Numerical analysis of a multistable capsule system under the delayed feedback control with a constant delay

Zhi Zhang, Joseph Páez Chávez, Jan Sieber, Yang Liu

Abstract

The vibro-impact capsule system is a self-propelled mechanism that has abundant coexisting attractors and moves rectilinearly under periodic excitation when overcoming environmental resistance. In this paper, we study the control of coexisting attractors in this system by using a delayed feedback controller (DFC) with a constant delay. The aim of our control is to steer this complex system toward an attractor with preferable performance characteristics among multiple coexisting attractors, e.g., a periodically fast forward progression. For this purpose, we give an example of a feedback-controlled transition from a period-3 motion with low progression speed to a period-1 motion with high progression speed at the system parameters where both responses coexist. The effectiveness of this controller is investigated numerically by considering its convergence time and the required control energy input to achieve transition. We combine pseudo-spectral approximation of the delay, event detection for the discontinuities and path-following (continuation) techniques for non-smooth delay dynamical systems to carry out bifurcation analysis. We systematically study the dynamical performance of the controlled system when varying its control gain and delay time. Our numerical simulations show the effectiveness of DFC under a wide range of system parameters. We find that the desired period-1 motion is achievable in a range of control delays between a period-doubling and a grazing bifurcation. Therefore, two-parameter continuation of these two bifurcations with respect to the control delay and control gain is conducted to identify the delay-gain parameter region where the period-1 motion is stable. The findings of this work can be used for tuning control parameters in experiments, and similar analysis can be carried out for other non-smooth dynamical systems with a constant delay term.

Introduction: The Challenge of Multistability in Capsule Robots

Vibro-impact capsule systems represent a promising frontier for medical devices, such as self-propelled endoscopes for gastrointestinal navigation. These systems generate motion by vibrating an internal mass against a housing, overcoming environmental friction to "hop" forward. However, their highly nonlinear, non-smooth dynamics lead to multistability—the coexistence of multiple attractors for a single set of parameters.

Schematic of the vibro-impact capsule system showing internal mass $m_1$ and capsule shell $m_2$.

In practice, this means a robot might move at its maximum speed, crawl slowly, or behave chaotically depending on its initial state. For medical applications, ensuring the robot operates in its most efficient "Period-1" (fast) motion is critical. This paper investigates using a Delayed Feedback Controller (DFC) to reliably steer the system toward these high-performance states.

Methods: Taming Non-Smooth Delay Dynamics

The researchers implemented a Delayed Feedback Control (DFC) strategy, specifically a Pyragas-type controller. This non-invasive approach applies corrections based on the difference between the current velocity and the velocity one cycle prior. When the system reaches the target periodic state, the control signal vanishes, minimizing energy consumption.

Analyzing this system required overcoming the mathematical complexity of "non-smooth delay differential equations." The authors utilized:

  • Pseudo-spectral Approximation: Converting the infinite-dimensional delay problem into a finite system of ordinary differential equations (ODEs).
  • Numerical Continuation (COCO Platform): Employing path-following techniques to map stability boundaries as control gain and delay time vary.
  • Event Detection: Specialized routines to handle discontinuities caused by impacts and friction transitions (static to kinetic).

Key Insights and Results

The study reveals that the desired fast motion is achievable within a specific "stability window" of time delays, bounded by period-doubling and grazing bifurcations.

Bifurcation diagram and phase portraits showing the transition from periodic to chaotic motion as frequency $\omega$ varies.

Key findings include:

  • Speed Doubling: The controller successfully transitioned the system from a "Period-3" motion (velocity ~0.0926) to a "Period-1" motion (velocity ~0.1753), nearly doubling the progression speed.
  • Chaos Suppression: The framework effectively stabilized chaotic trajectories into steady, high-speed periodic motions.
  • Optimization: An optimal gain ($K = 0.11$) was identified that balances fast convergence with low control energy requirements.

Conclusion and Future Directions

While the numerical framework is robust, it relies on a mathematical approximation most accurate for small delays. Future work will address variable delays (e.g., sensor jitter) and experimental validation on physical prototypes to test these "tuning maps" against real-world noise and friction uncertainties. This research provides a foundational manual for engineers to guarantee stable, high-speed movement in autonomous capsule systems.

Summary updated

Abstract

The vibro-impact capsule system is a self-propelled mechanism that has abundant coexisting attractors and moves rectilinearly under periodic excitation when overcoming environmental resistance. In this paper, we study the control of coexisting attractors in this system by using a delayed feedback controller (DFC) with a constant delay. The aim of our control is to steer this complex system toward an attractor with preferable performance characteristics among multiple coexisting attractors, e.g., a periodically fast forward progression. For this purpose, we give an example of a feedback-controlled transition from a period-3 motion with low progression speed to a period-1 motion with high progression speed at the system parameters where both responses coexist. The effectiveness of this controller is investigated numerically by considering its convergence time and the required control energy input to achieve transition. We combine pseudo-spectral approximation of the delay, event detection for the discontinuities and path-following (continuation) techniques for non-smooth delay dynamical systems to carry out bifurcation analysis. We systematically study the dynamical performance of the controlled system when varying its control gain and delay time. Our numerical simulations show the effectiveness of DFC under a wide range of system parameters. We find that the desired period-1 motion is achievable in a range of control delays between a period-doubling and a grazing bifurcation. Therefore, two-parameter continuation of these two bifurcations with respect to the control delay and control gain is conducted to identify the delay-gain parameter region where the period-1 motion is stable. The findings of this work can be used for tuning control parameters in experiments, and similar analysis can be carried out for other non-smooth dynamical systems with a constant delay term.
BibTeX
@misc{zhang2023numerical,
  author = {Zhi Zhang and Joseph Páez Chávez and Jan Sieber and Yang Liu},
  title = {{Numerical analysis of a multistable capsule system under the delayed feedback control with a constant delay}},
  year = {2023},
  eprint = {2302.08543},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/2302.08543},
}
Figure