Noninvasive and Real-Time Plasmon Waveguide Resonance Thermometry

Pengfei Zhang, Le Liu, Yonghong He, Yanfei Zhou, Yanhong Ji, Hui Ma

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel noninvasive, real-time temperature sensing technique called Plasmon Waveguide Resonance (PWR) thermometry. By leveraging an enhanced evanescent field and a thermal shielding effect, this method achieves high sensitivity and a wide dynamic range, outperforming traditional Surface Plasmon Resonance (SPR) sensors and offering a cost-effective solution for temperature measurement.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Accurate and noninvasive temperature sensing is crucial across various scientific and medical fields, from microfluidics to clinical diagnostics. While optical temperature sensors offer advantages like electrical immunity and compactness, existing Surface Plasmon Resonance (SPR) based thermometers face limitations in sensitivity (typically around 0.1 °C) and dynamic range (around 10 °C). These limitations stem from the background thermo-optic (TO) effect of the metal film used in SPR sensors, which can interfere with accurate temperature measurements, especially over wider ranges. The paper aims to overcome these limitations by developing a more sensitive and robust optical temperature sensor.

Methods

The researchers developed a Plasmon Waveguide Resonance (PWR) sensor, specifically a symmetrical PWR (sPWR) structure. This structure is an advancement over traditional SPR sensors by incorporating a dielectric layer (magnesium fluoride, MgF2) between the prism and the gold film, and another dielectric layer on top of the gold film. This configuration enhances the evanescent field and couples surface plasmons to a waveguide mode, leading to sharper resonance dips and improved sensitivity.

Key methodological aspects include:

  • Symmetrical PWR (sPWR) Structure: This design, unlike conventional PWR (cPWR) or SPR, uses a dielectric layer (MgF2) as an adhesion layer and also as a top layer, creating a symmetrical configuration. This symmetry is crucial for exciting long-range surface plasmons, which have lower energy loss.
  • Kretschmann Configuration: The sensor is implemented using the well-established Kretschmann configuration for exciting surface plasmons.
  • Theoretical Modeling: The paper employs multiple reflectance theory and Fresnel formulas to calculate the total reflectance in TM mode, allowing for theoretical prediction and analysis of sensor performance.
  • Experimental Setup: A one-dimensional imaging system is used, incorporating a light source, lenses, a polarizer, and a charge-coupled device (CCD) for data acquisition. The system is designed for real-time temperature monitoring of fluid samples.
  • Thermo-Optic (TO) Coefficient Analysis: The study investigates the TO coefficients of water and the sensor materials to understand their impact on temperature measurement and to quantify the sensor's performance.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The experiments utilize deionized water and glucose solutions as samples for refractive index (RI) testing and water for temperature sensing.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Enhanced Evanescent Field and Thermal Shielding: The dielectric layer in the sPWR structure not only enhances the evanescent field for better sensitivity but also acts as a thermal shield, mitigating the background TO effect of the gold film. This is a key innovation for improving temperature measurement accuracy.
  • Improved Extinction Ratio: The sPWR structure exhibits a higher extinction ratio in its angular reflectance spectra compared to cPWR and SPR sensors. This sharper resonance dip leads to better resolution in both RI and temperature measurements.
  • Suppression of Gold Film TO Effect: The study quantifies that the resonance angle variation caused by the gold layer's TO effect is significantly smaller in the sPWR sensor (about 1% of the variation caused by water temperature) compared to SPR sensors.
  • Nonlinearity Measurement: The PWR thermometer is capable of measuring the subtle nonlinearity of the thermo-optic coefficient, a phenomenon that is difficult to observe with current optical thermometers.
  • Real-time Thermal Gradient Analysis Potential: The ability to simultaneously monitor cooling processes in different areas of the flow cell demonstrates the potential of this technology for thermal gradient analysis.

Key Results

  • RI Resolution: The sPWR sensor achieves an RI resolution of 7.9 × 10⁻⁷ RIU, which is superior to SPR and cPWR sensors.
  • Temperature Sensitivity: A temperature measurement sensitivity of 9.4 × 10⁻³ °C is achieved, comparable to high-resolution optical temperature sensors.
  • TO Coefficient of Water: The measured TO coefficient of water in the 30-40 °C range is approximately (1.37 ± 0.019) × 10⁻⁴ RIU/°C.
  • Cooling Process Measurement: The system successfully monitors water cooling processes in real-time, fitting well to Newton's cooling law, demonstrating its capability for dynamic temperature monitoring.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Film Quality Fluctuation: The paper acknowledges that the more complex film structure of the sPWR sensor can lead to larger discrepancies between theoretical and experimental results due to fluctuations in film quality during the coating process.
  • Timing Error in Cooling Experiments: Deviations in initial temperature measurements during cooling experiments are attributed, in part, to timing errors in the system.
  • Temperature Control in Different Areas: Variations in temperature control across different areas of the flow cell during cooling experiments are noted, with the middle area being easier to control due to better thermal isolation.
  • Future Work: The authors suggest that the PWR thermometer has potential for further applications in noninvasive temperature sensing and could stimulate research into new electromagnetic field-based thermometry methods. The ability to accurately measure TO coefficient nonlinearity also opens avenues for more precise temperature measurements over wider ranges.

Summary updated

Abstract

In this paper, the noninvasive and real-time plasmon waveguide resonance (PWR) thermometry is reported theoretically and demonstrated experimentally. Owing to the enhanced evanescent field and thermal shield effect of its dielectric layer, a PWR thermometer permits accurate temperature sensing and has a wide dynamic range. A temperature measurement sensitivity of 9.4 × 10−3 °C is achieved and the thermo optic coefficient nonlinearity is measured in the experiment. The measurement of water cooling processes distributed in one dimension reveals that a PWR thermometer allows real-time temperature sensing and has potential to be applied for thermal gradient analysis. Apart from this, the PWR thermometer has the advantages of low cost and simple structure, since our transduction scheme can be constructed with conventional optical components and commercial coating techniques.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{zhang2015noninvasive,
  author = {Pengfei Zhang and Le Liu and Yonghong He and Yanfei Zhou and Yanhong Ji and Hui Ma},
  title = {{Noninvasive and Real-Time Plasmon Waveguide Resonance Thermometry}},
  booktitle = {Sensors},
  year = {2015},
  url = {https://openreview.net/forum?id=UVNAHZ-Yib},
}
Figure