Neutrinoless double beta decay in the minimal type-I seesaw model: mass-dependent nuclear matrix element, current limits and future sensitivities

Dong-Liang Fang, Yufeng Li, Y. Y. Zhang, Jingyu Zhu

Introduction

The origin of neutrino mass remains one of the most compelling mysteries in particle physics. While the Standard Model originally treated neutrinos as massless, oscillation experiments have confirmed they possess tiny, non-zero masses. The Type-I Seesaw mechanism offers an elegant solution to this discrepancy by introducing heavy, right-handed neutrinos (RHNs). If these neutrinos are Majorana fermions—meaning they are their own antiparticles—they would facilitate the extremely rare process of neutrinoless double beta decay ($0\nu\beta\beta$). Observing this decay would not only confirm the Majorana nature of neutrinos but also provide a window into the physics of the early universe.

The Challenge of Nuclear Matrix Elements

To translate experimental half-life limits of $0\nu\beta\beta$ into physical constraints on neutrino parameters, researchers require precise Nuclear Matrix Elements (NMEs). Traditionally, NMEs are calculated in two asymptotic limits: the "light" limit (where neutrino mass $m \ll 100$ MeV) and the "heavy" limit ($m \gg 100$ MeV). However, when RHN masses are comparable to the momentum transfer of the decay process (approximately 100 MeV), these approximations fail.

This research addresses this "middle ground" by employing mass-dependent NMEs. Using the deformed Quasi-particle Random Phase Approximation (dQRPA), the authors perform explicit many-body calculations across a broad mass range. For other established nuclear models—such as the Interacting Boson Model (IBM-2), Covariant Density Functional Theory (CDFT), and the Interacting Shell Model (ISM)—an interpolation framework is utilized to bridge the light and heavy regimes, ensuring a consistent treatment of the transition region where the NME typically peaks.

Experimental Analysis and Current Limits

The study performs a comprehensive statistical analysis by combining data from the leading $0\nu\beta\beta$ experiments. This includes $^{76}$Ge-based data from GERDA and MAJORANA, $^{130}$Te-based results from CUORE, and $^{136}$Xe-based constraints from KamLAND-Zen and EXO-200. Using a $\chi^2$ fit, the authors derive $3\sigma$ exclusion regions for RHN mass and mixing parameters.

A key insight is the "peak" phenomenon observed in the exclusion plots. Around an RHN mass of 200 MeV, a distinct peak appears where the effective Majorana mass becomes less sensitive to mixing parameters due to a degeneracy in the seesaw formula. Currently, KamLAND-Zen provides the most stringent bounds, pushing half-life limits into the $10^{25}\text{--}10^{26}$ year range and limiting the effective Majorana neutrino mass to between 50 meV and several eV, depending heavily on the chosen nuclear model.

Future Sensitivities and Model Uncertainty

The paper also projects the discovery potential of next-generation experiments over a ten-year exposure period. Detectors such as LEGEND-1000 ($^{76}$Ge), SuperNEMO ($^{82}$Se), SNO+II ($^{130}$Te), and nEXO ($^{136}$Xe) are poised to probe the entire Inverted Mass Ordering (IMO) region. If no signal is found, a large swath of the minimal type-I seesaw parameter space will be excluded.

However, the interpretation of these results remains hindered by theoretical uncertainties. The spread between different nuclear models (e.g., CDFT vs. ISM) can reach an order of magnitude, representing the primary bottleneck in the field. Furthermore, the "quenching" of the axial-vector coupling constant ($g_A$) and the influence of short-range correlations (SRC) remain significant sources of potential error that could shift results by a factor of two or more.

Conclusion

By integrating mass-dependent NMEs into the analysis of the minimal Type-I seesaw model, this work provides a more accurate mapping of the RHN parameter space. While current experiments already constrain significant portions of the theory, the next generation of $0\nu\beta\beta$ searches will either discover the Majorana nature of neutrinos or force a move toward more complex models beyond the minimal seesaw framework.

Summary updated

Abstract

In this work we discuss the neutrino mass dependent nuclear matrix element (NME) of the neutrinoless double beta decay process and derive the limit on the parameter space of the minimal Type-I seesaw model from the current available experimental data as well as the future sensitivities from the next-generation experiments. Both the explicit many-body calculations and naive extrapolations of the mass dependent NME are employed in the current work. The uncertainties of the theoretical nuclear structure models are taken into account. By combining the latest experimental data from $^{76}$Ge-based experiments, GERDA and MAJORANA, the $^{130}$Te-based experiment, CUORE and the $^{136}$Xe-based experiments, KamLAND-Zen and EXO-200, the bounds on the parameter space of the minimal Type-I seesaw model are obtained and compared with the limits from other experimental probes. Sensitivities for future experiments utilizing $^{76}$Ge-based (LEGEND-1000), $^{82}$Se-based (SuperNEMO), $^{130}$Te based (SNO+II) and $^{136}$Xe-based (nEXO), with a ten-year exposure, are also derived.
BibTeX
@article{fang2024neutrinoless,
  author = {Dong-Liang Fang and Yufeng Li and Y. Y. Zhang and Jingyu Zhu},
  title = {{Neutrinoless double beta decay in the minimal type-I seesaw model: mass-dependent nuclear matrix element, current limits and future sensitivities}},
  journal = {Journal of High Energy Physics},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.1007/jhep08(2024)217},
}

Loading related content...

Figure