New technology must support, not restrict humaneness: a qualitative interview study on the potential influences of a new digital system on specialized outpatient palliative care

A Weisser, Natalie Öhl, Ann-Kathrin Mahlein, Joachim Peters, Martina Simon, Stephanie Schmitt-Rüth, Anastasiya Zakreuskaya, Michael Nissen, Bjoern M. Eskofier, Christoph Ostgathe, Tobias Steigleder, Maria HeckelResearch Square 2025 · DOI

Abstract

Background: Electronic health applications are playing an increasingly significant role in modern healthcare systems. Therefore, the European Union proposed GAIA-X—a digital ecosystem that facilitates data exchange and sovereign data usage. TEAM-X aims to implement GAIA-X in healthcare; this study focuses on palliative care. Especially in this vulnerable context, identifying opinions of prospective users during development ensures that their needs as well as objectives and principles of palliative care are met. This study aims to gather perceptions and expectations regarding digital technologies in specialist palliative home care, exemplified by a proposed system.

Methods: We conducted a qualitative study using semi-structured, problem-centered interviews with employees and informal caregivers in specialist palliative home care. Participants were introduced to the conceptual TEAM-X system as well as different care scenarios as impulses for possible changes and were asked about their expectations for benefits and challenges, and requirements for such a system. Transcripts were analyzed using content structuring qualitative analysis complemented by a linguistic analysis that examined personal attitudes towards technology through language patterns.

Results: Nine employees and three informal caregivers agreed to participate. Interviewees highlighted several potential benefits of the planned system, some of them addressing challenges of the current care situation, like facilitated data exchange between healthcare professionals, reduced burden on informal caregivers, and optimized care processes. Challenges included concerns about system feasibility, data handling procedures and fears that technology might compromise humaneness. Linguistic analysis revealed varying levels of technology affinity, while the relevance for care and the alignment with palliative care principles were rated mainly high. As requirements, participants emphasized the importance of maintaining humaneness in care and ensuring that technology serves as a supportive tool rather than a restrictive element.

Conclusions: Despite its conceptual nature, the TEAM-X system elicited valuable user insights, identifying both benefits and critical requirements for successful implementation. Meeting the concrete and realizable derived requirements thoroughly, such as enhancing data security, maintaining human interaction, and ensuring user-friendliness, could enable the system to support specialist palliative home care effectively. Future research should validate these findings and explore implementation in diverse healthcare contexts.

Introduction

Palliative care, particularly in specialized outpatient settings (SAPV), is a deeply sensitive field where the quality of care is inextricably linked to "humaneness"—defined by attentiveness, consideration, and interpersonal relationships. Currently, this sector faces significant logistical hurdles, including fragmented communication and a heavy reliance on paper-based documentation. These inefficiencies often force informal caregivers (family and friends) to act as "human data routers," manually relaying critical health information between various medical professionals.

The German TEAM-X project, built upon the EU’s GAIA-X sovereign data ecosystem, seeks to address these gaps. However, introducing digital tools into end-of-life care requires a delicate balance. This study explores how a proposed digital system might influence palliative care, ensuring that technology serves to enhance, rather than replace, the essential human connection.

Methods

The researchers utilized a multi-layered qualitative methodology to capture a comprehensive view of user needs. The study involved semi-structured, problem-centered interviews with a total of 12 participants: nine healthcare professionals and three informal caregivers. To stimulate discussion, participants were presented with "use case scenarios" involving common palliative tasks such as symptom monitoring and opioid prescription.

The selection of participants followed strict inclusion and exclusion criteria to ensure relevant and ethical data collection, as detailed in the table below.

Inclusion and exclusion criteria for study participants.

Data analysis was two-fold:

  1. Content Structuring Qualitative Analysis: Transcripts were coded to categorize perceived benefits, risks, and functional requirements.
  2. Interactional Linguistic Analysis: A novel approach where linguists analyzed language patterns (e.g., metaphors, agency, and technical terminology) to determine each participant's "technology affinity." This helped researchers understand how personal attitudes toward tech might influence the adoption of new systems.

Results and Key Insights

The study revealed a high perceived relevance for the TEAM-X system, with most healthcare professionals viewing "facilitated data exchange" as a primary benefit. Several key themes emerged from the interviews:

The "Subordinate Aid" Philosophy

A recurring sentiment among participants was that technology must remain a "subordinate aid." Professionals emphasized that digital systems cannot replace the nuanced clinical judgment required in palliative care—such as interpreting a patient's moan or a specific look—but should instead handle the bureaucratic "background noise."

