Nonlinear functional regression: a functional RKHS approach

Hachem Kadri, Emmanuel Duflos, Philippe Preux, Stéphane Canu, Manuel DavyAISTATS 2010 · OpenReview

Abstract

This paper addresses the challenge of functional regression, where both input attributes and responses are functions rather than scalars or vectors. We develop a functional Reproducing Kernel Hilbert Space (RKHS) framework to model these complex, nonlinear relationships. By generalizing kernel methods to handle operator-valued kernels and proving a functional version of the Representer Theorem, we provide a robust, nonparametric solution that significantly outperforms traditional linear functional models in both simulated and real-world meteorological datasets.

Introduction

In fields such as meteorology, finance, and medicine, data often takes the form of continuous processes or curves. Traditional regression techniques, designed for scalar or vector inputs, struggle to capture the infinite-dimensional nature of these "functional" data points. While Functional Data Analysis (FDA) has emerged to treat curves as single entities, most existing tools are limited by linear assumptions or rigid parametric forms. This work introduces a flexible, nonlinear framework for functional regression using RKHS.

Methodology: Functional RKHS

The core of our approach is the extension of kernel methods to the functional domain.

Operator-Valued Kernels

In standard kernel methods, a kernel $k(x, y)$ returns a scalar similarity. We define a functional kernel $K(x, y)$ as an operator that maps a function to another function. This allows the model to capture intricate dependencies between input and output curves.

Functional Representer Theorem

We prove that the Representer Theorem holds in this functional setting. This ensures that the optimal regression function can be expressed as a finite linear combination of kernel operators applied to the training samples, making the infinite-dimensional problem computationally tractable.

The Functional Gaussian Kernel

We introduce a functional counterpart to the ubiquitous Radial Basis Function (RBF) kernel, using an exponential of the squared distance between functions. This allows the model to adapt its shape to the data without rigid parametric constraints.

A 3D visualization of the functional relationship or kernel surface used in nonlinear regression.

Experimental Setup

We evaluated the proposed method on two primary datasets:

  1. Simulated Data: A synthetic dataset generated using nonlinear bivariate functions (peaks and exponentials) to establish a ground truth for performance comparison.
  2. Canadian Weather Data: A benchmark FDA dataset consisting of daily temperature and precipitation measurements from 35 weather stations across Canada, averaged over 30 years. The objective is to predict the log-precipitation profile based on the temperature profile.
Canadian weather data profiles showing (a) daily temperature and (b) log-precipitation across 35 stations.

Key Results

The functional RKHS approach demonstrates significant improvements over Linear Functional Regression (LFR):

  • Simulation Performance: The Root Residual Sum of Squares (RRSS) was reduced from 2.07 (LFR) to 0.94 (RKHS).
  • Meteorological Accuracy: On the Canadian weather data, the RKHS model consistently outperformed linear models. For instance, in Montreal, the prediction error dropped from 1.52 to 1.37.
  • Qualitative Fidelity: Visually, the RKHS estimates follow the true precipitation curves more closely, particularly during sharp seasonal transitions where linear models often produce overly smoothed or inaccurate results.

Conclusion and Future Work

Our functional RKHS framework provides a powerful tool for nonlinear nonparametric regression on curves. While effective, the approach faces computational challenges as the number of measurement points grows. Future research will focus on implementing $l_1$ regularization for sparsity, developing automated hyperparameter selection, and adapting the algorithm for real-time streaming data.

Summary updated

Abstract

This paper deals with functional regression, in which the input attributes as well as the response are functions. To deal with this problem, we develop a functional reproducing kernel Hilbert space...
BibTeX
@inproceedings{kadri2010nonlinear,
  author = {Hachem Kadri and Emmanuel Duflos and Philippe Preux and Stéphane Canu and Manuel Davy},
  title = {{Nonlinear functional regression: a functional RKHS approach}},
  booktitle = {International Conference on Artificial Intelligence and Statistics},
  year = {2010},
  url = {https://openreview.net/forum?id=oBftbdnsMh},
}
Figure