Non-Wire Alternatives: an Additional Value Stream for Distributed Energy Resources

Jesus E. Contreras-Ocaña, Yize Chen, Uzma Siddiqi, Baosen Zhang

Abstract

Distributed energy resources (DERs) can serve as non-wire alternatives (NWAs) to capacity expansion by managing peak load to avoid or delay traditional expansion projects. However, the value stream derived from using DERs as NWAs is usually not explicitly included in DER planning problems. In this paper, we study a planning problem that co-optimizes investment and operation of DERs and the timing of capacity expansion. By including the timing of capacity expansion as a decision variable, we naturally incorporate NWA value stream of DERs into the planning problem. Furthermore, we show that even though the resulting optimization problem could have millions of variables and is non-convex, an optimal solution can be found by solving a series of smaller linear problems. Finally, we present a NWAs planning problem using real data from the Seattle Campus of the University of Washington.

Introduction: The "Wires" vs. DERs Dilemma

When a power grid reaches its capacity limit, the traditional "wires" solution is to build new substations or install thicker cables. While reliable, these projects are capital-intensive, often facing public opposition and long regulatory hurdles. Distributed Energy Resources (DERs)—such as solar panels, energy storage, and demand response—offer a flexible alternative. By managing peak loads, DERs can potentially delay the need for massive physical infrastructure investments.

However, most planning tools treat DERs and grid expansion as separate problems, ignoring the "time-value of money." A dollar spent on a substation ten years from now is significantly cheaper than a dollar spent today. This paper introduces a framework to quantify this "hidden" economic value by treating the timing of capacity expansion as a decision variable in a robust optimization model.

Methodology: Co-Optimizing Investment and Timing

The proposed model co-optimizes three critical dimensions:

  1. Investment: Determining the optimal mix of solar, storage, and energy efficiency.
  2. Operation: Managing the hourly charging/discharging of batteries and load shifting over a 20-year horizon.
  3. Timing: Identifying the specific year to initiate traditional capacity expansion.

Co-optimizing these factors alongside hourly operations creates a massive, non-convex problem. To solve this, the authors utilize Dantzig-Wolfe Decomposition to break the problem into manageable sub-problems for each technology. Furthermore, they demonstrate that because the planning horizon is finite (e.g., 20 years), the problem can be solved by iterating through each possible expansion year, effectively transforming a non-convex problem into a series of linear ones.

Case Study: University of Washington Seattle Campus

The model was tested using real-world data from the UW Seattle Campus. Historical load data (2011–2016) was processed using Generative Adversarial Networks (GANs) to project realistic future load scenarios over a 20-year period.

Projected peak load growth over a 20-year planning horizon, showing the uncertainty and upward trend that necessitates grid expansion.

The study assumed a $100 million cost for a traditional substation upgrade, a figure typical for urban utility work. Solar irradiation data was sourced from the National Renewable Energy Laboratory (NREL) to model DER performance.

Key Results and Insights

The primary finding is that DERs do not need to entirely replace grid upgrades to be profitable; their value lies in their ability to delay them. For instance, postponing a $100M investment by five years can yield approximately $13M in present-value savings.

Robustness vs. Cost

Planners must balance reliability with cost. Using a "protection level" ($\Gamma$) approach, the model ensures the grid remains reliable even under worst-case scenarios for solar generation and load growth.

The trade-off between the protection level ($\Gamma$) and the total objective value. Higher protection levels lead to increased costs as the system prepares for more extreme scenarios.

As shown in the figure above, high protection levels ($\Gamma \approx 1$) lead to earlier expansion and heavier investment in reliable DERs like energy storage. Conversely, lower protection levels might over-rely on cheaper but variable resources like solar.

Economic Viability

Accounting for the NWA value stream can significantly alter the economic outlook of a DER project, often contributing 20% to 50% of the total project benefits. Computationally, the sequential solving technique proved highly efficient, reaching an optimal solution in less than 2.5 hours on standard hardware.

Conclusion

This research demonstrates that integrating the timing of capacity expansion into DER planning reveals significant economic benefits. While technical challenges like voltage stability and complex power flows remain for future work, the framework provides a robust method for utilities and large campuses to evaluate the true value of Non-Wire Alternatives.

Summary updated

Abstract

Distributed energy resources (DERs) can serve as non-wire alternatives (NWAs) to capacity expansion by managing peak load to avoid or delay traditional expansion projects. However, the value stream derived from using DERs as NWAs is usually not explicitly included in DER planning problems. In this paper, we study a planning problem that co-optimizes investment and operation of DERs and the timing of capacity expansion. By including the timing of capacity expansion as a decision variable, we naturally incorporate NWA value stream of DERs into the planning problem. Furthermore, we show that even though the resulting optimization problem could have millions of variables and is non-convex, an optimal solution can be found by solving a series of smaller linear problems. Finally, we present a NWAs planning problem using real data from the Seattle Campus of the University of Washington.
BibTeX
@article{contrerasocana2019non,
  author = {Jesus E. Contreras-Ocaña and Yize Chen and Uzma Siddiqi and Baosen Zhang},
  title = {{Non-Wire Alternatives: an Additional Value Stream for Distributed Energy Resources}},
  journal = {IEEE Transactions on Sustainable Energy},
  year = {2019},
  doi = {10.1109/tste.2019.2922882},
}
Figure