Numerical evaluation of spray position for improved nasal drug delivery

Saikat Basu, Landon T. Holbrook, Kathryn Kudlaty, Olulade Fasanmade, Jihong Wu, Alyssa Burke, Benjamin Langworthy, Zainab Farzal, Mohammed Mamdani, William D. Bennett, Jason P. Fine, Brent A. Senior, Adam M. Zanation, Jr. Ebert, Adam J. Kimple, Brian D. Thorp, Dennis O. Frank‐Ito, Guilherme Jm Garcia, Julia S. Kimbell

TL;DR

Researchers have developed a "Line of Sight" (LoS) nasal spray technique that improves drug delivery to diseased sinus regions by an average of 8-fold compared to standard methods. By using Computational Fluid Dynamics (CFD) and 3D-printed anatomical replicas, the study demonstrates that simply re-orienting the spray axis to point directly at the target site harnesses particle inertia to bypass anatomical obstructions.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Topical nasal sprays are the primary treatment for sinonasal diseases like chronic rhinosinusitis. However, they are notoriously inefficient. Most of the medication ends up deposited in the front of the nose (the nasal vestibule) or is swallowed, never reaching the clinically critical areas like the Ostiomeatal Complex (OMC)—the "drainage highway" for the sinuses.

The core challenge is the nose's complex, tortuous anatomy. Current usage instructions are often vague (e.g., "tilt head forward," "keep bottle upright"), leading to inconsistent results. This paper seeks a definitive, engineering-backed usage strategy to ensure medication actually reaches the intended target sites.

Methods

The researchers employed a multi-disciplinary approach combining medical imaging, fluid mechanics, and nuclear medicine:

  1. Digital Reconstruction: They used CT scans from three chronic rhinosinusitis patients to create five high-fidelity digital models of nasal passages (NPM1–NPM5).
  2. Computational Fluid Dynamics (CFD): Using ANSYS Fluent, they simulated steady-state inspiratory airflow and tracked the trajectories of droplets from a virtual Nasacort™ spray. They used Lagrangian tracking to account for droplet size distributions (5–525µm).
  3. Physical Validation: To prove the simulations were accurate, they 3D-printed replicas of the patients' nasal passages using a combination of hard and soft plastics.
  4. Gamma Scintigraphy: They labeled real Nasacort™ spray with a radioactive tracer (Technetium-99m) and sprayed it into the 3D-printed models. A gamma camera then mapped exactly where the "drug" deposited, allowing for a direct comparison between the computer model and physical reality.
  5. Protocol Comparison: They compared the "Current Use" (CU) protocol (vertically upright bottle) against their proposed "Line of Sight" (LoS) protocol, where the spray axis is aligned to point directly at the OMC.

Datasets

The study utilized de-identified CT data from three pre-surgery chronic rhinosinusitis patients (two Caucasian males, one Caucasian female). While not a large-scale public dataset, these patient-specific models provided the high-resolution geometry necessary for accurate CFD. The spray characteristics (droplet size distribution and plume angle) were based on experimental measurements of over-the-counter Nasacort™.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Harnessing Inertia: The "aha moment" lies in understanding droplet momentum. Larger droplets ($\ge 100\mu m$) have high inertia; they tend to travel in straight lines regardless of airflow. Standard techniques point these droplets at the nasal walls, where they deposit immediately. The LoS technique identifies a "clear path" to the target, allowing that inertia to carry the drug deep into the nose.
  • Airflow vs. Trajectory: While small droplets follow the curving streamlines of inhaled air, the bulk of a spray's mass is in larger droplets. Therefore, the orientation of the spray nozzle is more critical for delivery than the patient's breathing pattern.
  • The LoS Scoring System: The authors proposed a scoring system (1–4) based on how much of the OMC is visible from the nostril. This provides a potential clinical tool for physicians to determine if a patient is a good candidate for the LoS technique.
  • Validation Success: The high Pearson correlation (average ~0.91) between the CFD predictions and the gamma scintigraphy results confirms that digital "in silico" models are highly reliable for predicting drug deposition.

Key Results

  • 800% Improvement: On average, the LoS protocol achieved an 8-fold increase in drug delivery to the target sites (OMC and sinuses) compared to the standard CU protocol.
  • Subject Variability: The improvement ranged from 1.8-fold to a staggering 15.8-fold, depending on the specific anatomy of the patient.
  • Statistical Significance: The results were robust, with a paired t-test yielding a p-value of 0.03 for the "true" LoS direction.
  • Robustness: Even when the spray angle was slightly "off" (perturbed by 1mm), the LoS protocol still outperformed the standard method by an average of 3-fold.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Sample Size: The study was limited to five nasal passage models from three patients. A larger cohort is needed to account for wider anatomical diversity.
  • Steady-State Assumption: The CFD assumed steady-state laminar flow, which simplifies the actual physics of a breathing cycle, though the authors argue the impact on sinus delivery is nominal.
  • Inanimate Models: The 3D-printed validation cannot perfectly replicate the "mucociliary escalator" (the moving layer of mucus inside a living nose).
  • Clinical Translation: The next step is moving from 3D prints to clinical trials with human subjects to see if the 8-fold increase in delivery translates to faster healing and better symptom management.
  • Anatomical Constraints: Not every patient has a clear "Line of Sight." In one of the six airway sides studied, the anatomy was too obstructed to establish an LoS, highlighting the need for personalized medicine.

Summary updated

Abstract

Topical intra-nasal sprays are amongst the most commonly prescribed therapeutic options for sinonasal diseases in humans. However, inconsistency and ambiguity in instructions show a lack of definitive knowledge on best spray use techniques. In this study, we have identified a new usage strategy for nasal sprays available over-the-counter, that registers an average 8-fold improvement in topical delivery of drugs at diseased sites, when compared to prevalent spray techniques. The protocol involves re-orienting the spray axis to harness inertial motion of particulates and has been developed using computational fluid dynamics simulations of respiratory airflow and droplet transport in medical imaging-based digital models. Simulated dose in representative models is validated through in vitro spray measurements in 3D-printed anatomic replicas using the gamma scintigraphy technique. This work breaks new ground in proposing an alternative user-friendly strategy that can significantly enhance topical delivery inside human nose. While these findings can eventually translate into personalized spray usage instructions and hence merit a change in nasal standard-of-care, this study also demonstrates how relatively simple engineering analysis tools can revolutionize everyday healthcare.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{basu2020numerical,
  author = {Saikat Basu and Landon T. Holbrook and Kathryn Kudlaty and Olulade Fasanmade and Jihong Wu and Alyssa Burke and Benjamin Langworthy and Zainab Farzal and Mohammed Mamdani and William D. Bennett and Jason P. Fine and Brent A. Senior and Adam M. Zanation and Jr. Ebert and Adam J. Kimple and Brian D. Thorp and Dennis O. Frank‐Ito and Guilherme JM Garcia and Julia S. Kimbell},
  title = {{Numerical evaluation of spray position for improved nasal drug delivery}},
  booktitle = {Scientific},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.1038/s41598-020-66716-0},
}
Figure