Noise reduction in diffusion MRI using non-local self-similar information in joint x-q space

Geng Chen, Yafeng Wu, Dinggang Shen, Pew-Thian Yap

TL;DR

Researchers have developed XQ-NLM, a denoising algorithm for Diffusion MRI that searches for self-similar patterns across a joint 6D space (3D spatial + 3D diffusion wavevector). By using rotation-invariant features, the method can "borrow" information from similar tissue structures regardless of their orientation, significantly outperforming traditional spatial-only denoising methods.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Diffusion MRI (dMRI) is a powerful tool for mapping the brain's white matter "wiring," but it has a major weakness: noise. To see fine details, researchers use high "b-values" (stronger diffusion weighting), which causes the signal-to-noise ratio (SNR) to plummet.

The standard way to fix this is an algorithm called Non-Local Means (NLM). NLM reduces noise by finding similar "patches" in an image and averaging them. However, most NLM tools only look for matches in the 3D spatial domain ($x$-space). This is a problem for the brain's curved structures. If a fiber bundle curves, a patch at one location will look different from a patch further down the curve simply because the orientation has changed. This leads to the "rare patch effect," where the algorithm can't find enough matches, resulting in blurring or artifacts.

Methods

The authors propose extending NLM into the joint $x-q$ space. Instead of just looking at where a voxel is in the brain ($x$), they look at the diffusion wavevector ($q$), which represents the direction and magnitude of the diffusion measurement.

The key technical innovations include:

  • Spherical Patch Matching: For every point in the 6D space, they define a spherical patch in $q$-space.
  • Rotation Invariance: To match patches from structures oriented in different directions, they use Azimuthal Equidistant Projection (AEP) to flatten the spherical patch into a 2D disc, followed by a Polar Complex Exponential Transform (PCET) to extract features that don't change when the brain structure rotates.
  • Noise Adaptation: Since MRI noise isn't usually Gaussian (it follows Rician or non-central Chi distributions), they include a preprocessing step to transform the signal so the noise becomes Gaussian-distributed, making the denoising math more accurate.

Datasets

The study evaluated the method using three distinct types of data:

  1. Synthetic Data: Generated using the Phantomαs toolbox, simulating complex fiber geometries (branching, crossing, kissing) with various noise levels and coil configurations.
  2. Repeated Acquisition Data: A "gold standard" dataset created by scanning one adult 25 times and averaging the results to create a nearly noise-free reference.
  3. Multi-Shell HCP Data: Real-world, high-quality data from the Human Connectome Project.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Orientation shouldn't hide similarity: By using rotation-invariant features, the algorithm recognizes that a vertical fiber bundle and a horizontal fiber bundle of the same tissue type are "the same" for denoising purposes.
  • The Power of 6D: Moving from 3D to 6D dramatically increases the "effective sample size." When you have more potential matches to choose from, you can use a tighter matching criterion, which reduces estimation bias.
  • $q$-space is "Smoother": Diffusion signal profiles are generally smoother than spatial image intensities. This makes it easier to find reliable matches in $q$-space than in the often-jagged spatial domain.

Key Results

XQ-NLM was compared against state-of-the-art methods like Adaptive NLM (ANLM), NLSAM, and MPPCA.

  • Quantitative Gains: In synthetic tests with 10% Rician noise, XQ-NLM improved the Peak Signal-to-Noise Ratio (PSNR) by up to 6.42 dB over the next best method (NLSAM).
  • Better Physics: The method produced much more accurate Fractional Anisotropy (FA) maps and Orientation Distribution Functions (ODFs). Specifically, it eliminated the "spurious peaks" (false fiber directions) that often appear at tissue boundaries in other denoising methods.
  • Edge Preservation: Qualitatively, the images show that XQ-NLM removes "halos" and blurring around object boundaries that plague traditional NLM.

Limitations and Future Work

While the paper demonstrates superior accuracy, it notes a few areas for growth:

  • Computational Complexity: Searching a 6D space is computationally expensive. While the authors simplified the patch shapes to mitigate this, it likely remains more intensive than 3D methods.
  • Generalization: The authors suggest that this $q$-space matching strategy isn't just for denoising—it could be extended to improve other dMRI tasks like atlas building, interpolation, and image registration.
  • Noise Estimation: The accuracy of the method depends on a good estimate of the noise standard deviation; the authors used MPPCA for this, but further refinements in noise modeling could yield even better results.

Summary updated

Abstract

Diffusion MRI affords valuable insights into white matter microstructures, but suffers from low signal-to-noise ratio (SNR), especially at high diffusion weighting (i.e., b-value). To avoid time-intensive repeated acquisition, post-processing algorithms are often used to reduce noise. Among existing methods, non-local means (NLM) has been shown to be particularly effective. However, most NLM algorithms for diffusion MRI focus on patch matching in the spatial domain (i.e., x-space) and disregard the fact that the data live in a combined 6D space covering both spatial domain and diffusion wavevector domain (i.e., q-space). This drawback leads to inaccurate patch matching in curved white matter structures and hence the inability to effectively use recurrent information for noise reduction. The goal of this paper is to overcome this limitation by extending NLM to the joint x-q space. Specifically, we define for each point in the x-q space a spherical patch from which we extract rotation-invariant features for patch matching. The ability to perform patch matching across q-samples allows patches from differentially orientated structures to be used for effective noise removal. Extensive experiments on synthetic, repeated acquisition, and real data demonstrate that our method outperforms state-of-the-art methods, both qualitatively and quantitatively.
BibTeX
@article{chen2019noise,
  author = {Geng Chen and Yafeng Wu and Dinggang Shen and Pew-Thian Yap},
  title = {{Noise reduction in diffusion MRI using non-local self-similar information in joint x-q space}},
  journal = {Medical Image Analysis},
  year = {2019},
  doi = {10.1016/j.media.2019.01.006},
}

Loading related content...

Figure