Nonlinear synthetic gauge potentials and sonic horizons in Bose-Einstein condensates

Salvatore Butera, Niclas Westerberg, Daniele Faccio, Patrik ÖhbergarXiv 2016 · DOI · arXiv

Abstract

Phonons in a Bose-Einstein condensate can be made to behave as if they propagate in curved spacetime by controlling the condensate flow speed. Seemingly disconnected to this, artificial gauge potentials can be induced in charge neutral atomic condensates by for instance coupling two atomic levels to a laser field. Here we connect these two worlds and show that synthetic interacting gauge fields, i.e., density-dependent gauge potentials, induce a non-trivial spacetime structure for the phonons. This allows for the creation of new spacetime geometries which depend not on the flow speed of the condensate but on an easily controlled transverse laser phase. Using this, we show how to create artificial black holes in a stationary condensate, we simulate charge in a Reissner-Nordström black hole and induce cosmological horizons by creating de Sitter spacetimes. We then show how to combine this de Sitter spacetime with a black hole, which also opens up the possibility to study in experiments its quantum stability.

Introduction: Beyond Flow-Based Analogue Gravity

For decades, the field of "analogue gravity" has provided a tabletop window into the physics of curved spacetime. By using fluids or optical systems, researchers can simulate phenomena like Hawking radiation that are otherwise inaccessible in astrophysical settings. In a Bose-Einstein Condensate (BEC), sound waves (phonons) experience what is known as an "acoustic metric." Traditionally, creating a sonic horizon—the acoustic equivalent of a black hole's event horizon—required the condensate to flow faster than its local speed of sound.

However, these models have been constrained by a single degree of freedom: the fluid's flow velocity. This limitation makes it difficult to engineer complex spacetime geometries or to simulate particles with intrinsic properties like electric charge. This paper introduces a second, independent control mechanism: nonlinear synthetic gauge fields.

Synthetic Gauge Fields and the Density-Dependent Twist

The researchers propose a system where two internal atomic levels of a BEC are coupled by a laser field. This coupling induces a Berry connection, which acts as a synthetic vector potential ($\mathbf{A}$) for the neutral atoms. The breakthrough lies in making this potential density-dependent (nonlinear). By tailoring laser parameters, the vector potential becomes a function of the local condensate density ($\rho$).

Schematic of a BEC setup showing the bulk flow velocity $v_0$ and the induced velocity $v_a$ resulting from synthetic gauge potentials.

As shown in the figure above, the total velocity field of the condensate is no longer just the bulk flow $v_0$ along the $x_3$ axis. The nonlinear gauge potential induces an additional velocity component $v_a$ in the transverse plane. Because laser phases are significantly easier to manipulate with high precision than the bulk flow of a quantum fluid, this approach offers a versatile "design kit" for warping the effective spacetime felt by phonons.

The Acoustic Metric and Kaluza-Klein Reduction

By linearizing the Gross-Pitaevskii Equation (GPE), the authors demonstrate that phonon perturbations evolve according to a wave equation identical to that of a scalar field in curved spacetime. The resulting acoustic metric $g_{\mu\nu}$ is influenced by both the fluid flow and the nonlinear gauge potential.

To simulate charge and mass, the authors employ a mathematical technique known as Kaluza-Klein reduction. They map the 3+1 dimensional system onto a 2+1 dimensional effective theory. In this framework, the third spatial dimension ($x_3$) acts as a "hidden" dimension. The phonon's momentum along this axis generates an effective mass and charge in the lower-dimensional plane, allowing phonons to behave like charged particles moving through a gravitational field.

Key Results: From Cyclotrons to Black Holes

The integration of nonlinear gauge potentials leads to several significant theoretical results:

  • Modified Acoustic Metric: A new metric form was derived that explicitly incorporates the induced velocity $\mathbf{v}_a$ from the nonlinear vector potential.
  • Effective Cyclotron Motion: By shaping the laser beam such that the phase gradient $\nabla \phi$ follows a $(1/r)\hat{e}_\theta$ profile, the researchers can induce a constant effective magnetic field. This causes phonons to undergo cyclotron-like precession with a frequency $\omega_c$.
  • Exotic Spacetimes: The framework allows for the simulation of Reissner-Nordström (charged) black holes and de Sitter (cosmological) spacetimes within a stationary condensate.

Experimental Outlook and Limitations

While theoretically robust, experimental realization faces specific challenges. The system requires the laser's Rabi frequency ($\Omega$) to be much larger than the BEC's chemical potential ($\mu$) to maintain adiabaticity. Furthermore, using long-lived atomic species like Ytterbium or Strontium is crucial to prevent spontaneous emission from decohering the condensate.

Despite these hurdles, the ability to combine de Sitter spacetimes with black hole geometries opens new avenues for studying quantum stability and the interplay between thermodynamics and gravity in a highly controlled laboratory environment.

Summary updated

Abstract

Phonons in a Bose-Einstein condensate can be made to behave as if they propagate in curved spacetime by controlling the condensate flow speed. Seemingly disconnected to this, artificial gauge potentials can be induced in charge neutral atomic condensates by for instance coupling two atomic levels to a laser field. Here we connect these two worlds and show that synthetic interacting gauge fields, i.e., density-dependent gauge potentials, induce a non-trivial spacetime structure for the phonons. This allows for the creation of new spacetime geometries which depend not on the flow speed of the condensate but on an easily controlled transverse laser phase. Using this, we show how to create artificial black holes in a stationary condensate, we simulate charge in a Reissner-Nordström black hole and induce cosmological horizons by creating de Sitter spacetimes. We then show how to combine this de Sitter spacetime with a black hole, which also opens up the possibility to study in experiments its quantum stability.
BibTeX
@misc{butera2016nonlinear,
  author = {Salvatore Butera and Niclas Westerberg and Daniele Faccio and Patrik Öhberg},
  title = {{Nonlinear synthetic gauge potentials and sonic horizons in Bose-Einstein condensates}},
  year = {2016},
  eprint = {1605.05556},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/1605.05556},
}
Figure