Numerical Simulation of the Hydraulic Characteristics and Fish Habitat of a Natural Continuous Meandering River

Pingyi Wang, Jian Li, Meili Wang, Jielong Hu, Fan ZhangSustainability 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper uses numerical simulations to analyze the hydraulic characteristics of a natural meandering river, finding it unsuitable for both ship navigation and fish habitats due to complex flow patterns and extreme velocities. A targeted remediation plan significantly improved these conditions, demonstrating a viable approach for creating sustainable ecological waterways in curved river systems.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The increasing global focus on ecological waterways highlights the need for river systems that can support both human navigation and healthy aquatic ecosystems. However, natural meandering rivers, while common, present significant challenges. Their complex flow dynamics, including sharp turns and varying depths, often create conditions that are too turbulent or too slow for safe ship passage and are detrimental to fish survival. While research exists on straight rivers and engineered bends, there's a notable gap in understanding and improving the ecological functionality of natural, continuous meandering river channels. This paper aims to bridge this gap by investigating the hydraulic characteristics of such a river and its suitability for navigation and fish, then proposing and evaluating a remediation strategy.

Methods

The core of this research relies on numerical simulation using the MIKE21 software, a standard tool for 2D shallow water equation modeling. The study employs the Navier-Stokes equations with specific assumptions (incompressibility, Boussinesq, hydrostatic pressure) to model the flow. A key methodological contribution is the application of the Shannon diversity index to quantify the complexity and heterogeneity of river flow velocity. This index, typically used in ecology, is adapted here to assess how varied the flow velocities are within the channel, serving as a proxy for the stability of the fish habitat. The study also incorporates a feasibility analysis by comparing simulation results with prototype hydrological data to validate the model's accuracy.

Datasets

The study utilizes topographic data of a natural river channel acquired via an unmanned survey vessel with a multibeam system. This data was processed using professional CAD software and imported into MIKE21 for grid mapping. Additionally, hydrological data from a natural river prototype was used for model verification, specifically focusing on water levels and flow velocities. No new benchmark datasets were introduced; rather, existing real-world data was used for model calibration and validation.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Meandering rivers are inherently challenging for ecological waterways: The study confirms that natural continuous meanders create complex flow conditions that are not conducive to either safe navigation or stable fish habitats.
  • Shannon Diversity Index as a habitat indicator: Applying the Shannon diversity index to flow velocity provides a novel quantitative measure for assessing the suitability of river channels for fish, correlating higher diversity with less stable environments.
  • Targeted remediation is effective: A multi-pronged approach involving dredging, filling, and submerged dam construction can significantly improve hydraulic conditions in meandering rivers.
  • Curved river connections are critical zones: The points where curves connect are identified as areas with the most complex water characteristics and thus require focused attention during remediation efforts.

Key Results

  • Natural conditions are suboptimal: In the natural state, the river exhibited high flow velocities (up to 4.8 m/s) and large water level gradients (up to 4.0%), exceeding safe navigation limits and creating unstable fish habitats. The Shannon diversity index for flow velocity was high, indicating a chaotic environment.
  • Remediation significantly improves conditions: After implementing the proposed channel regulation scheme (dredging, filling, submerged dams), the maximum flow velocities were reduced to 3.0-3.5 m/s, and water level gradients decreased to 1.3-1.9%. These values meet navigational requirements.
  • Fish habitat improved: The Shannon diversity index for flow velocity decreased significantly after remediation (e.g., from 1.52 to 0.94 in one condition), indicating a smoother, more stable flow regime. The proportion of flow conditions suitable for fish survival increased from 52% to 68% in one scenario.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several limitations:

  • 2D vs. 3D simulation: The study used a two-dimensional model, which simplifies the complex three-dimensional flow dynamics present in real rivers.
  • Sediment transport not analyzed: The impact of sediment movement on river morphology and flow was not considered.
  • Fish habitat analysis limited: The fish habitat assessment primarily focused on flow velocity, neglecting other crucial factors like water quality, temperature, and substrate.

Future work suggested includes:

  • Experimental studies: Conducting physical model tests to complement the numerical simulations.
  • 3D numerical simulations: Incorporating a third dimension to capture more realistic flow behavior.
  • Water-sediment coupled simulations: Investigating the interplay between flow and sediment transport.
  • Comprehensive fish habitat analysis: Expanding the analysis to include a wider range of environmental factors influencing fish survival.

Summary updated

Abstract

Increasing international attention is being focused on the construction of ecological waterways. Ecological waterways are not only able to successfully sustain the navigational functions for ships, but also provide a stable long-term environment in which fish can survive. In nature, meandering rivers are the most common form. Compared with straight rivers, their flow conditions are complex and not conducive to ship navigation and fish survival. There has been less research conducted on the construction of ecological waterways in naturally curving rivers. Therefore, in this paper, a naturally continuous curved river was used as a research object, and numerical simulation was employed to study the hydraulic characteristics of the river and the survival environment by fish by introducing the Shannon diversity index. It was concluded that a naturally continuous curved river cannot meet the navigational requirements and does not provide a stable survival environment for fish. After proposing a targeted channel restoration plan, the hydraulic characteristics of the flow were significantly improved, and the flow velocity Shannon diversity index was reduced. The restored channel met the navigational requirements of vessels, and provided a more stable environment for fish. In the construction of the continuous bend river ecological corridor, the location of the continuous bend stream connection was used as a key restoration area. This paper provides ideas and basic research for the sustainable development of ecological river channels and the construction of continuous curved river channels.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{wang2022numerical,
  author = {Pingyi Wang and Jian Li and Meili Wang and Jielong Hu and Fan Zhang},
  title = {{Numerical Simulation of the Hydraulic Characteristics and Fish Habitat of a Natural Continuous Meandering River}},
  booktitle = {Sustainability},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.3390/su14169798},
}
Figure