Non-Rayleigh photon statistics of superbunching pseudothermal light

Chaoqi Wei, Jianbin Liu, Xuexing Zhang, Rui Zhuang, Yu Zhou, Hui Chen, Yuchen He, Huaibin Zheng, Zhuo Xu

TL;DR

This paper provides the first detailed measurement of the photon number distribution for "superbunching" pseudothermal light—a classical light source where photons "clump" together even more aggressively than in standard thermal light. By modulating a laser with white noise before passing it through a rotating ground glass, the researchers demonstrated that superbunching light creates "fat-tailed" photon statistics and non-Rayleigh temporal speckles, offering a new tool for high-visibility quantum optics experiments.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

In quantum optics, the way photons are distributed in time—their "statistics"—tells us a lot about the light source. Standard thermal light (like from a star or a lightbulb) exhibits "bunching," meaning photons are more likely to arrive in pairs than randomly. This is quantified by the second-order coherence degree, $g^{(2)}(0)$, which equals 2 for thermal light.

While "pseudothermal" light (laser light scattered by a rotating ground glass) has been a workhorse for the field because its coherence time is easy to control, researchers recently developed "superbunching" sources where $g^{(2)}(0)$ can be much larger than 2. However, while the $g^{(2)}(0)$ value was known, the actual probability distribution of the photons—the "photon statistics"—hadn't been measured. Understanding this distribution is vital for applications like ghost imaging and multi-photon interference, where the "clumpiness" of the light determines the experiment's sensitivity and visibility.

Methods

The authors constructed a hybrid light source designed to push classical light beyond standard thermal limits:

  1. Intensity Modulation: They used an electro-optical modulator (EOM) driven by a white noise signal generator. This adds random intensity fluctuations to a continuous-wave laser.
  2. Phase Randomization: The modulated light was then sent through a traditional rotating ground glass (RG), which randomizes the spatial phase.
  3. Detection: They used a Hanbury Brown-Twiss (HBT) interferometer consisting of a fiber beam splitter and two single-photon detectors.
  4. Analysis: They measured the photon distribution $P(n)$ (the probability of detecting $n$ photons in a specific time window) and compared it to the theoretical geometric distribution (which describes standard Rayleigh speckles). They also calculated $g^{(2)}(0)$ directly from these photon counts to see if it matched the values measured via coincidence counting.

Datasets

As an experimental physics paper, the "datasets" consist of primary experimental measurements:

  • Photon Count Distributions: Data collected over 100,000 time windows (each 5 $\mu$s wide) for various noise voltage levels ($V_{pp}$ from 0V to 10V).
  • Coherence Functions: Temporal second-order coherence functions $g^{(2)}(\tau)$ measured via a coincidence counting system with a 165 ps time resolution.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The "Fat Tail" Effect: The most significant finding is that as superbunching increases (higher $g^{(2)}(0)$), the photon distribution deviates further from the standard geometric distribution. Specifically, it develops a "fat tail"—the probability of detecting a high number of photons in a single window is significantly higher than what is predicted for standard thermal light.
  • Non-Rayleigh Temporal Speckles: Standard pseudothermal light produces Rayleigh speckles. By adding the EOM modulation, the authors proved they could generate "non-Rayleigh" speckles in the temporal domain. This is analogous to how correlated scatterers create non-Rayleigh spatial speckles.
  • Validation of the Statistical Model: The researchers showed that the $g^{(2)}(0)$ value calculated from the photon number distribution $P(n)$ matched the value measured by the HBT interferometer. This confirms that the measured photon statistics accurately represent the physical state of the superbunching light.

Key Results

  • Control over Bunching: By increasing the peak-to-peak voltage ($V_{pp}$) of the noise driving the EOM from 0V to 10V, the researchers successfully tuned the $g^{(2)}(0)$ from 1.89 (near-thermal) to 3.12 (superbunching).
  • Distribution Shift: In the superbunching regime ($V_{pp} = 10V$), the probability of seeing 5 or 6 photons in a single window was noticeably higher than the geometric distribution baseline, even when the average photon number remained low (~0.1).
  • Consistency: Table 1 in the paper shows that the calculated $g^{(2)}_c(0)$ from photon statistics (ranging from 1.84 to 2.96) stayed consistent with the HBT-measured $g^{(2)}_m(0)$ (ranging from 1.89 to 3.12) within experimental uncertainty.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Time Window Constraints: The authors noted that their 5 $\mu$s measurement window was longer than the light's coherence time (measured at 1.28 $\mu$s and 4.63 $\mu$s). This can lead to an underestimation of the true $g^{(2)}(0)$ because the detector averages out some of the fluctuations.
  • Low Mean Photon Number: The experiments were conducted with a low average number of photons per window ($<1$). Exploring higher intensity regimes might reveal more complex statistical behaviors.
  • Application Testing: While the paper suggests these non-Rayleigh temporal speckles are useful for ghost imaging and interference, the authors did not perform those specific applications in this study. Future work could involve using this specific "fat-tailed" light to improve the signal-to-noise ratio in temporal ghost imaging.

Summary updated

Abstract

Superbunching pseudothermal light has important applications in studying the second- and higher-order interference of light in quantum optics. Unlike the photon statistics of thermal or pseudothermal light is well understood, the photon statistics of superbunching pseudothermal light has not been studied yet. In this paper, we will employ single-photon detectors to measure the photon statistics of superbunching pseudothermal light and calculate the degree of second-order coherence. It is found that the larger the value of the degree of second-order coherence of superbunching pseudothermal light is, the more the measured photon distribution deviates from the one of thermal or pseudothermal light in the tail part. The results are helpful to understand the physics of two-photon superbunching with classical light. It is suggested that superbunching pseudothermal light can be employed to generate non-Rayleigh temporal speckles.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{wei2021non,
  author = {Chaoqi Wei and Jianbin Liu and Xuexing Zhang and Rui Zhuang and Yu Zhou and Hui Chen and Yuchen He and Huaibin Zheng and Zhuo Xu},
  title = {{Non-Rayleigh photon statistics of superbunching pseudothermal light}},
  booktitle = {Chinese},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.1088/1674-1056/ac0ba9},
}

Loading related content...

Figure