Numerical Analysis of Heat Transfer Behaviours of Melting Process for Ice Thermal Storage Based on Various Heat Source Configurations

Chunwei Zhang, Dongdong Chai, Yubin Fan, Wenyun Zhang, Meng Yu, Zhenwu Wang, L. JiangSustainability 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper numerically investigates how different heat source configurations (position and shape) affect the melting process in ice thermal storage systems. The key takeaway is that placing the heat source lower and using a vertical flat-tube design significantly enhances melting speed and overall heat transfer efficiency, offering practical insights for designing more effective ice storage solutions.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Ice thermal storage (ITS) systems are crucial for balancing energy demand, especially in cooling applications. However, their efficiency is often limited by the poor thermal conductivity of phase change materials (PCMs), like water ice. While natural convection can enhance heat transfer, its impact, particularly concerning the geometry and placement of heat sources within shell-and-tube latent heat storage (STLHS) units, hasn't been fully explored. This study aims to fill this gap by systematically analyzing how various heat source configurations influence the melting process, focusing on temperature distribution, melting time, and heat transfer coefficients.

Methods

The researchers employed a numerical approach using ANSYS FLUENT to simulate the melting process of water ice in a shell-and-tube latent heat storage unit. They utilized the enthalpy-porosity method, a standard technique for modeling phase change phenomena, to handle the solid-liquid interface. The governing equations for continuity, momentum (incorporating the Boussinesq approximation for natural convection and accounting for water's density inversion around 4°C), and energy conservation were solved. The model was validated against experimental data from a previous study. The study systematically varied heat source positions (central, eccentric upper/lower) and configurations (circular, vertical flat-tube, horizontal flat-tube) under different heat fluxes (500 W/m² to 3000 W/m²).

Datasets

The study did not introduce new datasets. Instead, it relied on:

  • Experimental data from a previous study [29]: This data was used for model validation, comparing simulated temperature profiles with experimental measurements.
  • Physical properties of water: Standard thermal properties of water (specific heat, melting temperature, viscosity, thermal conductivity, thermal expansion coefficient, latent heat of fusion) were used, as listed in Table 2.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Natural convection is king: The study strongly emphasizes that natural convection, driven by density differences in the melting PCM (water), becomes the dominant heat transfer mechanism as melting progresses, significantly influencing the melting front and overall efficiency.
  • Density inversion matters: The unique density behavior of water around 4°C plays a critical role in dictating the direction of natural convection currents, which in turn affects how quickly different parts of the ice melt.
  • Heat flux dictates flow direction: A critical heat flux range (between 1000 W/m² and 2000 W/m²) was identified where the direction of natural convection flow shifts from downwards to upwards. This is directly linked to whether the water's temperature is below or above its maximum density point.
  • Geometry and position are not trivial: The shape and placement of the heat source are not minor details. They can significantly alter flow patterns and heat distribution, leading to substantial differences in melting time and heat transfer rates.

Key Results

  • Heat flux impact: Higher heat fluxes (e.g., 3000 W/m²) drastically reduce melting time compared to lower fluxes (e.g., 500 W/m²), with melting times being over five times longer at lower fluxes.
  • Eccentric heat source benefits: Placing the heat source in a lower position generally leads to shorter melting times, especially at higher heat fluxes. For instance, at 3000 W/m², a lower heat source position resulted in melting times up to 25% shorter than an upper position.
  • Vertical flat-tube superiority: The vertical flat-tube heat source configuration, particularly with an L:D ratio of 2, demonstrated the shortest melting times and highest heat transfer coefficients, outperforming central and horizontal flat-tube designs. This is attributed to better alignment with natural convection streamlines, reducing flow resistance.
  • Overall heat transfer coefficient: This coefficient initially drops sharply due to heat conduction dominance and then stabilizes, with convection becoming the primary driver. The vertical flat-tube configuration maintained higher coefficients for longer durations.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Simplified boundary conditions: The study assumed a constant temperature for the endothermic source and an adiabatic shell. Real-world applications might involve more dynamic boundary conditions.
  • Ignored shell thickness: The thickness of the inner tube and shell was ignored in the model, which might introduce minor inaccuracies.
  • Isotropic and homogeneous melting: The assumption of isotropic and homogeneous melting might not perfectly capture all real-world PCM behaviors.
  • Focus on water: While water is a common PCM, the findings might differ for other phase change materials with different thermal properties and density behaviors.

The authors suggest that their findings provide a strong basis for designing ice storage units, particularly for air conditioning applications, aiming for improved system compactness and energy storage efficiency. Future work could explore other PCMs, more complex geometries, or dynamic operating conditions.

Summary updated

Abstract

Ice thermal storage (ITS) performance for cooling systems is greatly influenced by the poor thermal conductivity of phase change material (PCM). The effect of natural convection on the melting process is significant for heat transfer enhancement. Thus, the melting performance of PCM in a shell-and-tube latent heat storage (STLHS) unit is numerically studied by considering natural convection in terms of various heat source positions and configurations, i.e., central position, eccentric position, and flat-tube type. Temperature distribution, melting time, and the overall heat transfer coefficient during the process are investigated. The results show that the circulation vortex formed by natural convection is a dominant factor that affects melting front evolution and the overall heat transfer coefficient. When input heat flux is relatively weak, PCM below the heat source is liquefied first. In contrast, PCM in the upper part melts earlier when the heat flux is excellent. The overall heat transfer coefficient decreases sharply with the increase in melting time in the early stage. Then, the heat transfer coefficient tends to be constant. PCM in an STLHS unit with a heat source in a lower position and a configuration of vertical flat-tube type has a desirable performance when compared with other cases, which could provide good support for ITS application.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{zhang2022numerical,
  author = {Chunwei Zhang and Dongdong Chai and Yubin Fan and Wenyun Zhang and Meng Yu and Zhenwu Wang and L. Jiang},
  title = {{Numerical Analysis of Heat Transfer Behaviours of Melting Process for Ice Thermal Storage Based on Various Heat Source Configurations}},
  booktitle = {Sustainability},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.3390/su15010365},
}
Figure