorporates the geological conditions and structural dimensions of the Daguanying subway station in Beijing as an engineering background. The construction process is simplified into four main stages: excavation of pilot tunnels, installation of piles and beams, installation of arches, and excavation of interior soil. The Mohr-Coulomb constitutive model is used for the soil, and a linear elastic model for the structural components. The research specifically analyzes the impact of varying surface loads on ground and structural deformation during the final construction stage. Additionally, the paper employs the stochastic medium theory to predict surface settlement and horizontal displacement, comparing these predictions with numerical simulation results.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study uses the geological conditions and structural dimensions of the Daguanying subway station as an engineering background for its numerical model.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Stage-Specific Deformation: Ground deformation is not uniform throughout construction. The excavation of pilot tunnels (Stage I) and the installation of arches (Stage III) are identified as the critical phases contributing the most to surface settlement and horizontal displacement, respectively.
  • Surface Load Significance: External surface loads, often overlooked in simpler analyses, significantly influence both ground settlement and structural stress. The study demonstrates a clear, positive correlation between increasing surface load and increased ground displacement.
  • Structural Stress Concentration: The construction process leads to stress concentration within the station structure, particularly in the middle column during the final excavation stage, reaching a maximum principal stress of 14.203 MPa. This highlights the need for targeted reinforcement measures.
  • Rebound Mechanism: A "rebound" in surface settlement is observed after the arch installation (Stage III) and during the final excavation (Stage IV). This is attributed to the formation of a "structure-soil" system that bears stress, followed by a decrease in the self-weight of this system as interior soil is excavated.
  • PBA Method Optimization: The study suggests that optimizing the excavation sequence of pilot tunnels, particularly an "upper first, then lower, sides first, then middle" approach, can effectively reduce surface displacement.
  • Stochastic Medium Theory as a Conservative Predictor: While the stochastic medium theory provides predictions that are generally larger than numerical simulation results, it offers a conservative estimate, which can be beneficial for guiding on-site construction.

Key Results

  • The excavation of pilot tunnels (Stage I) and arch installation (Stage III) account for approximately 67% and 23.1% of the total surface settlement, and 70% and 21% of the total horizontal displacement, respectively.
  • The maximum surface settlement observed in the numerical simulation was 27.8 mm.
  • The maximum principal stress in the structure reached 14.203 MPa in the middle column during Stage IV.
  • A linear relationship (R² > 0.9) was found between surface load and surface displacement. A 10 kPa increase in surface load resulted in approximately 1.76 mm of surface settlement and 0.5 mm of horizontal displacement.
  • The stochastic medium theory predicted a maximum surface settlement of 32.7 mm and a maximum horizontal displacement of 12.73 mm, which were larger than the simulation results, indicating a conservative prediction.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge that the PBA method involves numerous steps and complex structural transformations, suggesting that further research is needed to fully understand these intricacies. Specific limitations and future work identified include:

  • Number of Pilot Tunnels: The study found that eight pilot tunnels resulted in more displacement than six, suggesting that optimizing the number of pilot tunnels could further reduce ground deformation.
  • Pile-Column System Optimization: Future research could focus on optimizing the dimensions (spacing and cross-sectional area) of the pile-column system to ensure both safety and economic efficiency.
  • Sensitivity Analysis of Stochastic Medium Theory: A more in-depth sensitivity analysis of the parameters within the stochastic medium theory is recommended to better understand their influence on prediction accuracy and establish clearer relationships with influencing factors.
  • Accumulation and Growth of Track Settlements: The paper highlights the need to consider the accumulation and growth of track settlements in the station operation phase, especially due to dynamic interactions, which is proposed as a focus for future research.
  • Seismic Action: The authors suggest that the effect of seismic action on the station structure should be considered in future research, particularly given the potential weakness of nodes in the PBA construction.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@article{zeng2022numerical,
  author = {Yu Zeng and Yao Bai and Yu Zou and Bo Huang},
  title = {{Numerical Study on Stratigraphic and Structural Deformation Patterns Considering Surface Load with Pile-Beam-Arch Method Construction}},
  journal = {Symmetry},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.3390/sym14091892},
}
Figure