Nucleation and phase transition of decagonal quasicrystals

Tiejun Zhou, Lei Zhang, Pingwen Zhang, An‐Chang Shi, Kai Jiang

TL;DR

Researchers have developed a novel "nullspace-preserving saddle search" (NPSS) algorithm to map the complex birth and transformation of decagonal quasicrystals. Their findings reveal that these exotic structures prefer "stepwise" transitions—moving through intermediate phases to break or recover symmetry—because these paths offer significantly lower energy barriers than direct, one-step transformations.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Quasicrystals are a fascinating state of matter: they possess long-range order and distinct rotational symmetry (like a 10-fold decagon), yet they lack the repeating translational symmetry found in ordinary crystals. Understanding how they form from a liquid (nucleation) or transform into periodic crystals is a major challenge in condensed matter physics.

Experimentally, these events happen at ultra-high speeds and involve unstable "critical nuclei" that are nearly impossible to capture. Computationally, the challenge is even steeper. The "energy landscape" of these systems is full of "nullspaces"—flat regions where traditional search algorithms get stuck. Furthermore, because quasicrystals and regular crystals don't "line up" (they are incommensurate), representing both in the same simulation requires sophisticated mathematical workarounds.

Methods

The authors employ a multi-pronged theoretical approach:

  • Lifshitz-Petrich (LP) Model: A mathematical framework used to represent the density profiles of quasiperiodic systems.
  • NPSS Algorithm: This is the paper's core technical contribution. To find "saddle points" (the high-energy mountain passes between stable states), the NPSS algorithm ensures the search direction stays orthogonal to the "nullspace" of the starting state. This prevents the simulation from wasting time in the flat regions of the energy landscape.
  • Periodic Approximation & Diophantine Theory: To simulate incommensurate structures together, the authors use Diophantine approximation to find a large "periodic box" that can approximately fit both the quasicrystal and the periodic crystal with minimal error.
  • Group-Subgroup Theory: The authors use formal symmetry groups (like $p10mm$ for decagonal quasicrystals) to track exactly how symmetry is lost or gained during a transition.

Datasets

As a theoretical physics paper, this work does not use external experimental datasets. Instead, it generates its own data through numerical simulations of the LP model. The authors utilized the AGPD (Automatically Generating Phase Diagram) software to map out stable regions across different temperature-like parameters ($\tau$) and interaction intensities ($\gamma$).

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Discovery of Intermediate Phases: The study identified three previously uncharacterized stable or metastable phases: the Fusiform Crystal (FC), the Pseudo-6-fold crystal (PC6), and the Lamellar Quasicrystal (LQ).
  • The "Stepwise" Preference: The most striking insight is that nature prefers the scenic route. Instead of a direct jump from a Decagonal Quasicrystal (DQC) to a periodic crystal, the system favors a two-stage path (e.g., DQC $\rightarrow$ LQ $\rightarrow$ FC).
  • Symmetry Costs Energy: The authors found a direct correlation between the amount of symmetry changed and the height of the energy barrier. Breaking 10-fold symmetry and mirror symmetry simultaneously is "expensive" (high energy barrier), whereas breaking them one by one is much "cheaper."
  • Symmetry Recovery: The same logic applies in reverse. When forming a DQC from a crystal, the system recovers its high-order symmetry in stages rather than all at once.

Key Results

  • Nucleation Path: The authors successfully mapped the path from a high-symmetry liquid to a DQC, identifying the "critical nucleus" that triggers the transformation.
  • Quantified Barriers: In the transition from DQC to FC, the one-stage path had an energy barrier ($\Delta f$) of $2 \times 10^{-7}$, while the first step of the two-stage path (DQC $\rightarrow$ LQ) was only $1 \times 10^{-7}$.
  • Probability: Because the nucleation rate $J$ depends exponentially on the energy barrier ($J \propto \exp(-\Delta f)$), the lower-barrier stepwise paths are mathematically much more likely to occur in nature.

Limitations and Future Work

While the LP model is a powerful tool for understanding the physics of symmetry, it is a simplified 2D model. Real-world metallic quasicrystals are 3D and involve complex atomic interactions that this model doesn't fully capture.

The authors suggest that future research should apply the NPSS method to 3D systems, such as icosahedral quasicrystals, and explore the "kinetic prefactor"—a variable in the nucleation rate equation that was assumed to be constant in this study but could influence the speed of these transitions in real materials.

Summary updated

Abstract

In this work, we study the nucleation of quasicrystals from liquid or periodic crystals by developing an efficient order-order phase transition algorithm, namely, the nullspace-preserving saddle search method. In particular, we focus on nucleation and phase transitions of the decagonal quasicrystal (DQC) based on the Lifshitz-Petrich model. We present the nucleation path of DQC from the liquid and demonstrate one- and two-stage transition paths between DQC and periodic crystals. We provide a perspective of the group-subgroup phase transition and nucleation rates to understand the nucleation and phase transition mechanisms involving DQC. These results reveal the one-step and multi-step modes of symmetry breaking or recovery in the phase transition from DQC, where the multi-step modes are more probable.
BibTeX
@article{zhou2024nucleation,
  author = {Tiejun Zhou and Lei Zhang and Pingwen Zhang and An‐Chang Shi and Kai Jiang},
  title = {{Nucleation and phase transition of decagonal quasicrystals}},
  journal = {The Journal of Chemical Physics},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.1063/5.0232334},
}

Loading related content...

Figure