Nonmyopic Distilled Data Association Belief Space Planning Under Budget Constraints

Moshe Shienman, Vadim Indelman

Abstract

Robotic planning in environments with perceptual aliasing requires maintaining multiple hypotheses, leading to an exponential explosion of possibilities during long-term planning. This paper introduces ND2A-BSP, a computationally efficient framework that utilizes a "belief tree skeleton" and "belief distillation" to make high-quality decisions under strict computational budgets. By calculating upper and lower bounds on cost functions, the algorithm provides provable performance guarantees while significantly reducing the number of hypotheses processed.

Introduction

A fundamental challenge in robotics is navigating environments where different locations appear identical, a phenomenon known as perceptual aliasing. To remain localized, a robot must maintain a multi-modal belief consisting of several hypotheses. When planning future actions—a process known as Belief Space Planning (BSP)—the number of potential future scenarios grows exponentially with the planning horizon and the number of possible data associations.

Existing systems often manage this complexity by heuristically pruning hypotheses. However, such pruning typically lacks a formal understanding of how information loss impacts decision quality. Furthermore, robots often face hard computational budgets in both inference (maintaining beliefs) and planning (evaluating future actions). ND2A-BSP addresses these challenges by integrating budget constraints directly into the planning process.

Methods: ND2A-BSP

The proposed Nonmyopic Distilled Data Association BSP (ND2A-BSP) framework introduces several key innovations to manage complexity without sacrificing decision quality.

Belief Tree Skeleton

Instead of performing full probabilistic updates at every node of a planning tree, the algorithm constructs a "skeleton." It samples future observations to look ahead, avoiding the heavy computational cost of updating every possible hypothesis at every step.

The belief tree skeleton allows for nonmyopic planning by sampling future observations without full belief updates at every node.

Belief Distillation and Bounding

The core mechanism for efficiency is "belief distillation." Rather than evaluating all $N$ hypotheses, the algorithm selects a distilled subset. This subset is used to calculate upper and lower bounds on the true cost function (such as Shannon Entropy).

If the upper bound for Action A is lower than the lower bound for Action B, Action A is guaranteed to be better than Action B. This allows the robot to discard suboptimal actions and hypotheses without ever calculating the full, complex belief, maintaining optimality while adhering to a computational budget.

When bounds for different actions do not overlap, the optimal action can be identified without full belief evaluation.

Key Insights

  • Optimal Pruning: The paper demonstrates that exact probabilities for every hypothesis are not always necessary for optimal decision-making. As long as the "best-case" and "worst-case" estimates for an action are sufficiently separated from others, the optimal move is clear.
  • Horizon Advantage: Interestingly, longer planning horizons can make it easier to discard incorrect hypotheses, as more future observations provide additional opportunities for disambiguation.
  • Planning-Centric Heuristics: In scenarios where the planner influences which hypotheses the inference engine retains, the authors identified a novel heuristic ($h^{p*}$). This heuristic prioritizes hypotheses that minimize loss in planning quality, rather than just keeping the most likely states.

Results

The framework was evaluated in simulated environments, including a "kidnapped robot" scenario across multiple identical floors and a complex 2D environment with random landmarks.

  • Efficiency and Scalability: In the "Floors" environment, ND2A-BSP achieved optimal solutions with zero loss while using only a fraction of the total hypotheses. While planning time for full belief evaluation exploded as the number of prior hypotheses grew, ND2A-BSP's planning time remained relatively flat.
  • Guaranteed Quality: Under strict budgets (e.g., limiting the inference engine to 3 hypotheses), the algorithm successfully provided an upper bound on the potential loss compared to an infinite-budget version.

Conclusion

ND2A-BSP provides a robust framework for nonmyopic planning in ambiguous environments under computational constraints. By leveraging belief distillation and cost function bounding, it offers a way to maintain decision quality while avoiding the exponential growth of hypotheses. Future work will explore the application of these techniques to non-linear cost functions and testing on physical hardware in dynamic real-world settings.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@inproceedings{shienman2022nonmyopic,
  author = {Moshe Shienman and Vadim Indelman},
  title = {{Nonmyopic Distilled Data Association Belief Space Planning Under Budget Constraints}},
  booktitle = {ISRR},
  year = {2022},
  url = {https://openreview.net/forum?id=PiPjw34MzG},
}

Loading related content...

Figure