Reclaiming Time for Care

Informal caregivers viewed the centralized system as a means to reduce their organizational burden. By automating data sharing, they hoped to "buy back" time to focus on emotional support and being present with their loved ones, rather than managing paperwork.

Concerns Over Data Sovereignty and Humaneness

Despite the benefits, fears of the "transparent patient" were prominent. There were concerns that automated data transfer might lead to a loss of control or a reductionist view of the patient. Furthermore, participants largely rejected digitalizing sensitive processes like Advance Care Planning (ACP), insisting these must remain face-to-face conversations.

Linguistic Tech Affinity

The linguistic analysis found that participants with lower tech affinity often used vague pronouns and metaphors when describing the system, viewing it as an abstract obstacle. In contrast, those with higher affinity used concrete technical nouns and saw the system as a functional tool. This suggests that implementation strategies must be tailored to the varying comfort levels of staff.

Conclusion and Future Directions

The TEAM-X system has the potential to significantly improve the efficiency of specialized outpatient palliative care by streamlining communication and reducing the burden on caregivers. However, its success depends on meeting rigorous user-defined requirements, such as offline capability for rural areas, verbal data entry to minimize screen time, and a modular design that respects data sovereignty.

While the small sample size of informal caregivers and the absence of direct patient voices are limitations, this study provides a foundational roadmap. Future work should focus on validating these findings with functional mock-ups and developing targeted training programs to bridge the gap in technology affinity among healthcare providers.

Summary updated

Abstract

<title>Abstract</title> <bold>Background</bold> Electronichealth applications are playing an increasingly significant role in modern healthcare systems. Therefore, the European Union proposed GAIA -X - a digital ecosystem that facilitates data exchange and sovereign data usage. TEAM-X aims to implement GAIA -X in healthcare, this study focuses on palliative care. Especially in this vulnerable context, identifying opinions of prospective users during development ensures that their needs as well as objectives and principles of palliative care are met. This study aims to gather perceptions and expectations regarding digital technologies in specialist palliativehome care, exemplified by a proposed system. <bold>Methods</bold> We conducted a qualitative study using semi-structured, problem-centered interviews with employees and informal caregivers in specialistpalliative home care. Participants were introduced to the conceptual TEAM-X system as well as different care scenarios as impulses for possible changes and were asked about their expectations for benefits and challenges, and requirements for such a system. Transcripts were analyzed using content structuring qualitative analysis complemented by a linguistic analysis that examined personal attitudes towards technology through language patterns. <bold>Results</bold> Nine employees and three informal caregivers agreed to participate. Interviewees highlighted several potential benefits of the planned system, some of them addressing challenges of the current care situation, like facilitated data exchange between healthcare professionals, reduced burden on informal caregivers, and optimized care processes. Challenges included concerns about system feasibility, data handling procedures and fears that technology might compromise humaneness. Linguistic analysis revealed varying levels of technology affinity, while the relevance for care and the alignment with palliative care principles were rated mainly high. As requirements, participants emphasized the importance of maintaining humaneness in care and ensuring that technology serves as a supportive tool rather than a restrictive element. <bold>Conclusions</bold> Despite its conceptual nature, the TEAM-X system elicited valuable user insights, identifying both benefits and critical requirements for successful implementation. <bold/> Meeting the concrete and realizable derived requirements thoroughly, such as enhancing data security, maintaining human interaction, and ensuring user-friendliness, could enable the system to support specialistpalliative home care effectively. Future research should validate these findings and explore implementation in diverse healthcare contexts.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{weisser2025new,
  author = {A Weisser and Natalie Öhl and Ann-Kathrin Mahlein and Joachim Peters and Martina Simon and Stephanie Schmitt-Rüth and Anastasiya Zakreuskaya and Michael Nissen and Bjoern M. Eskofier and Christoph Ostgathe and Tobias Steigleder and Maria Heckel},
  title = {{New technology must support, not restrict humaneness: a qualitative interview study on the potential influences of a new digital system on specialized outpatient palliative care}},
  booktitle = {Research Square},
  year = {2025},
  doi = {10.21203/rs.3.rs-5834363/v1},
}
Figure