Abstract
Amid China's pressing energy crisis and excessive investment in the new energy vehicle (NEV) sector, this study delves into the risks and challenges associated with such investments. By incorporating an analysis of micro-level individual psychology, it designs specific indicators to assess investment risks. Building on existing research and practices in investment risk assessment, the study introduces a novel framework that integrates individual psychological factors. This new system elucidates the interplay between investment risks and investor psychology, aiming to assist individual investors in making informed decisions, optimizing capital allocation, and fostering the sustainable growth of the new energy industry.
Introduction
The New Energy Vehicle (NEV) sector in China represents a critical pillar for national energy security and environmental sustainability. However, the industry currently faces significant challenges, including overcapacity, land constraints, and "blind investment" bubbles. Traditional risk assessment models often operate under the "rational agent" assumption, presupposing that investors make decisions based solely on objective data. In reality, with over 200 million individual investors in China’s capital market, psychological factors such as policy-driven hype and the "herd effect" frequently lead to valuation bubbles. This paper addresses the failure of existing models to capture these micro-level psychological drivers, which leaves individual investors vulnerable to substantial losses.
Methodology: Integrating AHP and Prospect Theory
To create a more realistic risk assessment tool, this research proposes a hybrid framework combining the Analytic Hierarchy Process (AHP) with Prospect Theory.
The Analytic Hierarchy Process (AHP)
AHP is used to decompose the complex investment decision into a hierarchical structure. It organizes the problem into three levels: the overall goal (risk assessment), secondary criteria (e.g., Technical Risks, Market Risks), and tertiary indicators (e.g., cruising range, subsidy policies). To quantify the relative importance of these indicators, experts use a standardized scale to perform pairwise comparisons.
Prospect Theory Adjustments
While AHP provides a structural foundation, Prospect Theory introduces behavioral realism through three key adjustments:
- Loss Aversion: A coefficient ($\lambda \approx 2.25$) is applied to reflect that the psychological impact of a loss is roughly twice that of an equivalent gain.
- Probability Weighting: A tuning parameter ($\gamma = 0.65$) accounts for the human tendency to overweight low-probability "black swan" events and underweight high-probability outcomes.
- Reference Dependence: Risks are evaluated relative to a specific reference point, such as current asset levels, rather than in absolute terms.
Results and Discussion
The integration of psychological parameters leads to a significant redistribution of indicator weights compared to traditional models. By applying a loss aversion coefficient, the model effectively "amplifies" the weight of risk factors that could lead to capital loss, aligning the assessment with actual human sentiment.
As shown in the adjusted weight distribution, specific indicators undergo notable shifts. For instance, in the "Technical Risks" category, the portfolio weight for "Fungibility" (the risk of technology being replaced) was adjusted from an initial 0.0316 to approximately 0.0159. This "Psychological Multiplier" ensures that the final "Expected Utility" score reflects both objective risk and the psychological comfort levels of a typical investor. Interestingly, the study chooses not to adjust indicators related to profitability and corporate strength, as these primarily involve potential gains and are less influenced by the specific loss-avoidance mechanics that drive risk-averse behavior.
Conclusion
This framework bridges the gap between traditional financial analysis and behavioral economics. By accounting for human biases like loss aversion and the herd effect, it provides a more robust decision-making tool for the volatile NEV market. While the model currently relies on static median psychological values, future work should focus on tailoring these parameters to specific market conditions and validating the framework against historical market data to enhance its predictive accuracy.
Summary updated