NIMBus: a negative binomial regression based Integrative Method for mutation Burden Analysis

Jing Zhang, Jason Liu, Patrick D. McGillivray, Caroline Yi, Lucas Lochovsky, Donghoon Lee, Mark Gerstein

Introduction

In cancer genomics, identifying "driver" mutations—those that actively promote tumor growth—is a critical yet challenging task. The primary obstacle is the inherent "noise" of the human genome. Mutation rates are not uniform; they fluctuate significantly based on individual genetics and local genomic contexts, such as replication timing and chromatin organization.

Existing statistical models often rely on Poisson or Binomial distributions, which assume a constant mutation rate. However, real-world genomic data exhibits high variance, a phenomenon known as overdispersion. When models fail to account for this variance, they frequently flag thousands of false positives—regions that appear to be mutational hotspots but are actually just naturally high-mutation areas. NIMBus (negative binomial regression-based Integrative Method for mutation Burden analysiS) was developed to address this by accurately estimating background mutation rates to isolate true drivers.

Methodology

NIMBus introduces a novel computational framework designed to filter biological noise through advanced statistical modeling and massive data integration.

The NIMBus computational framework workflow, illustrating the preprocessing, training, and testing phases.

Statistical Modeling

Unlike standard models, NIMBus utilizes a Gamma-Poisson mixture, resulting in a Negative Binomial distribution. This approach specifically accounts for overdispersion by treating individual mutation rates as random variables rather than constants, allowing the model to better fit the observed variance in genomic data.

Feature Integration and Dimensionality Reduction

The framework incorporates 381 genomic features sourced from the ENCODE and Roadmap Epigenomics projects, including histone marks, DNA methylation, and replication timing. To manage the high dimensionality of this dataset, the researchers employed Principal Component Analysis (PCA). While the initial components capture the majority of variance, the team determined that utilizing all 381 principal components yielded the highest prediction accuracy.

Network Analysis

NIMBus extends beyond single-gene analysis. By aggregating P-values using Fisher’s method, the tool can identify entire biological pathways—such as the p53 signaling pathway—that exhibit a significant mutational burden.

Data and Benchmarking

The model was trained and validated using whole-genome sequencing (WGS) data from 649 patients across seven cancer types, including breast, lung, and gastric cancers. Benchmarking was performed against the PCAWG (PanCancer Analysis of Whole Genomes) consortium findings and the COSMIC (Catalogue of Somatic Mutations in Cancer) database.

Key Results

  • Suppression of False Positives: In lung cancer datasets where standard binomial models flagged over 6,000 genes, NIMBus narrowed the results to 11 high-confidence genes, demonstrating superior noise suppression.
  • Coding and Noncoding Drivers: The tool identified 15 significant coding genes (e.g., TP53, KRAS, ARID1A) and 1,450 noncoding regions. Notably, it pinpointed the Transcription Start Sites (TSS) for TP53 and TERT as major hotspots, regions often overlooked by tools focused solely on protein-coding sequences.
  • Tissue-Specific Performance: While the model performs optimally when genomic features match the cancer's tissue of origin, its accuracy remains high even without a perfect match due to the correlation of genomic features across different tissues.

Limitations and Future Directions

Despite its precision, NIMBus faces challenges regarding data scarcity; its sensitivity is expected to improve as more high-quality WGS data becomes available. Additionally, the current use of 1Mb "bins" for regression training requires careful calibration to avoid "zero-inflation" in low-mutation regions. Future iterations may also refine the assumption of gene independence when calculating pathway-level P-values, as genes within the same pathway often exhibit correlated mutation patterns.

Summary updated

Abstract

Background Identifying frequently mutated regions is a key approach to discover DNA elements influencing cancer progression. However, it is challenging to identify these burdened regions due to mutation rate heterogeneity across the genome and across different individuals. Moreover, it is known that this heterogeneity partially stems from genomic confounding factors, such as replication timing and chromatin organization. The increasing availability of cancer whole genome sequences and functional genomics data from the Encyclopedia of DNA Elements (ENCODE) may help address these issues. Results We developed a negative binomial regression-based Integrative Method for mutation Burden analysiS (NIMBus). Our approach addresses the over-dispersion of mutation count statistics by (1) using a Gamma–Poisson mixture model to capture the mutation-rate heterogeneity across different individuals and (2) estimating regional background mutation rates by regressing the varying local mutation counts against genomic features extracted from ENCODE. We applied NIMBus to whole-genome cancer sequences from the PanCancer Analysis of Whole Genomes project (PCAWG) and other cohorts. It successfully identified well-known coding and noncoding drivers, such as TP53 and the TERT promoter. To further characterize the burdening of non-coding regions, we used NIMBus to screen transcription factor binding sites in promoter regions that intersect DNase I hypersensitive sites (DHSs). This analysis identified mutational hotspots that potentially disrupt gene regulatory networks in cancer. We also compare this method to other mutation burden analysis methods. Conclusion NIMBus is a powerful tool to identify mutational hotspots. The NIMBus software and results are available as an online resource at github.gersteinlab.org/nimbus.
BibTeX
@article{zhang2020nimbus,
  author = {Jing Zhang and Jason Liu and Patrick D. McGillivray and Caroline Yi and Lucas Lochovsky and Donghoon Lee and Mark Gerstein},
  title = {{NIMBus: a negative binomial regression based Integrative Method for mutation Burden Analysis}},
  journal = {BMC Bioinformatics},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.1186/s12859-020-03758-1},
}
Figure