Reconstruction: Key to Social Responsibility Risk Assessment for Tourism Investment Projects†

Chen Lv, Xiaoyan LiJournal of Risk Analysis and Crisis Response 2021 · DOI

Abstract

Large-scale tourism investment abroad refers to the economic behavior of undertaking large-scale tourism investment projects abroad under the guidance of the host country or region government, with foreign tourism enterprise group as the main body. Characterized by large investment scale, long cycle and complex social influence, it has important use function and great social significance. In recent years, Chinese enterprises have invested more than $100 billion in 10 large-scale tourism projects abroad. The strategy of investing large-scale tourism projects abroad has become one of China's important strategies to help developing countries improve their people's livelihood, provide assistance and fulfill its international responsibilities. The proposal and implementation of the Belt and Road (B&R) Initiative provides an opportunity for the rapid development of China's large-scale tourism investment project abroad.

Introduction

When a multi-billion dollar tourism project fails, the post-mortem analysis typically focuses on economic fluctuations or technical hurdles. However, research suggests that the real "silent killers" are social responsibility (SR) risks—issues such as labor disputes, environmental mismanagement, and cultural conflicts. For instance, some Chinese cultural tourism projects in Paris have faced loss rates as high as 90%, and a $3.6 billion resort in the Bahamas recently went bankrupt due to labor issues.

Despite these high-profile failures, most investment risk models remain hyper-focused on financial metrics. There is a distinct lack of systematic, quantitative tools to measure SR risks based on international standards. This paper addresses this gap by "reconstructing" the risk assessment process specifically for the tourism sector, particularly for projects under China’s Belt and Road Initiative (B&R).

Methods

The researchers developed a quantitative evaluation model through a multi-stage process:

  1. Framework Selection: The study adopted the ISO 26000 Guidance on Social Responsibility as its foundation. This standard is part of a broader landscape of international norms designed to regulate corporate behavior globally.
International norms and standards for social responsibility
  1. Dimension Extraction: From the ISO 26000 core subjects, 21 specific "third-level" indicators were extracted, including dispute treatment, ecological restoration, and protection of vulnerable groups.
  2. Analytic Hierarchy Process (AHP): To quantify qualitative guidelines, five experts in tourism investment risk scored the relative importance of these dimensions on a scale of 1–9.
  3. Weight Calculation: Expert scores were used to calculate the "weight" or priority of each risk factor, ensuring mathematical consistency through Consistency Ratio tests.

Key Results and Insights

The application of the AHP model revealed critical insights into the lifecycle of tourism investments. Contrary to conventional wisdom, risk is heavily front-loaded and persists long after construction ends.

Hierarchical model and weight distribution for social responsibility risk assessment

The Dominance of Project Selection

The most significant finding is that Project Selection (47.93% weight) is the most critical phase for social responsibility risk. This indicates that the initial decision of where and with whom to invest—accounting for geopolitics and local domestic stability—is more hazardous than the physical implementation.

The "Follow-up" Trap

While it is often assumed that risk subsides once a project is built, the model shows that Project Follow-up Management (30.68%) carries significantly more SR risk than Project Implementation (21.39%). Managing ongoing community relations and consumer disputes is a vital long-term risk vector.

Critical Risk Indicators

Out of the 21 specific indicators, "Dispute Treatment" emerged as the single most dominant risk factor (0.0727). Other top indicators include:

  • Community Environment (0.0610)
  • Education and Awareness (0.0529)
  • Community Participation (0.0499)
  • Skills and Technology (0.0426)

These results suggest that for B&R projects to succeed, investors must shift focus from mere project completion to active relationship management throughout the investment's entire lifecycle.

Conclusion

This paper proposes a new framework for evaluating social responsibility risk in international tourism investments. By shifting the focus toward project selection and long-term management, the model provides a more comprehensive view of the "soft" risks that often lead to project failure.

However, the study has limitations. The model relies on the AHP method, which is based on subjective expert scoring. Additionally, the theoretical model requires further empirical validation through real-time case studies of ongoing B&R projects. Future work will focus on applying this model to specific projects and integrating more objective, data-driven quantitative methods to reduce potential expert bias.

† This paper summarizes research on social responsibility risk assessment for large-scale tourism investment projects.

Summary updated

Abstract

Large-scale tourism investment abroad refers to the economic behavior of undertaking large-scale tourism investment projects abroad under the guidance of the host country or region government, with foreign tourism enterprise group as the main body. Characterized by large investment scale, long cycle and complex social influence, it has important use function and great social significance. In recent years, Chinese enterprises have invested more than $100 billion in 10 large-scale tourism projects abroad. The strategy of investing large-scale tourism projects abroad has become one of China's important strategies to help developing countries improve their people's livelihood, provide assistance and fulfill its international responsibilities [1]. The proposal and implementation of the Belt and Road (B&R) Initiative provides an opportunity for the rapid development of China's large-scale tourism investment project abroad. In 2017, Dalian Wanda Group invested as much as $10 billion in Malaysia's Dama City tourism investment project and India's Haryana Industrial City project.
BibTeX
@article{lv2021reconstruction,
  author = {Chen Lv and Xiaoyan Li},
  title = {{Reconstruction: Key to Social Responsibility Risk Assessment for Tourism Investment Projects†}},
  journal = {Journal of Risk Analysis and Crisis Response},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.2991/jracr.k.210111.002},
}
Figure