CARE-HOUSE: Developing a framework for conceptualizing social implications of digital health technologies in palliative care

Natalie Oehl, Tobias Steigleder, Eva Maria Hille, Matthias Braun, A Weisser, Felix Muehlensiepen, Martin Vossiek, Bjoern M. Eskofier, Alexander Koelpin, Peter Dabrock, Cynthia C. Forbes, Christoph Ostgathe, Maria HeckelResearch Square 2025 · DOI

Introduction

The integration of digital health technologies—ranging from artificial intelligence and wearables to ambient sensors—is transforming the landscape of modern medicine. In the sensitive domain of palliative care, where the focus shifts from curing to comfort and quality of life, these technologies offer significant potential for better symptom tracking and care coordination. However, palliative care is fundamentally rooted in human connection and "Total Care," addressing physical, psychological, social, and spiritual needs. The introduction of digital tools can disrupt these delicate social dynamics in ways that are often difficult to predict or quantify.

This paper introduces the CARE-HOUSE framework, a conceptual model designed to identify and analyze the social implications of digital health technologies in palliative care settings. By providing a structured lens, the framework helps researchers and developers understand how technology reshapes relationships and care practices before these tools are fully implemented.

The Challenge: Technology in a Human-Centric Space

Palliative care relies heavily on interpersonal presence and social inclusion. As digital health tools like telehealth or sensor-based monitoring are introduced, they inevitably alter daily routines and clinical workflows. There is a growing concern among healthcare professionals that an over-reliance on technology could lead to the "dehumanization" of end-of-life care.

While the ethical and legal dimensions of medical technology are frequently scrutinized, the social implications—such as how a device changes a patient's self-perception or how it alters the definition of "being present"—have lacked a robust conceptual foundation. The CARE-HOUSE framework addresses this gap, moving beyond simple usability to explore the deeper sociological shifts triggered by digital intervention.

Methodology: A Multi-Staged Qualitative Approach

The researchers employed a sequential, qualitative research design to build the framework, ensuring it was grounded in both existing literature and the lived experiences of stakeholders. The process involved three overlapping phases:

  1. Iterative Narrative Literature Review: A comprehensive scan of existing research to identify recurring themes regarding technology's impact on palliative care.
  2. Multidisciplinary Expert Consultations: Ten sessions were held with experts, including researchers, clinicians, and patient advocates. Using digital conceptual mapping (via Miro boards), these groups visually mapped the parameters and relationships that define the social impact of technology.
  3. Focus Groups: Three distinct focus groups involving 18 participants (ranging from clinical professionals to informal caregivers) provided deep insights into the practical realities of care.

The resulting data was analyzed using qualitative structured content analysis, allowing the team to refine the framework through both deductive (theory-driven) and inductive (data-driven) coding.

The CARE-HOUSE Framework: Mapping Social Dynamics

The authors synthesized their findings into the "CARE-HOUSE" metaphor, which organizes the complex social variables of palliative care into a cohesive structure:

  • The Roof (Principles): Represents the overarching goals of palliative care, such as patient-centeredness, multiprofessional collaboration, and the relief of suffering. These serve as the benchmark for any new technology.
  • The Foundation (Context): Encompasses the broader societal norms, structural environments, and organizational cultures that influence how care is delivered.
  • The Rooms (Care Delivery): These represent the active processes of care, including specific tasks, workflows, and the interactions between different parties.
  • The Inhabitants (Actors): Crucially, the framework treats technology not just as a tool, but as an "actor" with its own characteristics and embedded values that interact with patients, families, and professionals.

Key Insights and Results

The study identified several critical areas where technology impacts the social fabric of care:

  • Technology as an Active Participant: Digital tools carry embedded moral values (e.g., a focus on data security or surveillance) that influence the care environment.
  • Shifting Roles and Self-Conception: The introduction of technology can fundamentally change how individuals view themselves. For example, a family member might feel their role shifting from a "loving companion" to an "unpaid medical technician" when tasked with managing complex monitoring equipment.
  • The "Total Care" Test: The framework posits that if a technology improves physical monitoring but inadvertently increases social isolation or reduces the quality of human interaction, it may be incompatible with the core tenets of palliative care.

Limitations and Future Directions

While the CARE-HOUSE framework provides a vital roadmap, the authors acknowledge certain limitations. The framework was developed within a specific German healthcare context, which may affect its immediate generalizability to other cultures. Additionally, the iterative nature of the methodology makes it difficult to isolate the origin of specific insights.

Future work will focus on applying the framework to specific case studies, such as comparing the social impact of ambient radar sensors versus mobile symptom-tracking apps. The ultimate goal is to link CARE-HOUSE with practical R&D tools, helping engineers and clinicians assess social risks during the design phase of new medical technologies.

Conclusion

The CARE-HOUSE framework offers a necessary bridge between technological innovation and the human-centric values of palliative care. By providing a systematic way to evaluate social implications, it ensures that the digital future of end-of-life care remains compassionate, inclusive, and deeply human.

Summary updated

Abstract

<title>Abstract</title> Background The use of digital health technologies holds potential benefits for palliative care. Their implementation is fundamentally shifting routines and care practices. These shifts entail social implications that are complex, may emerge gradually and are challenging to identify. However, the social implications of digital health technologies are not conceptualized yet. This study addresses this gap by developing a framework on the social implications of digital technologies in palliative care, where the importance of social inclusion and interpersonal connection is particularly evident. Methods We assessed the potential social implications of digital health technologies’ use in palliative care through a sequential research design using qualitative empirical methods of social research. Alongside conducting an iterative narrative literature review, we held multidisciplinary expert consultations using a conceptual mapping method and focus groups involving researchers, clinicians, and a patient and public involvement group, analyzed with qualitative structured content analysis. Results Participants as well as the literature review identified key areas to the understanding and analysis of the social implications of digital health technologies in palliative care: principles and objectives of palliative care (patient-centered care, Total care, multiprofessional collaboration, relieving suffering, improving quality of life); the various actors involved in a specific care practice; the different roles they might have; the interactions among different actors; the tasks individual actors might carry out; the processes they are involved in; and the contexts they are embedded in. These factors were summarized and set out in the CARE-HOUSE Framework to conceptualize the social implications of digital health technologies’ use in palliative care and to support researchers in assessing the impacts of these technologies. Conclusions The CARE-HOUSE Framework provides guidance for analyzing the social implications of digital health technologies in palliative care. It will be for future studies to evaluate the framework's adaptability and scalability to diverse technologies and settings.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{oehl2025care,
  author = {Natalie Oehl and Tobias Steigleder and Eva Maria Hille and Matthias Braun and A Weisser and Felix Muehlensiepen and Martin Vossiek and Bjoern M. Eskofier and Alexander Koelpin and Peter Dabrock and Cynthia C. Forbes and Christoph Ostgathe and Maria Heckel},
  title = {{CARE-HOUSE: Developing a framework for conceptualizing social implications of digital health technologies in palliative care}},
  booktitle = {Research Square},
  year = {2025},
  doi = {10.21203/rs.3.rs-5563747/v1},
}
Figure