Nucleated polymerisation in the presence of pre-formed seed filaments

Samuel I. A. Cohen, Michele Vendruscolo, Christopher M. Dobson, Tuomas P. J. Knowles

Abstract: We revisit the classical problem of nucleated polymerisation and derive a range of exact results describing polymerisation in systems intermediate between the well-known limiting cases of a reaction starting from purely soluble material and for a reaction where no new growth nuclei are formed.

Introduction

The assembly of proteins into long, thread-like filaments is a fundamental process in biological systems, playing roles in both healthy cellular architecture (e.g., actin) and the pathology of neurodegenerative diseases (e.g., amyloid fibrils in Alzheimer’s). Historically, the mathematical modeling of these processes relied on the Oosawa theory from the 1960s. However, Oosawa’s exact solutions were limited to two extreme scenarios: purely soluble systems starting from monomers and purely seeded systems where no new nuclei form.

Real-world experimental conditions frequently occupy an intermediate regime where spontaneous nucleation and growth from added seeds occur simultaneously. This paper addresses this gap by providing the first exact analytical solutions for nucleated polymerization in systems containing arbitrary amounts of pre-formed seed filaments.

Methodology

The authors derive their solutions starting from the master equation, which tracks the concentration of every possible filament size over time. By focusing on the total number of filaments ($P$) and the total mass ($M$), and assuming irreversible growth—a condition typical of many experimental setups—the complex system is reduced to a single second-order differential equation for free monomer concentration.

Using a logarithmic substitution, the problem is transformed into a separable equation, yielding solutions expressed through hyperbolic functions ($\text{sech}$ and $\text{tanh}$). These provide a clean, exact formula for polymer mass evolution. The analytical solutions were validated against numerical simulations, showing a perfect match across various seed concentrations (see Figure 2).

Growth curves showing the fractional fibrillar mass concentration over time for various ratios of initial seed strength to nucleation strength ($k_0/\lambda$).

Key Insights and Diagnostic Tools

A central finding is the mathematical definition of the "lag phase." The authors demonstrate that an inflection point in the growth curve—the hallmark of a lag phase—only exists if $k_0 < \lambda$. This implies that a lag phase occurs only when growth from added seeds is slower than the rate of spontaneous nucleation and subsequent growth.

Furthermore, the paper provides a crucial diagnostic framework for researchers to distinguish between different underlying physical mechanisms. While primary nucleation and secondary nucleation (such as fragmentation) both produce S-shaped curves, their early-time growth behaviors differ significantly: primary nucleation follows a polynomial rise ($t^2, t^3$, etc.), whereas secondary nucleation exhibits exponential growth. This distinction is vital for identifying the underlying physical mechanism of a disease or biological process, as summarized in Figure 4.

Comparison of kinetic parameters, early-time growth behavior, and scaling laws across different nucleation mechanisms.

Results and Scaling Laws

The study culminates in the derivation of exact closed-form expressions (Equations 9 and 10) for the evolution of polymer mass $M(t)$ and number $P(t)$ for any initial seed concentration. These equations are unified, reducing perfectly to Oosawa’s classic 1962 results when seed concentration is set to zero. Additionally, the paper confirms the inverse relationship between maximal growth rate ($r_{max}$) and lag time ($\tau_{lag}$), a characteristic scaling law of nucleated growth that persists even in the presence of seeds.

Discussion and Future Directions

While the current model assumes irreversibility, it provides a robust baseline for the field. Future work may extend these derivations to include depolymerization effects. By offering exact results, this work enables more accurate "global fitting" of experimental aggregation data, helping researchers determine precisely how proteins misfold and aggregate in various biological contexts.

Summary updated

Abstract

We revisit the classical problem of nucleated polymerisation and derive a range of exact results describing polymerisation in systems intermediate between the well-known limiting cases of a reaction starting from purely soluble material and for a reaction where no new growth nuclei are formed.
BibTeX
@article{cohen2011nucleated,
  author = {Samuel I. A. Cohen and Michele Vendruscolo and Christopher M. Dobson and Tuomas P. J. Knowles},
  title = {{Nucleated polymerisation in the presence of pre-formed seed filaments}},
  journal = {International Journal of Molecular Sciences},
  year = {2011},
  doi = {10.3390/ijms12095844},
}
Figure