Numerical and experimental investigations of the flow–pressure relation in multiple sequential stenoses coronary artery

Shiqiang Li, Rey Chin, Vikas Thondapu, Eric Poon, Jason Monty, Yingguang Li, Andrew Ooi, Shengxian Tu, Peter BarlisInternational Journal of Cardiac Imaging 2017 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper investigates the relationship between blood flow and pressure drop in coronary arteries with multiple sequential blockages, a crucial factor for virtual Fractional Flow Reserve (vFFR) calculations. They found a surprisingly simple linear correlation and demonstrated that steady-state flow simulations are accurate enough for vFFR, significantly reducing computational burden.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Fractional Flow Reserve (FFR) is a gold standard for assessing the severity of coronary artery blockages, guiding treatment decisions. However, invasive FFR measurement is costly, time-consuming, and requires inducing hyperemia (increased blood flow). Virtual FFR (vFFR) aims to overcome these limitations by using computational fluid dynamics (CFD) on patient-specific models derived from imaging. Despite its promise, the accuracy and complexity of vFFR simulations, particularly for the common scenario of multiple sequential stenoses, remain unclear. This study tackles this by investigating the fundamental flow-pressure relationship in such complex geometries and evaluating the necessity of simulating pulsatile blood flow for vFFR.

Methods

The researchers employed a two-pronged approach:

  • Experimental Setup: They created a physical model of a coronary artery with three sequential stenoses (blockages) of varying severity. This model was used to measure pressure drops across different sections of the artery under both steady and pulsatile flow conditions. The fluid used mimicked blood viscosity.
  • Computational Fluid Dynamics (CFD): They developed a CFD model of the same idealized arterial geometry. This model was used to simulate blood flow and pressure drop under similar conditions as the experiments. The CFD simulations utilized the incompressible Navier-Stokes equations.

A key aspect of their methodology was comparing results from steady-state flow simulations with those from pulsatile flow simulations, and then comparing both to experimental data.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study utilized a custom-built physical model and a corresponding CFD model.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Simplicity in Complexity: Despite the complex geometry of multiple sequential stenoses, the relationship between pressure drop and flow rate is remarkably linear. This suggests that the underlying physics, at least in this idealized model, can be simplified.
  • Steady Flow Suffices for vFFR: The study found that the difference in pressure drop between steady and pulsatile flow simulations was negligible. This is a significant finding, as steady-state simulations are computationally far less demanding than pulsatile ones, paving the way for faster and more accessible vFFR calculations.
  • CFD Accuracy: The CFD simulations closely matched the experimental results, validating the computational approach for predicting flow-pressure dynamics in stenotic arteries.
  • Cumulative Stenosis Effect: The pressure drop increases linearly with the number of stenoses, and the slope of this relationship is steeper with more stenoses. This highlights the cumulative impact of multiple blockages.

Key Results

  • Linear Flow-Pressure Correlation: A strong linear correlation was observed between pressure drop and flow rate, irrespective of the number of stenoses.
  • CFD-Experiment Agreement: CFD results showed good agreement with experimental data, with an approximate 5% difference.
  • Steady vs. Pulsatile Flow: The difference in pressure drop between steady and pulsatile flow conditions was found to be negligible, suggesting steady flow is a viable simplification for vFFR computations.
  • Pressure Drop Increase with Stenoses: The pressure drop increased with the number of stenoses between measurement points, as expected.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several limitations:

  • Idealized Geometry: The study used a simplified, idealized model of the coronary artery. Real-world arteries have more complex geometries and branching patterns, which could influence flow dynamics and turbulence.
  • Tight Lesions: Very tight stenoses, where laminar-turbulent transition is more likely, were not extensively studied.
  • Vessel Wall Properties: The simulations ignored the elastic properties of the vessel wall and the dynamic changes in lumen geometry during the heartbeat.

Future work could involve:

  • Patient-Specific Models: Incorporating patient-specific arterial models with more complex morphologies.
  • Vessel Compliance: Modeling the compliance of the vessel wall and its impact on flow.
  • In Vivo Studies: Conducting in vivo studies to validate these findings in actual patients.

Summary updated

Abstract

Virtual fractional flow reserve (vFFR) has been evaluated as an adjunct to invasive fractional flow reserve (FFR) in the light of its operational and economic benefits. The accuracy of vFFR and the complexity of hyperemic flow simulation are still not clearly understood. This study investigates the flow-pressure relation in an idealised multiple sequential stenoses coronary artery model via numerical and experimental approaches. Pressure drop is linearly correlated with flow rate irrespective of the number of stenosis. Computational fluid dynamics results are in good agreement with the experimental data, demonstrating reasonable accuracy of vFFR. It was also found that the difference between data obtained with steady and pulsatile flows is negligible, indicating the steady flow may be used instead of pulsatile flow conditions in vFFR computation. This study adds to the current understanding of vFFR and may improve its clinical applicability as an adjunct to invasively determined FFR.
BibTeX
@article{li2017numerical,
  author = {Shiqiang Li and Rey Chin and Vikas Thondapu and Eric Poon and Jason Monty and Yingguang Li and Andrew Ooi and Shengxian Tu and Peter Barlis},
  title = {{Numerical and experimental investigations of the flow–pressure relation in multiple sequential stenoses coronary artery}},
  journal = {International Journal of Cardiac Imaging},
  year = {2017},
  doi = {10.1007/s10554-017-1093-3},
}
Figure