Novel 'Housekeeping' Genes and an Unusually Heterogeneous Distribution of Transporter Expression Profiles in Human Tissues and Cell Lines, Assessed Using the Gini Coefficient

Steve O’Hagan, Marina Wright Muelas, Philip J. Day, Emma Lundberg, Douglas B. Kell

This research paper, published in bioRxiv, explores the distribution of membrane transporters across human tissues using a tool borrowed from economics: the Gini coefficient. By quantifying expression inequality, the authors reveal that transporters are far more specialized than previously thought and identify a new suite of "housekeeping" genes that could revolutionize how we normalize transcriptomic data.

TL;DR

By applying the Gini coefficient to human transcriptome data, researchers discovered that membrane transporters are unusually specialized in their tissue distribution, far exceeding the "inequality" seen in global wealth distributions. The study also identifies PCBP1 as a highly stable, high-expression "housekeeping" gene, offering a superior alternative for normalizing genetic experiments.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

In biology, we often categorize genes as either "housekeeping" (expressed everywhere to maintain basic cell functions) or "specialized" (expressed only in specific tissues like the liver or brain). Membrane transporters—the SLC and ABC families—are the gatekeepers of the cell, moving nutrients in and drugs out.

The challenge is twofold:

  1. We lack a precise, non-parametric way to quantify exactly how "specialized" a gene’s distribution is across the entire body.
  2. The "housekeeping" genes we currently use to calibrate experiments (like GAPDH or ACTB) are actually quite variable across different tissues, which can lead to skewed results in qPCR and transcriptomic studies.

Methods

The authors utilized the Gini coefficient (or Gini index), a statistical measure typically used by economists to calculate income inequality. In this context:

  • A Gini of 0 represents "perfect equality" (the gene is expressed at the exact same level in every tissue).
  • A Gini of 1 represents "extreme inequality" (the gene is expressed in only one tissue).

They calculated Gini indices for thousands of genes using RNA-seq data. To handle the complex data flows and visualization, they employed the KNIME analytics platform and the ineq R package. They also validated their findings using Immunohistochemistry (IHC) from the Human Protein Atlas to ensure that mRNA expression levels matched actual protein presence in tissues.

Datasets

The study analyzed two massive datasets from the Human Protein Atlas:

  • The Tissue Atlas: Transcriptome data for 409 SLCs and 48 ABCs across 59 different human tissue types.
  • The Cell Atlas: Expression profiles for the same transporters across 56 human-derived cell lines.
  • Comparative Data: They also calculated Gini indices for "other" (non-transporter) genes to provide a baseline for "normal" genomic distribution.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Transporters are the "1%": The median Gini coefficient for SLC transporters is 0.587. To put that in perspective, that is higher than the income inequality of any country on Earth. Transporters are significantly more heterogeneously expressed than most other gene classes.
  • The Specialization Paradox: Many transporters have extremely high Gini coefficients (above 0.9), meaning they are nearly tissue-specific. This is surprising because many of their substrates (like glucose or amino acids) are needed by every cell in the body. This suggests a much higher level of evolutionary "tuning" and specialization than textbooks imply.
  • Cell Lines as Mirrors: Generally, cell lines maintain transport profiles similar to their tissues of origin. However, ABC transporters (efflux pumps) showed higher Gini indices in cell lines, suggesting that lab culture conditions might select for specific transport behaviors.
  • Rethinking "Housekeeping": The study found that traditional housekeeping genes often have Gini indices around 0.2–0.3. The authors identified a group of genes with much lower Gini indices (0.11–0.14), indicating far greater stability across the body.

Key Results

  • Top Housekeeping Candidate: The gene PCBP1 emerged as a "super-housekeeping" gene. It has a very low Gini index (0.139 in tissues, 0.135 in cell lines) and is expressed at high enough levels (median >100 TPM) to be easily detected and used for normalization.
  • Tissue Extremes: The kidney showed the highest overall expression of transporters, while the pancreas showed the lowest, potentially explaining why it is so difficult to target drugs to the pancreas.
  • Specific Findings: SLCO1B1 (a major statin transporter) was confirmed to be almost entirely liver-specific (Gini ~0.96), while SLC35A4 was found to be one of the most uniformly distributed transporters.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge that their analysis focused on whole tissues. This averages out the "intra-organ" distribution. For example, a transporter might be expressed throughout the liver, or it might be restricted to specific zones (perivenous vs. periportal).

Future work should apply this Gini-based approach to single-cell RNA-seq data to understand how transporters are distributed across different cell types within a single organ. Additionally, the "natural" substrates for many of these highly specialized transporters remain unknown, representing a major gap in our understanding of human biochemistry.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract We analyse two comprehensive transcriptome datasets from human tissues and human-derived cell lines in terms of the expression profiles of the SLC and ABC families of membrane transporters. The Gini index (coefficient) characterises inequalities of distributions, and is used in a novel way to describe the distribution of the expression of each transporter among the different tissues and cell lines. In many cases, transporters exhibit extremely high Gini coefficients, even when their supposed substrates might be expected to be available to all tissues, indicating a much higher degree of specialisation than is usually assumed. This is consistent with divergent evolution from a more restricted set of ancestors. Similar trends hold true for the expression profiles of transporters in different cell lines, suggesting that cell lines exhibit largely similar transport behaviour to that of tissues. By contrast, the Gini coefficients for ABC transporters tend to be larger in cell lines than in tissues, implying that some kind of a selection process has taken place. In particular, with some exceptions such as olfactory receptors and genes involved in keratin production, transporter genes are significantly more heterogeneously expressed than are most non-transporter genes. The Gini index also allows us to determine those transcripts with the most stable expression; these often differ significantly from the ‘housekeeping’ genes commonly used for normalisation in transcriptomics and qPCR studies. The lowest four in tissues are FAM32A, ABCB7, MRPL21 and PCBP1, while the lowest three in cell lines are SF3B2, NXF1 and RBM45. PCBP1 is both reasonably highly expressed and has a low Gini coefficient in both tissues and cell lines, and is an excellent novel housekeeping gene. Overall, our analyses provide novel opportunities for the normalisation of genome-wide expression profiling data.
BibTeX
@misc{ohagan2018novel,
  author = {Steve O’Hagan and Marina Wright Muelas and Philip J. Day and Emma Lundberg and Douglas B. Kell},
  title = {{Novel 'Housekeeping' Genes and an Unusually Heterogeneous Distribution of Transporter Expression Profiles in Human Tissues and Cell Lines, Assessed Using the Gini Coefficient}},
  year = {2018},
  doi = {10.2139/ssrn.3155744},
  howpublished = {SSRN},
}
Figure